Guided reading
The Binnan Industrial Park EIA hearing was the statutory hearing of the second-stage environmental impact assessment of the Binnan Industrial Park development plan, held by the Industrial Development Bureau of the Ministry of Economic Affairs on December 9, 1997, in the auditorium of Jhaoming Junior High School, Qigu Township, Tainan County; 33 people spoke 41 times, mostly in opposition.R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved(None, or not applicable)Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.
- Evidence mix
Where to start reading
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
Relationship map
People involved2323
The Binnan Industrial Park EIA hearing was the statutory hearing of the second-stage environmental impact assessment of the Binnan Industrial Park (濱南工業區) development plan, held on December 9, 1997, by the Industrial Development Bureau of the Ministry of Economic Affairs (經濟部工業局) under Article 12 of the Environmental Impact Assessment Act in the auditorium of Jhaoming Junior High School (昭明國中), Qigu Township, Tainan County, and chaired by Chang Fan (張璠), head of the bureau's Fifth Division R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.. Secondhand account The supporting and opposing sides each put forward ten speakers, and in the end 33 people spoke 41 times; by the thesis author's count, 22 statements opposed the plan and 4 supported it, and 22 questioned flaws in the EIA procedure R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.R002SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 93、97–98、104、108 [pp. 93, 97–98, 104, 108]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93、97–98、104、108Chapter 5: statistics on numbers of speakers, positions and lines of argument (the thesis author's content analysis). The thesis text counts 9 neutral statements, while its Table 5-7 gives 15.. A newspaper reported that the two sides mobilized about six hundred and more than a thousand residents respectively R004SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁),《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"](國立中山大學政治學研究所在職專班 [In-Service Master's Program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2005),頁 99 [p. 99]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 99Note 198, citing the United Daily News, 1997-12-10. The mobilization figures are cited by Tsai Lung-yu's thesis from the United Daily News of 1997-12-10.. The full record of the hearing is in Appendix 4 of Kuo Hsien-ming's (郭憲銘) master's thesis R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.. Secondhand account
Course of events
First items: Time: 1997-12-09 (the heading of the rec…Place: auditorium of Jhaoming Junior Hig…Chair: Chang Fan (張璠), director of the F…MoreLess
- Time: 1997-12-09 (the heading of the record is misprinted as 「民國八十六年時二月九日」, i.e. "ROC year 86, shi [for shi'er, twelfth] month, 9th day"), from 9:30 to 11:50 a.m. R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.. Secondhand account
- Place: auditorium of Jhaoming Junior High School (昭明國中), Qigu Township (七股鄉), Tainan County R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.. Secondhand account
- Chair: Chang Fan (張璠), director of the Fifth Division, Industrial Development Bureau, Ministry of Economic Affairs R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.. Secondhand account
- Developers: Yieh Loong Enterprise (燁隆企業) and Great East Asia Petrochemical (大東亞石化); the briefing was given by Hung Chiu-huang (洪秋煌), a manager at CTCI Corporation (中鼎工程公司) R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.. Secondhand account
- Procedure: the chair said the hearing was being held under Article 12 of the EIA Act, that all opinions would be recorded and answered by the developers before being sent to the Environmental Protection Administration for review, and that 「我們剛剛有協調贊成和反對者各推十位來發言」 ("we have just arranged for the supporters and the opponents each to put forward ten people to speak"); written opinions could be submitted within ten days after the meeting R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks.. Secondhand account
- The scene: the United Daily News of 1997-12-10 reported that the opposing side, the 「反七輕、反煉鋼廠行動聯盟」 ("Action Alliance Against the Seventh Naphtha Cracker and the Steel Mill"), and the supporting side, the 「大七股地區整體開發住民權益促進會」 ("Greater Qigu Area Comprehensive Development Residents' Rights Promotion Association"), mobilized about six hundred and more than a thousand residents respectively to attend, each hanging their own banners, and 「雙方不斷對陣叫罵與爭執不斷」 ("the two sides kept facing off, hurling abuse and quarreling without end") R004SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁),《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"](國立中山大學政治學研究所在職專班 [In-Service Master's Program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2005),頁 99 [p. 99]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 99Note 198, citing the United Daily News, 1997-12-10. The mobilization figures are cited by Tsai Lung-yu's thesis from the United Daily News of 1997-12-10.. Secondhand account
Statements
First items: Statistics on the statements (the thesis author's content analysis)MoreLess
The identities below follow the meeting record; what was said is the personal statement of each speaker, and the thesis did not verify accusations of bribery, collusion, violence and the like R003SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 96–97、145–172 [pp. 96–97, 145–172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 96–97、145–172Table 5-1 and the individual statements in Appendix 4.. Secondhand account
- Wang Yen-tsung (王燕宗) (chief of Kunshen Village, Jiangjun Township): opened by protesting that no briefing session had been held in Qingkunshen, and later spoke formally.
- Hsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) (professor at National Taiwan University): pointed out that the developers had not followed the scoping guidance table, and that 「程序有嚴重的瑕疵」 ("the procedure has serious flaws"); in his second statement he said 「四年來我們所反對的意見超過六萬字,開發單位都不予理會」 ("over four years our objections have run to more than sixty thousand characters, and the developers have ignored them all").
- Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智) (legislator): spoke three times, on compensation, flooding and health, and finally demanded that the police return the keys of a campaign vehicle taken the day before.
- Wu Chung-chang (吳仲常) (general secretary of the Qigu Township promotion association): spoke twice.
- Lin Shang-wu (林上武) (president of the Qigu Township Village Chiefs' Association): in favor; asked for generous compensation.
- Chen Chi-ming (陳啟明) (Qigu township chief): put forward a compensation formula of NT$2.5 million per jia.
- Chou Kun-tsung (周昆宗): asked that compensation be settled clearly first.
- Chou Tzu-hai (周賜海) (Qigu township representative, speaking for the township council): respected the EPA and the Industrial Development Bureau, and asked for better communication and protection of the fishermen's rights.
- Chen Cheng-hua (陳正華) (Jiangjun township representative): Qingkunshen 「沒有一尺一寸可以發展的餘地」 ("has not a foot or an inch of room left to develop").
- Fang Lung-sheng (方隆盛) (Tainan county councilor, speaking for the county council): in favor; hoped development would bring the population back.
- Chou Kuo-chen (周國珍): criticized the process as a black box.
- An unnamed protester: 「陳唐山贊成開發,陳唐山得票數才會麼多。」 ("Only because Chen Tang-shan supports development did Chen Tang-shan get so many votes.")
- Chen Jung-chi (陳榮棋) (village chief): asked for compensation on behalf of farmers.
- Chou Chi-ching (周吉靜): said that the day before, they had been left covered in injuries.
- Chou Kuo-pin (周國彬) (fishermen's representative of the Tainan County District Fishermen's Association): questioned why the oceanographic survey had been conducted for only one year.
- Wang Hui-sheng (王惠生) (Tainan County Fishing Rights Association, resident of Qingkunshen): spoke twice, and asked for a referendum of residents within three kilometers.
- Hsu Kuo-chia (許國家) (Qigu township representative): in favor of development.
- Chou Chin-chih (周金至): called on by the chair; the record notes 「周先生沒有發言,而陳朝來發言」 ("Mr. Chou did not speak; Chen Chao-lai spoke instead").
- Chen Chao-lai (陳朝來): 「八十三年反對七輕和大煉鋼廠,反四年了,不曾聽到財團真正誠懇地和漁民溝通」 ("We have opposed the seventh naphtha cracker and the big steel mill since [ROC year] 83; we've been opposing it for four years, and never once have we heard the conglomerates communicate with the fishermen truly sincerely").
- Huang Jung-cheng (黃榮政) (speaker of the Qigu Township Council): 「代表會完全支持濱南工業區的開發」 ("the council fully supports the development of the Binnan Industrial Park").
- Chen Chiang-shui (陳江水) (Qingkunshen Protest Committee): opposed.
- Yu Jung-ho (余榮和) (Tainan county councilor): called on, not present.
- Wu Jung-hua (吳榮華) (chief of Dacheng Village): citing the compensation given for an incinerator as an example, demanded that the compensation figure be stated.
- Huang Ming-chin (黃銘欽) (professor at National Cheng Kung University): spoke three times, asking why the Industrial Development Bureau was in such a hurry to hold the site inspection; someone in the crowd said 「若要質詢就請他去國會質詢」 ("if he wants to interpellate, let him go and do it in the legislature").
- Chen Wen-chi (陳文淇): said that their ancestors had fished here for nearly four hundred years.
- Huang Wei-che (黃偉哲) (National Assembly delegate): 「我們甘願有國際機場的發展,我們甘願有觀光區的發展,但重污染性的工業,我們必須要慎重」 ("We would gladly accept the development of an international airport, we would gladly accept the development of a tourist area, but with heavily polluting industry we must be cautious").
- Li Ching-hsin (李敬新) (Qingkunshen Coastal Fishermen's Self-Help Association) and Hsieh Kuo-hua (謝國華): called on; the record shows no statement.
- Lin Ming-te (林明德) (vice president of the Qingkunshen Coastal Fishermen's Self-Help Association): respected the government's policy, and asked for environmental protection and compensation in return.
- Hsieh Kuo-huang (謝國煌) (president of the Taiwan Association of University Professors, professor in the Department of Chemical Engineering, National Taiwan University): Binnan would endanger the electronics industry of the Southern Taiwan Science Park.
- Wang Wang-en (汪旺恩) (member of the Anti–Seventh Naphtha Cracker Action Committee): 「我是為了七輕被殺了十一刀的汪旺恩」 ("I am Wang Wang-en, who was stabbed eleven times over the seventh naphtha cracker"); the chair interjected a name, Chou Ching-po (周清波), whose identity the record does not give.
- Wu Wan-chang (吳萬長) (vice president of the Qigu Coastal Protection Association) and Wu Tzu-jen (吳賜仁) (Coastal Protection Association).
- Chou Kuo-lung (周國龍) (county council candidate), Huang Chien-chin (黃千金) (general secretary of the Qigu Lagoon Promotion Association), Chen Chin-hua (陳進華) (Xuejia), Chen Jung-hua (陳榮華) (Qigu township resident), and Huang Te-yu (黃得友) (vice president of the Qigu Lagoon National Park Promotion Association).
- The chair's closing remarks: 「再次感謝保五總隊很多同仁。我們也謝謝黃副分局長、昭明國中、機關代表及委員來參加這次的活動」 ("Thanks once again to the many colleagues of the Fifth Special Police Corps. We also thank Deputy Precinct Chief Huang, Jhaoming Junior High School, the agency representatives and the committee members for taking part in this event") R001SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 142、145、167、172 [pp. 142, 145, 167, 172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 142、145、167、172Appendix 4, the meeting record: heading, chair's opening remarks, closing remarks..
Statistics on the statements (the thesis author's content analysis)
- In total, 33 people spoke 41 times: 6 elected representatives, 3 experts and scholars, 20 local residents and 4 environmental groups R002SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 93、97–98、104、108 [pp. 93, 97–98, 104, 108]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93、97–98、104、108Chapter 5: statistics on numbers of speakers, positions and lines of argument (the thesis author's content analysis). The thesis text counts 9 neutral statements, while its Table 5-7 gives 15.. Secondhand account
- Positions: 22 statements of opposition, 4 of support, 9 neutral (another count gives 15) and 6 other R002SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 93、97–98、104、108 [pp. 93, 97–98, 104, 108]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93、97–98、104、108Chapter 5: statistics on numbers of speakers, positions and lines of argument (the thesis author's content analysis). The thesis text counts 9 neutral statements, while its Table 5-7 gives 15.. Secondhand account
- Lines of argument: procedural flaws 22 times, emotional statements 17, compensation 15, residents' livelihoods 14, environmental protection 10, economic development 8 R002SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 93、97–98、104、108 [pp. 93, 97–98, 104, 108]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93、97–98、104、108Chapter 5: statistics on numbers of speakers, positions and lines of argument (the thesis author's content analysis). The thesis text counts 9 neutral statements, while its Table 5-7 gives 15.. Secondhand account
Differing accounts
- The thesis author considers that, since the developers had no obligation to respond on the spot when the public raised questions, such a hearing 「僅能視為單向意見表達之『意見發表會』」 ("can only be regarded as a one-way 'opinion-airing session'") R005SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 110–111、118 [pp. 110–111, 118]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 110–111、118Conclusions of Chapter 5 (the thesis author's views).. Secondhand account
- Most of those present questioned why, with the EIA procedure not yet completed, the site inspection and hearing were being held in such a hurry R002SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 93、97–98、104、108 [pp. 93, 97–98, 104, 108]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93、97–98、104、108Chapter 5: statistics on numbers of speakers, positions and lines of argument (the thesis author's content analysis). The thesis text counts 9 neutral statements, while its Table 5-7 gives 15.. Secondhand account
- Whether a briefing session had been held in Qingkunshen: Wang Yen-tsung and Chen Cheng-hua said no; Chen Chao-lai said 「在青鯤身的說明會中……結果十二分鐘的說明」 ("at the briefing session in Qingkunshen... in the end it was a twelve-minute briefing"), and Chen Chiang-shui said 「已故的郭董也曾到青鯤鯓辦說明會」 ("the late Chairman Kuo also came to Qingkunshen to hold a briefing session"). The thesis does not clarify whether these refer to the statutory briefing session R003SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 96–97、145–172 [pp. 96–97, 145–172]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 96–97、145–172Table 5-1 and the individual statements in Appendix 4.. Secondhand account
- When interviewed in 2003, supporters and opponents alike said 「環評程序真的拖太久了」 ("the EIA procedure really dragged on far too long") R005SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系 [Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2003),頁 110–111、118 [pp. 110–111, 118]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 110–111、118Conclusions of Chapter 5 (the thesis author's views).. Secondhand account
See also
- Binnan Industrial Park⚖︎A 1990s petrochemical and steel industrial park project at QiguContains 73 items
- Qigu Jhaoming Junior High School⚖︎Private substitute junior high school in Dacheng Village, QiguContains 2 items
- Binnan Industrial Park EIA Site Survey Clash (1997)The EIA site-survey clash in front of the Qigu Township Office
- 1987 to present・Postwar officialsChang FanIndustrial Development Bureau official who chaired the Binnan EIA inspection
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansKuo Hsien-mingThe researcher who compiled the record of the Binnan EIA hearing
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsWang Yen-tsungChief of Kunshen Village, Jiangjun Township
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsChen Chi-mingMayor of Qigu Township during the Binnan case
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsFang Lung-shengFormer Tainan County councilor
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsChou Tzu-haiFormer county councilor for Qigu, Jiali and Xigang
- 1987 to present・People in major eventsChen Chao-laiFormer Tainan City councilor
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsHuang Wei-cheMayor of Tainan and former legislator
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansHuang Ming-chinNCKU statistics professor and convener of the Taiwan Coast Protection Association
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansHsieh Chih-chengAuthor of The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsSu Huan-chih⚖︎Former Tainan County Magistrate and legislator, an initiator of the opposition to Binnan
- 1987 to present・People in major eventsWang Wang-enVice-chairman of the anti-naphtha-cracker action committee
- Binnan Industrial Park scoping meetingsFive meetings that ruled out the area east of the West Coast Expressway
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersChen Chiang-shuiMember of the Qingkunshen protest committee
- 1987 to present・People in major eventsChen Chin-huaAn opponent from Xuejia
- 1987 to present・People in major eventsChen Jung-huaQigu resident who spoke at the Binnan EIA hearing
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsChen Jung-chiVillage chief, speaker at the Binnan EIA hearing
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersChen Wen-chi (陳文淇)Speaker at the Binnan EIA hearing
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsChen Cheng-hua (陳正華)Jiangjun Township council representative
- 1987 to present・Doctors, lawyers and other professionalsHung Chiu-huangManager at CTCI Corporation
- 1987 to present・Community groupsHuang Te-yuVice-chairman of the Lagoon National Park Promotion Association
- 1987 to present・Community groupsHuang Chien-chinSecretary-general of the Qigu Lagoon Promotion Association
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsHuang Jung-chengPro-development chairman of the Qigu township council
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersLin Ming-te (Qingkunshen Coastal Fishermen's Self-Help Association)Vice president of the Qingkunshen fishermen's self-help association
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsLin Shang-wuPresident of the Qigu Township Village Chiefs' Association
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersWang Hui-shengThe Qingkunshen villager who demanded a referendum within three kilometers
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersWu Tzu-jenQigu fisher, member of the Qigu Coastal Protection Association
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsWu Jung-huaThe Dacheng village chief who demanded a compensation figure
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersWu Wan-changVice-chairman of the Qigu Coastal Protection Association
- 1987 to present・Community groupsWu Chung-changOfficer of the Qigu Development Promotion Association
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansHsieh Kuo-huangProfessor of chemical engineering at National Taiwan University
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsHsu Kuo-chia (許國家)Qigu Township council representative
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsYu Jung-hoFormer Tainan County councilor for Qigu, Jiali and Xigang
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersChou Kuo-pinThe fishermen's representative who questioned the oceanographic survey
- 1987 to present・Elected representatives and officialsChou Kuo-lung (周國龍)County council candidate at the Binnan hearing
- 1987 to present・People in major eventsChou Kuo-chenThe hearing speaker who denounced backroom dealing
- 1987 to present・People in major eventsChou Chi-chingThe resident who said Chou Chi-ching was covered in injuries the day before
- 1987 to present・Fishers, fish farmers and farmersChou Kun-tsungSpeaker at the Binnan EIA hearing
Reports that mention it
Hall of the Present6.5Present conditions and institutions / Industrial parks and pollution
The Binnan Industrial Park: The 16 Years It Was Held Back
A single development project merged from two conglomerates, two purposes, and one dedicated industrial port: proposed in 1993, passed its EIA in 1999, finalized by notice in 2006, and ended in 2009 through the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act — not because the EIA was overturned.
Continue from here
- Qigu: other EventsBinnan Industrial Park⚖︎A 1990s petrochemical and steel industrial park project at QiguContains 73 items
- Located inQigu Jhaoming Junior High School⚖︎Private substitute junior high school in Dacheng Village, QiguContains 2 items
- Entries in the same hallTaiwan Alkali Anshun Plant⚖︎A former chlor-alkali plant and Taiwan's pollution site No. 1Contains 28 items