Xigang Huang–Guo feud

Scholarly viewSecondhand accountUnverified
300

Verification status of the entries on this page

  • Verified
  • Partially verified
  • Not covered by sources
  • Verified: the source was found and checked
  • Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

Guided reading

The Xigang Huang–Guo feud was an armed feud between the Huang and Guo surnames on the Zengwen River floodplain of Xigangzai Bao in the early Japanese period, lasting thirteen years and remembered in the saying 「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」; the rivalry survives in the headband factions and sedan-order rules of the Xigang Incense Procession.R001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).

Evidence mix
Verification
  • ✓ Verified 3
  • ◑ Partially verified 0
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources 0
Source type
  • Scholarly view 10
  • Secondhand account 2
  • Unverified 1
✓ ◑ ⊗
  • ✓ Verified: the source was found and checked
  • ◑ Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.

The Xigang Huang–Guo feud (西港黃郭械鬥) was an armed feud between the Huang and Guo surnames on the Zengwen River floodplain of Xigangzai Bao in the early Japanese period; it lasted thirteen years and is remembered in the saying 「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」 ("the Huang and Guo of Xigangzai killed each other for thirteen winters") R001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).. Scholarly view Its distant cause was a grudge from the Daoguang years, when Guo settlers refused to reclaim land jointly with Huang settlers, and its immediate cause a boundary dispute between Shuzijiao (Huang) and Dawenliao (Guo); each side lost more than ten people "in battle" R001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).R002Source本站研究檔 V8-11〈械鬥、爭地與廟際衝突〉[this site's research file V8-11, "Armed Feuds, Land Disputes and Conflicts between Temples"]:楊書濠引黃文博《南瀛地名誌—北門區卷》(1998)黃郭械鬥原文與「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」俗諺 [Yang Shu-hao (楊書濠) quoting the original text on the Huang–Guo feud and the saying 「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」 from Huang Wen-po's 《南瀛地名誌—北門區卷》 (Nanying Place Names: Beimen District Volume) (1998)]Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Secondhand citation; Yang Shu-hao's original is still to be obtained and checked.. Afterwards villages allied by surname and martial troupes multiplied, leaving traces in the headband system and sedan-order rules of the Xigang Incense Procession R001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).. It is a different event from the Guo–Huang feud of Tuchengzi in the Daoguang years of the Qing (see Guo–Huang feud).

Course of events

5 itemsFirst items: Huang Wen-po (黃文博): 「『黃郭相刣』是『西港仔堡』的歷史大事…Remote cause: 「道光年間的開墾問題,大竹林、大塭寮…Immediate cause: 「日據初期樹仔腳(黃)與大塭寮(郭)兩庄農民因…MoreLess
  1. Huang Wen-po (黃文博): 「『黃郭相刣』是『西港仔堡』的歷史大事,也是歷史慘劇,時間發生於日據初期,械鬥長達十三年,所以有『西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬』之語流傳。」 ("The 'Huang–Guo killings' were a major historical event of 'Xigangzi Bao' and also a historical tragedy; they took place in the early Japanese occupation period, and the feud lasted thirteen years, which is why the saying 'at Xigangzi the Huangs and Guos killed each other for thirteen winters' has been handed down.") Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).
  2. Remote cause: 「道光年間的開墾問題,大竹林、大塭寮、郭份寮(來自布袋郭岑寮)的郭姓墾戶,不願與樹仔腳、溪南寮、埔頂、蚶寮(含塭仔內)、七十二份的黃姓墾戶併墾,致結下恩怨,時有土地之糾紛,而經常引發黃郭械鬥。」 ("The problem of reclamation in the Daoguang era: the Guo settler households of Dazhulin (大竹林), Dawenliao (大塭寮) and Guofenliao (郭份寮) (who came from Guocenliao in Budai) were unwilling to reclaim land jointly with the Huang settler households of Shuzijiao (樹仔腳), Xinanliao (溪南寮), Puding (埔頂), Hanliao (蚶寮) (including Wenzinei, 塭仔內) and Qishierfen (七十二份), which bred grievances; there were frequent land disputes, which often set off armed feuds between the Huangs and the Guos.") Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).
  3. Immediate cause: 「日據初期樹仔腳(黃)與大塭寮(郭)兩庄農民因土地界址糾紛而引發衝突,先是庄拼庄,接著是姓拼姓,械鬥十三年間,雙方各『戰亡』十餘人」 ("In the early Japanese occupation period, farmers of the two villages of Shuzijiao (Huang) and Dawenliao (Guo) clashed over a land-boundary dispute, first village against village, then surname against surname; in the thirteen years of the feud, each side had more than ten people 'killed in battle'"). Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).
  4. Yang Shu-hao (楊書濠), quoting Huang Wen-po's 《南瀛地名誌—北門區卷》 (Nanying Place Names: Beimen District Volume), writes similarly: the dispute between the two sides was temporarily settled after the authorities surveyed the boundary, but was not fully resolved, and 「到日治初期,終於爆發曾文溪溪埔地開發史上有名的『黃郭械鬥』之歷史悲劇」 ("in the early Japanese period, the historical tragedy of the 'Huang–Guo feud,' famous in the history of the development of the Zengwen River riverbed lands, finally broke out"); the saying is written as 「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」 ("at Xigangzi the Huangs and Guos killed each other for thirteen winters"). Secondhand accountR002Source本站研究檔 V8-11〈械鬥、爭地與廟際衝突〉[this site's research file V8-11, "Armed Feuds, Land Disputes and Conflicts between Temples"]:楊書濠引黃文博《南瀛地名誌—北門區卷》(1998)黃郭械鬥原文與「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」俗諺 [Yang Shu-hao (楊書濠) quoting the original text on the Huang–Guo feud and the saying 「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」 from Huang Wen-po's 《南瀛地名誌—北門區卷》 (Nanying Place Names: Beimen District Volume) (1998)]Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Secondhand citation; Yang Shu-hao's original is still to be obtained and checked.
  5. Original newspaper reports from the Japanese period and lists of casualties on both sides: not found online. Unverified

Impact

5 items1949First items: Alliances and factions: after the event,…Troupe names: Dawenliao's 「五虎平『西』陣」 ("Fi…Palanquin order: one of the principles o…MoreLess
  1. Alliances and factions: after the event, 「各姓村庄更加聯繫,形成結盟現象」 ("the villages of each surname became more closely connected, forming alliances"); martial troupes were founded one after another, and 「黃腳巾、紅腳巾之『腳巾制度』亦從此時定型」 ("the 'waist sash system' of yellow waist sashes and red waist sashes also took its settled form from this time"). Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣). See Waist Sash (jiaojin).
  2. Troupe names: Dawenliao's 「五虎平『西』陣」 ("Five Tigers Pacify the 'West' Troupe") and Shuzijiao's 「薛仁貴征『東』(白鶴陣)陣」 ("Xue Rengui's 'Eastern' Campaign (White Crane Troupe) Troupe"). Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).
  3. Palanquin order: one of the principles of the procession was that 「樹仔腳神轎與頂下寮(即大竹林和大塭寮)神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Shuzijiao god palanquins and the Dingxialiao (that is, Dazhulin and Dawenliao) god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins"), which Huang Wen-po says 「實乃肇因於『黃郭相刦』」 ("in fact originated in the 'Huang–Guo conflict'"). The data booklets before the 1988 Wuchen cycle (戊辰科) still contained this proposal; the review opinions of that cycle deleted it and resolved that 「今後不得再提此條文,各神轎號轎順序由抽籤決定之」 ("henceforth this clause may not be proposed again, and the order of the god palanquins shall be decided by drawing lots"), and the clause no longer appears in the data booklet of the 1991 Xinwei cycle (辛未科). Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣).
  4. Serving before the deity (駕前): this was originally taken by Guo Shengwang (郭聖王) of Dingxialiao, and after the 1928 raft-capsizing incident it was decided by lot. Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣). The Wikipedia table also says that the post of 「副帥」 (deputy commander) was long held by Dingxialiao; in 1979 Shuzijiao Bao'an Temple's wish to take it caused a dispute, and in 1982 it was changed to drawing lots. Secondhand accountR003Source維基百科中文版 [Chinese Wikipedia]〈西港刈香〉["Xigang Incense Procession"]「參與村鄉」表 [table of "participating villages"](轉錄黃文博《西港刈香》2014 頁 47–55、《南瀛刈香誌》1994 頁 235–244)[transcribed from Huang Wen-po's 《西港刈香》 [The Xigang Incense Procession] (2014), pp. 47–55, and 《南瀛刈香誌》 [Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying] (1994), pp. 235–244],本站研究檔 V4-09 逐列整理 [organized row by row in this site's research file V4-09]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/zh-tw/%E8%A5%BF%E6%B8%AF%E5%88%88%E9%A6%99Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Secondhand online account, transcribing specialist books.
  5. In 1949 (or 1952), the Song Jiang Troupe (宋江陣) of Hanliao and the White Crane Troupe of Shuzijiao jointly performed a circling formation (打圈), which set off a "great troupe clash" (大軋陣) between the seven yellow-waist-sash troupes and the nine red-waist-sash troupes; it was defused only when the flag-and-tablet officer (旗牌官) arrived bearing the royal command of the Qiansui (千歲爺) and everyone knelt. Scholarly viewR001SourceHuang Wen-po (黃文博),《南瀛刈香誌》[Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying], 臺南縣立文化中心 [Tainan County Cultural Center], 1994Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-03Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Records of the Incense Processions of Nanying (南瀛刈香誌)》p. 294–295、298、314Rough OCR draft from photographs of the copy held by the National Taiwan Library, not manually proofread. Note 37 records how the proposal 「頂下寮神轎與樹仔腳神轎須相隔十頂轎」 ("the Dingxialiao god palanquins and the Shuzijiao god palanquins must be separated by ten palanquins") in the data booklets before the Wuchen cycle (1988) was deleted; note 38 records the Huang–Guo feud (黃郭相刣). See the 1952 troupe contest at Sigang Elementary School.

As recorded in a study of flood landscapes

6 itemsFirst items: Where the saying circulates: in southern…Cause: after the great storm of 1823 the…Extent: mainly the emerged land running …MoreLess

Tsai Min-chih's (蔡旻芝) 2024 master's thesis places the Huang–Guo feud in the context of the struggle over the emerged land of the Zengwen River R004SourceTsai Min-chih (蔡旻芝),《曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討》[Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area],國立臺灣師範大學地理學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University],2024,頁 52–53 [pp. 52–53]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area (曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討)》p. 52–53. Scholarly view

  1. Where the saying circulates: in southern Qigu, Annan District and Xigang District, the saying 「西港仔黃郭相刣十三冬」 ("the Huang and Guo of Xigangzai killed each other for thirteen winters") circulates (citing Huang Chien-kai (黃健凱), 2022) R004SourceTsai Min-chih (蔡旻芝),《曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討》[Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area],國立臺灣師範大學地理學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University],2024,頁 52–53 [pp. 52–53]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area (曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討)》p. 52–53.
  2. Cause: after the great storm of 1823 the Taijiang Inner Sea emerged as land, and Hong Li (洪理), Huang Jun (黃軍) and others of the Sixteen Share-Heads (十六股首) were the first to go to the lower Zengwen River to recruit tenants and open land; among them, the Huang clan came into conflict over land reclamation with Guo Mushi (郭畝使), a wealthy man of Xizhou in Xuejia (citing Lu Chia-hsing (盧嘉興), 1962) R004SourceTsai Min-chih (蔡旻芝),《曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討》[Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area],國立臺灣師範大學地理學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University],2024,頁 52–53 [pp. 52–53]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area (曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討)》p. 52–53.
  3. Extent: mainly the emerged land running south from Qishierfen (七十二份) and Gongdiwei (公地尾) to Tuchengzi; to guard against attack by the Huang clan, the Guo clan built earthen ramparts to protect where their tenants lived, which the thesis, citing Huang Wen-po (1994), says is one of the explanations of the origin of the place name 「土城仔」 (Tuchengzi, "earthen walled place") R004SourceTsai Min-chih (蔡旻芝),《曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討》[Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area],國立臺灣師範大學地理學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University],2024,頁 52–53 [pp. 52–53]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area (曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討)》p. 52–53. See Tuchengzi.
  4. Outcome: the authorities intervened, and the affair finally ended with the erection of boundary steles, but the antagonism between the two sides continued, and disputes arose again under Japanese rule (citing Lu Chia-hsing, 1962) R004SourceTsai Min-chih (蔡旻芝),《曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討》[Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area],國立臺灣師範大學地理學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University],2024,頁 52–53 [pp. 52–53]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area (曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討)》p. 52–53.
  5. The thesis says that a century after the events, local residents' memory of the causes and course of the feud has become very vague, and they no longer even connect the conflict with the flooding of the Zengwen River and the reclamation of emerged land (citing Huang Chien-kai, 2022) R004SourceTsai Min-chih (蔡旻芝),《曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討》[Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area],國立臺灣師範大學地理學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University],2024,頁 52–53 [pp. 52–53]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Shaping and Changing of the Traditional Floodscape and its Implication in the Lower Zengwun River Area (曾文溪下游傳統洪災地景之形塑與變遷意涵的探討)》p. 52–53.
  6. Dating: the text above follows Huang Wen-po in writing "the early Japanese period, a feud lasting thirteen years"; Tsai Min-chih's thesis instead places the reclamation conflict in the Daoguang era after 1823, with the Japanese period being when "disputes arose again."

See also

Reports that mention it

Hall of Faith3.2bFaith / The orthodoxy dispute

The Orthodoxy Dispute: Sixty Years of Debate between Two Luermen Mazu Temples

On the north bank of the Luermen River stands the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple, and on the south bank the Luermen Tianhou Temple; both say they carry on the incense lineage of the Qing-dynasty old Luermen Mazu Temple. Beginning with a survey in 1956, press conferences, petitions, official documents and special newspaper issues followed one after another. The two sides' own words are quoted as they were and set alongside scholars and official documents; this site does not adjudicate.

24129

Continue from here