Topic · Faith

The orthodoxy dispute

Religious life in Tuchengzi centers on the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple and extends outward to the Luermen Tianhou Temple, the Sicao Dazhong Temple, and the temples of Anping and Annan District. This section covers the history of each temple, the origins of its deities, temple property, and the orthodoxy dispute over Luermen Mazu.

Click a name to open its page; press + / − to expand or collapse.

Explore further

Hall of Faith3.2

The Orthodoxy Dispute

A survey in 1956 opened nearly a decade of debate; and the most even-handed piece of evidence today is that the two sides' Qing-dynasty stele inscriptions are preserved, one each, in the two temples that now stand opposed.

653

Hall of Faith3.2b

The Orthodoxy Dispute: Sixty Years of Debate between Two Luermen Mazu Temples

On the north bank of the Luermen River stands the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple, and on the south bank the Luermen Tianhou Temple; both say they carry on the incense lineage of the Qing-dynasty old Luermen Mazu Temple. Beginning with a survey in 1956, press conferences, petitions, official documents and special newspaper issues followed one after another. The two sides' own words are quoted as they were and set alongside scholars and official documents; this site does not adjudicate.

24129

Hall of Faith3.2c

1661: Koxinga Enters Taijiang through Luermen

On a foggy morning at the end of April 1661, several hundred junks appeared outside the Luermen channel. Koxinga went ashore first by small boat to survey the ground, the fleet sailed into Taijiang on the tide, and that evening the main force landed at Heliao Harbor north of Chikan. This page compares, passage by passage, the campaign record of Yang Ying on the Zheng side with the day-by-day journal kept in the Dutch castle, and explains where these places are today and which matters the historical sources cannot settle.

1456

Events under this level

  • 1623Dutch East India Company shipwrecks in the old Taijiang Inner Sea (1623–1661)⚖︎The Dutch East India Company shipwrecks in the old Taijiang Inner Sea are the VOC ships that sank in the waters of the Taijiang Inner Sea and Tayouan between 1623 and 1661; Fu Chiung-hui and colleagues compiled fourteen from the records, most of which went down around Beixianwei and Luermen.
  • 1661Battle of Baxemboy (1661)⚖︎The Battle of Baxemboy (北線尾之戰) was the clash on May 1, 1661, between the Dutch East India Company garrison and the army of Koxinga on the Baxemboy (Beixianwei) sandbar; Captain Thomas Pedel (called Bat-kui-a, 拔鬼仔, in Zheng sources) led a sortie of some two hundred men or more out of Fort Zeelandia and was routed by the troops of Xuanyi Vanguard Garrison commander Chen Ze; Thomas Pedel and more than a hundred soldiers were killed.
  • 1661The Koxinga–Dutch War (1661–1662)⚖︎The Koxinga–Dutch War was the war of 1661–1662 between the forces of Koxinga and the Dutch East India Company in the Taijiang area; Koxinga's army entered Taijiang through the Luermen channel and besieged Fort Zeelandia for about nine months, and on February 1, 1662, Governor of Formosa Frederick Coyett signed a treaty and surrendered.
  • 1958The 1958 Break in Incense Ties⚖︎The 1958 Break in Incense Ties refers to the rift between Tucheng and Xigang during the 1958 Wuxu cycle of the Xigang incense procession, after which Tucheng's Bao'an Temple and its neighborhoods withdrew from the Xigang procession and held their own Tuchengzi procession from 1961; six versions of the cause circulate.
  • 1993Sealing Ceremony (Fengyin Dadian)The Sealing Ceremony (Fengyin Dadian) is the Luermen Tianhou Temple's deity send-off rite held at dawn on the 24th day of the 12th lunar month each year, first held in 1993: the sealing minister wraps and seals the temple seal, the round-altar envoy closes the altar at the Qinian Altar, and finally the God of Joy command token is burned to send off the gods.
  • 1993Luermen Tianhou Temple Cultural FestivalThe Luermen Tianhou Temple Cultural Festival is the annual cultural event of the Luermen Tianhou Temple, founded in 1993 under the leadership of the chairperson Lin Hsien-yang; the Lunar New Year "Mazu Year" rites of sending off and welcoming the gods grew out of it.
  • 1993Deity Send-off and Welcoming Rites of the Luermen Tianhou TempleThe Deity Send-off and Welcoming Rites of the Luermen Tianhou Temple are the rites of sending off the gods (the Sealing Ceremony) and receiving them (the Grand Ceremony of Welcoming the God of Joy) held by the Luermen Tianhou Temple around the Lunar New Year; begun in 1993, they were registered as Tainan City folklore in 2013.
  • 2005Taijiang Welcoming-the-Deities FestivalThe Taijiang Welcoming-the-Deities Festival is the procession of the Luermen Mazu held irregularly by the Luermen Tianhou Temple, chiefly covering the sixteen liao of Taijiang; it was first held in 2005, for the second time in 2012 and for the third in 2021.
  • 2017Lantern Festival Fireworks and the Spring Ox Welcoming⚖︎The Lantern Festival Fireworks and the Spring Ox Welcoming are folk events held each year from the New Year to the Lantern Festival by the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple, comprising the spring ox parade, the whipping and touching of the spring ox, and high-altitude fireworks and beehive fireworks around the temple; the "Tuchengzi Spring Ox Welcoming" was registered in 2017 as a Tainan intangible cultural heritage folk custom.
  • 2024Sanjiao Inviting-the-Deities Jiao RitualThe Sanjiao Inviting-the-Deities Jiao Ritual is a preliminary rite of the Tuchengzi Incense Procession of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple, in which friendly temples are visited before the xiangke and their deities invited to witness the jiao; at the Jiachen-year invitation on April 6, 2024, the temple's Zhendian Second Mazu entered the prefectural city and gathered with the Sanjiao temples of Tainan as the "five Sanjiao temples."
  • Rescue of the Luermen Mazu during the Kominka periodThe rescue of the Luermen Mazu in the Kominka period was the event, late in Japanese rule, in which Tucheng villagers carved a stand-in Mazu and, with insiders at the town office, swapped back on a rainy night the Bao'an Temple's principal Dama image that had been confiscated for burning, hiding it until after the war.
  • Grand Ceremony of Welcoming the God of JoyThe Grand Ceremony of Welcoming the God of Joy is the Luermen Tianhou Temple's ceremony for receiving the gods, held each year at the Qinian Altar on the morning of the 4th day of the Lunar New Year, in which the year's God of Joy (a God of Wealth) is welcomed with an official-style rite of three offerings accompanied by music and dance.
  • The Dispute over the Orthodoxy of the Luermen Mazu⚖︎The dispute over the orthodoxy of the Luermen Mazu is the long-running debate in which the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple of Tucheng and the Luermen Tianhou Temple of Xiangong each claim to have inherited the incense lineage of the Qing-period Old Luermen Mazu Temple.

See all events in the Chronicle

Unresolved questions

Site-wide list of open questions