History of the Binnan Industrial Park project

The history of the Binnan Industrial Park project: in 1993 Yieh Loong and Tuntex separately proposed a steel mill and the seventh naphtha cracker, merged in 1994 as the Binnan Industrial Park; after two stages of environmental impact assessment, the Control Yuan's corrective measures and the regional planning review, the Ministry of the Interior declared the zoning-approval procedure terminated in 2009.R001Source環境部 [Ministry of Environment] Environmental Impact Assessment Document Search System: the Binnan group of cases 0850201A (1,873 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical), 0850641A (1,036 ha, Yieh Loong Group), 0940502A (1,732.05 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical, committee date 1999-12-17); Qigu Industrial Park 0800132A; Tainan Technology Industrial Park 0810082AOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)The four area figures are different documents from different stages and cannot be added together; where a single figure is needed, the 1,732.05 ha of 0940502A is used.

Official recordSecondhand accountUnverified
000

Verification status of the entries on this page

  • Verified
  • Partially verified
  • Not covered by sources
  • Verified: the source was found and checked
  • Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

The history of the Binnan Industrial Park project traces the Binnan Industrial Park year by year: the separate proposals of the Yieh Loong Group's "Steel City" and the Tuntex Group's seventh naphtha cracker in 1993 and their merger in 1994; the revocation of the original plan in 1995; the alternative plans and second-stage environmental impact assessment from 1996; conditional approval on December 17, 1999; the Control Yuan's corrective measures in 2000; the announcement of the review conclusions and the return of the plan by the Regional Planning Committee in 2006; and the Ministry of the Interior's termination of the procedure on September 1, 2009.

Relationship map

  • Events
  • People, shops and terms
History of the Binnan Industrial Park project

Key events

101 items1987–2026First items: The Tainan County Government (臺南縣政府) pro…At the end of the year, a group of black…The Yieh Loong Group submitted to the In…MoreLess
  1. 1987
    1. The Tainan County Government (臺南縣政府) pro…Official recordMoreLess
      The Tainan County Government (臺南縣政府) promoted the 「臺南縣七股區域綜合開發計劃」 ("Tainan County Qigu Regional Comprehensive Development Plan"), whose sub-plans included the Qigu Industrial Park; see the entry "Qigu Industrial Park" R001Source環境部 [Ministry of Environment] Environmental Impact Assessment Document Search System: the Binnan group of cases 0850201A (1,873 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical), 0850641A (1,036 ha, Yieh Loong Group), 0940502A (1,732.05 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical, committee date 1999-12-17); Qigu Industrial Park 0800132A; Tainan Technology Industrial Park 0810082AOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The four area figures are different documents from different stages and cannot be added together; where a single figure is needed, the 1,732.05 ha of 0940502A is used.. Official record
  2. 1992
    1. At the end of the year, a group of black…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      At the end of the year, a group of black-faced spoonbills was shot by unknown persons in Qigu (七股); the photographer Wang Cheng-chi (王徵吉) was assigned to cover the story and from then on devoted himself to protecting the birds R002Source國家影視聽中心 [Taiwan Film and Audiovisual Institute] 台灣電影網 [Taiwan Cinema],《守護黑面琵鷺》[Guarding the Black-faced Spoonbill] (Liang Chieh-te (梁皆得), 2023)Original URLhttps://taiwancinema.bamid.gov.tw/Film/Filmcontent/?ContentUrl=89691Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
  3. 1993
    1. 06-10The Yieh Loong Group submitted to the In…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Yieh Loong Group submitted to the Industrial Development Bureau of the Ministry of Economic Affairs (經濟部工業局) a NT$112 billion 「鋼鐵城」 ("Steel City") plan: a refined integrated steel mill producing 6.5 million tonnes of crude steel a year on a site of about 1,000 ha, with its sights on the Qigu Industrial Park R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    2. 06-30Tuntex Group president Chen Yu-hao (陳由豪)…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Tuntex Group president Chen Yu-hao (陳由豪) announced plans to build an oil refinery and an aromatics plant, putting forward a plan to build the seventh naphtha cracker R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    3. 09Lien Ting Steel Co. was established, pla…Official recordMoreLess
      Lien Ting Steel Co. was established, planning to build an integrated steel mill in the Binnan Industrial Park, Tainan County R004Source中鴻鋼鐵股份有限公司及子公司合併財務報表暨會計師核閱報告 [Chung Hung Steel Corporation and Subsidiaries: Consolidated Financial Statements and Independent Accountants' Review Report], first three quarters of ROC year 97 (2008) (company history)Original URLhttps://www.chsteel.com.tw/cg/pdf/fin_report_9703c.pdfRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Public financial report of a listed company.. Official record
    4. 09-27Tuntex submitted an investment plan for …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Tuntex submitted an investment plan for an integrated petrochemical complex R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    5. 10-29The Ministry of Economic Affairs approve…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Ministry of Economic Affairs approved in principle Tuntex's development of 1,500 ha of Taiyen's (台鹽) Qigu Salt Field (七股鹽場) as its plant site under the Statute for Upgrading Industries (《促進產業升級條例》) R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
      1. That day the Minister of Economic Affairs, Chiang Pin-kung (江丙坤), convened a meeting to coordinate the land; those attending were Industrial Development Bureau director-general Wang Chueh-min (王覺民) and deputy director-general Pan Ting-pai (潘丁白), National Property Administration director-general Liu Chin-piao (劉金標), Taiyen general manager Yu Kuang-hua (余光華), and Tuntex chairman Chen Yu-hao R005SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement], 1993–1995 chapter (including the production record of《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast])Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=136Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    6. 11-29The environmental impact assessment of t…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The environmental impact assessment of the Qigu Industrial Park development plan was rejected, and the site of Yieh Loong's Steel City shifted to Taiyen's Qigu Salt Field, the same land as Tuntex's R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
  4. 1994
    1. 01-15A four-party agreement among the Tainan …Secondhand accountSecondhand accountMoreLess
      A four-party agreement among the Tainan County Government, Taiyen, Tuntex, and Yieh Loong: to build their plants jointly on newly formed tidal land and to open a dedicated industrial port jointly R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand accountAnother chronicle describes it as the Industrial Development Bureau inviting the two conglomerates and Taiyen to coordinate; see "Discrepancies in the records" below R005SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement], 1993–1995 chapter (including the production record of《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast])Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=136Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    2. 04-14The Industrial Development Bureau held a…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Industrial Development Bureau held a coordination meeting to allocate land areas R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    3. 05-13Legislator Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智) held a 「七輕…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Legislator Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智) held a 「七輕、燁隆七股開發案公聽會」 ("Public Hearing on the Seventh Naphtha Cracker and Yieh Loong Qigu Development Projects") at the Legislative Yuan R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    4. 08-21The Taiwan Coastal Protection Associatio…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Taiwan Coastal Protection Association (台灣海岸保護協會) was founded in the auditorium of Beimen Senior High School in Jiali, convened by Huang Ming-chin (黃銘欽), a professor of statistics at National Cheng Kung University R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    5. 08-31The two projects were merged and named t…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The two projects were merged and named the "Binnan Industrial Park Comprehensive Development Plan" R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    6. 09-11The 「濕地國家公園/高科技工業園區促進會」 ("Wetland Nation…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 「濕地國家公園/高科技工業園區促進會」 ("Wetland National Park/High-Tech Industrial Park Promotion Association") was founded at the fishermen's activity center of Dingshan Village (頂山), Qigu, with Chen Chao-lai (陳朝來) as its president R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    7. 09-12The promotion association and the fishin…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The promotion association and the fishing-rights association protested at the Tainan County Government; on the same day, Tuntex and Yieh Loong set up the 「濱南工業區聯合開發籌備辦公室」 ("Binnan Industrial Park Joint Development Preparatory Office") in Jiali R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    8. 09-30The 「反七輕、反大煉鋼廠行動聯盟」 ("Action Alliance Ag…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 「反七輕、反大煉鋼廠行動聯盟」 ("Action Alliance Against the Seventh Naphtha Cracker and the Large Steel Mill") was founded in the Qunxian Building of the Legislative Yuan R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    9. 10-07Three masked thugs broke into the home o…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Three masked thugs broke into the home of Chen Chao-lai, general secretary of the action committee, intending to kill his whole family, but failed R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    10. 10-08 to 10-31Eleven consecutive anti-Binnan informati…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Eleven consecutive anti-Binnan information meetings, all held in front of temples: the Dingshan Daitian Temple in Qigu, the Dujia Wenheng Temple, the Zhongliao Tianhou Temple (中寮天后宮), the Shifen Shenghu Temple, the Sangu Longde Temple (三股龍德宮), the Zhuqiao Qingshan Temple (竹橋慶善宮), Xinsheng Road in Jiali, the Xiliao Xixing Temple, the Longshan Longevity Club, the Qingkunshen Chaotian Temple (青鯤鯓朝天宮) in Jiangjun, and in front of the great temple of Mashagou in Jiangjun R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    11. 10-26Su Chiu (蘇秋), a producer at Jutao Audiov…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Su Chiu (蘇秋), a producer at Jutao Audiovisual (and Su Huan-chih's aunt), was invited to visit Qigu Lagoon, which gave rise to the idea for the documentary The Beauty of the West Coast (《西濱之美》) R005SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement], 1993–1995 chapter (including the production record of《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast])Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=136Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    12. 11-02Opposition groups called at the central …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Opposition groups called at the central headquarters of the Democratic Progressive Party to protest the ambiguous stance of the party's county magistrate, Chen Tang-shan (陳唐山) R005SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement], 1993–1995 chapter (including the production record of《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast])Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=136Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    13. 12-05The developers prepared a "Feasibility P…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The developers prepared a "Feasibility Planning Report" and an "Environmental Description," which were forwarded via the Tainan County Government, the provincial government, and the Industrial Development Bureau to the Environmental Protection Administration (環保署) R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    14. 12-30The Environmental Impact Assessment Act …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Environmental Impact Assessment Act (《環境影響評估法》) took effect; the documents had been submitted just before it did R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
  5. 1995
    1. 01-06The Aixiang Cultural and Educational Fou…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Aixiang Cultural and Educational Foundation (愛鄉文教基金會) and Su Huan-chih's legislative office jointly commissioned Jutao Audiovisual Production and Communication Co., Ltd. (巨濤視聽製作傳播有限公司) to film The Beauty of the West Coast; shooting began on 02-04, the master tape was finished on 03-13, and it was released on 03-15, with a running time of 54 minutes R005SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement], 1993–1995 chapter (including the production record of《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast])Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=136Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    2. 01-20Supporters and opponents clashed on site…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Supporters and opponents clashed on site in Qigu R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    3. 02-10Fishermen and salt workers protested at …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Fishermen and salt workers protested at the Qigu Salt Field against the conglomerates swallowing up Taiyen's land R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    4. 02-23At the Industrial Development Bureau, th…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      At the Industrial Development Bureau, the Tainan County Government consulted with the Environmental Protection Administration, the Ministry of the Interior, and the Ministry of Economic Affairs, and it was confirmed that the project's environmental impact assessment would be reviewed by the central government R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    5. 03-22The documentary The Choice of the West C…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The documentary The Choice of the West Coast's Fate (《西濱命運的抉擇》) was completed R005SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement], 1993–1995 chapter (including the production record of《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast])Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=136Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    6. 03-25The 「反七輕、反大煉鋼廠行動委員會」 ("Action Committee …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 「反七輕、反大煉鋼廠行動委員會」 ("Action Committee Against the Seventh Naphtha Cracker and the Large Steel Mill") was founded at Jiali Elementary School R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    7. 05-23Wang Wang-en (汪旺恩), vice president of th…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Wang Wang-en (汪旺恩), vice president of the action committee, and his wife were slashed more than twenty times R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    8. 08-03At an on-site inspection by the Environm…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      At an on-site inspection by the Environmental Protection Administration, Huang Wei-che (黃偉哲), on the opposing side, was beaten and injured by supporters R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    9. 11-10First preliminary review by the first-st…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      First preliminary review by the first-stage task force; environmental groups presented six reasons for opposition at the gate of the Environmental Protection Administration, among them that 「填土量高達 7,275 萬公噸」 ("the volume of landfill would reach 72.75 million tonnes") R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.R006SourceChinese Wikipedia: 濱南工業區 [Binnan Industrial Park], 陳由豪 [Chen Yu-hao], 義联集團 [E-United Group], 林義守 [Lin Yi-shou]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%BF%B1%E5%8D%97%E5%B7%A5%E6%A5%AD%E5%8D%80Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    10. 11-28The 22nd meeting of the Environmental Im…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 22nd meeting of the Environmental Impact Assessment Review Committee rejected the original plan and required an alternative plan to be submitted R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
  6. 1996
    1. 02-14The developers submitted alternative pla…Official recordMoreLess
      The developers submitted alternative plans: 0850201A (integrated petrochemical complex plus dedicated industrial port, 1,873 ha) and 0850641A (steel mill plus dedicated industrial port, 1,036 ha) R001Source環境部 [Ministry of Environment] Environmental Impact Assessment Document Search System: the Binnan group of cases 0850201A (1,873 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical), 0850641A (1,036 ha, Yieh Loong Group), 0940502A (1,732.05 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical, committee date 1999-12-17); Qigu Industrial Park 0800132A; Tainan Technology Industrial Park 0810082AOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The four area figures are different documents from different stages and cannot be added together; where a single figure is needed, the 1,732.05 ha of 0940502A is used.. Official record
    2. 04-18Fourteen environmental groups held a pre…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Fourteen environmental groups held a press conference at the Tainan County Government and were surrounded by dozens of people afterward R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    3. 05-06The 26th meeting of the Environmental Im…Official recordMoreLess
      The 26th meeting of the Environmental Impact Assessment Review Committee resolved that a second-stage environmental impact assessment would proceed, with conditions R001Source環境部 [Ministry of Environment] Environmental Impact Assessment Document Search System: the Binnan group of cases 0850201A (1,873 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical), 0850641A (1,036 ha, Yieh Loong Group), 0940502A (1,732.05 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical, committee date 1999-12-17); Qigu Industrial Park 0800132A; Tainan Technology Industrial Park 0810082AOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The four area figures are different documents from different stages and cannot be added together; where a single figure is needed, the 1,732.05 ha of 0940502A is used.. Official record
    4. 06-05The Environmental Protection Administrat…Official recordMoreLess
      The Environmental Protection Administration announced the conclusions of the first-stage review, whose second article reads: 「其開發使用潟湖、沙洲之比例,應降至百分之三十以下」 ("the proportion of the lagoon and sandbars used for development shall be reduced to below thirty percent") R001Source環境部 [Ministry of Environment] Environmental Impact Assessment Document Search System: the Binnan group of cases 0850201A (1,873 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical), 0850641A (1,036 ha, Yieh Loong Group), 0940502A (1,732.05 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical, committee date 1999-12-17); Qigu Industrial Park 0800132A; Tainan Technology Industrial Park 0810082AOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The four area figures are different documents from different stages and cannot be added together; where a single figure is needed, the 1,732.05 ha of 0940502A is used.. Official record
    5. 06-22Minister of Economic Affairs Wang Chih-k…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Minister of Economic Affairs Wang Chih-kang (王志剛) said he expected construction to begin within six months R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    6. 08-11 to 08-18「愛鄉土・反七輕・南瀛苦行」 ("Love the Homeland, Oppo…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      「愛鄉土・反七輕・南瀛苦行」 ("Love the Homeland, Oppose the Seventh Naphtha Cracker: A Nanying Pilgrimage of Hardship"), an eight-day march on foot R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    7. 09-21, 09-22The 「反濱南護水愛鄉行動聯盟」 ("Anti-Binnan Action A…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 「反濱南護水愛鄉行動聯盟」 ("Anti-Binnan Action Alliance to Protect Water and Love the Homeland") and the "Qigu Coastal Protection Association" (七股海岸保護協會) were founded; the Tainan Environmental Protection Union (台南市環保聯盟), Wetlands Taiwan, and the Wild Bird Society of Tainan (台南市野鳥學會) launched the march 「保全台南,為希望而行」 ("Protect Tainan, Walk for Hope") R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    8. 10-04The 「1004 全國反濱南護水愛鄉聯合大請願」 ("1004 Nationa…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 「1004 全國反濱南護水愛鄉聯合大請願」 ("1004 National Joint Grand Petition Against Binnan to Protect Water and Love the Homeland") R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    9. 10-07, 10-08Su Huan-chih was twice beaten in the Leg…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Su Huan-chih was twice beaten in the Legislative Yuan by Legislator Lin Ming-yi (林明義); on the same day he went to the Control Yuan to demand the impeachment of the head of the Environmental Protection Administration R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    10. From 10-11Scoping meetings 1 to 5 (through 1997-03…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Scoping meetings 1 to 5 (through 1997-03-05); at the 2nd meeting, Chou Ko-jen (周克任) of the Pingtung Blue Donggang River Conservation Association was beaten and injured R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    11. 10-18, 10-21Taej Mundkur, Asia-Pacific coordinator o…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Taej Mundkur, Asia-Pacific coordinator of Wetlands International (國際濕地組織), visited Qigu and called on the Council of Agriculture R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    12. 10-20, 10-25The 「七股潟湖國家風景區促進會」 ("Qigu Lagoon Nationa…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 「七股潟湖國家風景區促進會」 ("Qigu Lagoon National Scenic Area Promotion Association") and the 「西濱國家風景區促進會」 ("West Coast National Scenic Area Promotion Association") were founded R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
  7. 1997
    1. 05-26At a symposium of the Building and Plann…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      At a symposium of the Building and Planning Research Foundation of National Taiwan University, an open letter to President Lee Teng-hui (李登輝) was presented: "An Island on the Verge of Extinction—Taiwan, a Black Coastline—the Binnan Industrial Park" R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    2. 06-23The developers submitted the second-stag…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The developers submitted the second-stage environmental impact statement R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    3. 06-24The Kaohsiung District Prosecutors Offic…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Kaohsiung District Prosecutors Office directed searches of 12 affiliated companies of the Yieh Loong Group R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    4. 07-19Su Huan-chih invited Environmental Prote…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Su Huan-chih invited Environmental Protection Administration head Tsai Hsun-hsiung (蔡勳雄) to inspect Qigu Lagoon R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    5. 10-05The International Black-faced Spoonbill …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The International Black-faced Spoonbill Conservation Center (國際黑面琵鷺保育中心) was established in Shifen Village, Qigu R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    6. 12-08The Industrial Development Bureau of the…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Industrial Development Bureau of the Ministry of Economic Affairs conducted an on-site inspection for the second-stage environmental impact assessment, chaired by Chang Fan (張璠), head of the bureau's Fifth Division. More than 200 opponents of the naphtha cracker blocked it and faced off against security police (another passage of the report says more than 100 riot police with shields and helmets); after negotiations between Legislator Su Huan-chih, who led the group, and the Industrial Development Bureau and police broke down, the police forcibly removed them R007Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center] (excerpting a 中國時報 [China Times] Tainan County report),〈反七輕人士抗爭鎮暴警察強制驅離 濱南工業區會勘流血衝突〉[Anti-Naphtha-Cracker Protesters Forcibly Removed by Riot Police: Bloody Clash at Binnan Industrial Park Site Inspection], 1997-12-09Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/node/79681Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    7. 12-08At a county affairs meeting, the Tainan …Official recordMoreLess
      At a county affairs meeting, the Tainan County Government added point 8 to the 「台南縣海岸一定限度內不得為私有土地之劃定作業要點」 ("Guidelines for Delimiting Land Within a Certain Limit of the Tainan County Coast That May Not Be Held Privately"); the Control Yuan's censure of 2000 found that this was done to clear the way for the Binnan Industrial Park R008Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、李伸一委員提案糾正經濟部工業局及台南縣政府〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung and Lee Shen-yi against the Industrial Development Bureau, MOEA, and the Tainan County Government] (Binnan Industrial Park; addition of point 8 to the guidelines for delimiting coastal land not to be held privately), 2000-01-07Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3584Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
    8. 12-09The Industrial Development Bureau of the…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Industrial Development Bureau of the Ministry of Economic Affairs held a 「濱南工業區開發計畫聽證會」 ("Hearing on the Binnan Industrial Park Development Plan") R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.R007Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center] (excerpting a 中國時報 [China Times] Tainan County report),〈反七輕人士抗爭鎮暴警察強制驅離 濱南工業區會勘流血衝突〉[Anti-Naphtha-Cracker Protesters Forcibly Removed by Riot Police: Bloody Clash at Binnan Industrial Park Site Inspection], 1997-12-09Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/node/79681Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    9. 12-30The Industrial Development Bureau sent t…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Industrial Development Bureau sent to the Environmental Protection Administration the draft second-stage environmental impact statements of Great East Asia Petrochemical and the Yieh Loong Group, together with the records of the 12-08 on-site inspection and the 12-09 hearing R009SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈二階環評 輪番上場1998~1999〉[The Second-Stage EIA: One Round After Another, 1998–1999]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=433Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side.R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
  8. 1998
    1. 02-09After its preliminary review, the Enviro…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      After its preliminary review, the Environmental Protection Administration wrote asking the developers to supplement their materials and pay the review fee R009SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈二階環評 輪番上場1998~1999〉[The Second-Stage EIA: One Round After Another, 1998–1999]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=433Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side.R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
    2. 02-18The developers paid the review fee, and …Secondhand accountOfficial recordMoreLess
      The developers paid the review fee, and the review period for the second-stage environmental impact assessment began to run R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).R009SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈二階環評 輪番上場1998~1999〉[The Second-Stage EIA: One Round After Another, 1998–1999]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=433Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side.. Secondhand accountThe Control Yuan press release gives the start as 02-19; see "Discrepancies in the records" below R012Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan] (environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park), 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
    3. 02-27The Environmental Protection Administrat…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Environmental Protection Administration sent the draft statement to the agencies and organizations concerned and sought the opinions of the task-force members; the review was originally to be organized under six topics, with four preliminary review meetings expected R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.R009SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈二階環評 輪番上場1998~1999〉[The Second-Stage EIA: One Round After Another, 1998–1999]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=433Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side.. Secondhand account
    4. 03-19Su Huan-chih sent a letter proposing tha…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Su Huan-chih sent a letter proposing that the review topics be expanded from 6 items to 10 groups, and the Environmental Protection Administration accepted R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
    5. 04-02Premier Vincent Siew (Siew Wan-chang) (蕭…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Premier Vincent Siew (Siew Wan-chang) (蕭萬長) questioned the supply of water and electricity R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    6. From 04-07Preliminary reviews by the second-stage …Secondhand accountSecondhand accountMoreLess
      Preliminary reviews by the second-stage task force: 14 in all through 1999-12-15, plus 3 additional sessions, 6 of which were closed to the public R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand accountThe censure text records that by 1999-11-23 there had been 13 preliminary task-force meetings and 3 meetings of scholars and experts R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
      • The dates of the review meetings listed in the censure text (listed to document the absences of the committee member with expertise in air pollution control): in 1998, 04-24, 06-02, 06-15, 06-25, 07-09, and 07-17; in 1999, 01-29 morning, 01-29 afternoon, 02-08, 05-15, 07-23, 08-12, 08-26, and 10-13 R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
      1. 04-07 First preliminary review R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
      2. 07-09 The original minutes are headed 「專案小組第二次初審會議結論」 ("Conclusions of the Second Preliminary Review Meeting of the Task Force"); going by the sequence of the topic-by-topic reviews, there was another meeting on 04-24 after 04-07, so for which day was the second, see "Discrepancies in the records" below R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Unverified
  9. 1999
    1. 08-2611th task-force meeting: 「不論任何使用潟湖比率(5%、10%…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      11th task-force meeting: 「不論任何使用潟湖比率(5%、10%、15%、20%、25%、30%)對潟湖生態均有影響」 ("any proportion of lagoon use (5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, 25%, 30%) would affect the lagoon's ecology"), and 「潟湖使用面積比率百分之五就等於將北潮口堵塞」 ("using even five percent of the lagoon area is equivalent to blocking the northern tidal inlet") R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
    2. 08-27Hsieh Chih-cheng and Lin Sheng-chung (林聖…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Hsieh Chih-cheng and Lin Sheng-chung (林聖崇), convener of the Ecological Conservation Alliance (生態保育聯盟), went to the Control Yuan and petitioned Ma Yi-kung (馬以工), the Control Yuan member on duty, about flaws in the Environmental Protection Administration's review; the author writes that he is not sure whether the censure arose from this R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
    3. 09-02When the Environmental Protection Admini…UnverifiedMoreLess
      When the Environmental Protection Administration sent its letter based on the previous conclusion, 「使用潟湖面積低於 23% 之方案」 ("an option using less than 23% of the lagoon area") appeared R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Unverified
    4. 11-2213th preliminary review by the task forc…Official recordMoreLess
      13th preliminary review by the task force; on 11-25 the Environmental Protection Administration held a 「環境影響評估案件審查原則研商會議」 ("Consultative Meeting on Review Principles for Environmental Impact Assessment Cases"), which resolved that when a case risked running past its deadline, it would 「繼續審查」 ("continue to be reviewed") at the developer's request with the committee's consent, with no time limit set R012Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan] (environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park), 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
    5. 11-23Taipei Times front-page report: the day …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Taipei Times front-page report: the day before (11-22), a committee under the Environmental Protection Administration decided to postpone sending the Binnan Industrial Park plan to the next month's plenary environmental impact assessment meeting; the developers, the Tuntex Group and Yieh Loong, said the share of the lagoon in the site had fallen from 29% to 19.8%; environmental groups demanded that the case be withdrawn immediately; and the Environmental Protection Administration decided to ask experts to review the southern part of the site again R013SourceTaipei Times,頭版(1999-11-23)[Taipei Times, front page, 1999-11-23]Original URLhttps://www.taipeitimes.com/News/front/archives/1999/11/23/0000011865Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—English-language news report.. What follows is a paraphrase of the English-language report, not the original Chinese words: Secondhand account
      1. Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智, then a Democratic Progressive Party legislator from Tainan County) said 「環評過程有明顯缺失」 ("the environmental impact assessment process had clear shortcomings").
      2. A Kuomintang legislator from Tainan County (rendered in the report as Chou Wu-liu; Chinese name unverified) said 「如果我們不支持這個案子,地方居民就沒有未來」 ("if we do not support this project, the local residents will have no future").
      3. County Magistrate Chen Tang-shan (陳唐山) said 「開發確實會傷害環境」 ("development will indeed harm the environment").
      4. Oyster farmers and fishermen from Qigu attended; one long-time oyster farmer said that what he cared about most was the oyster beds he had tended all his life.
    6. 11-24The Control Yuan questioned the Industri…Official recordMoreLess
      The Control Yuan questioned the Industrial Development Bureau, the Water Resources Bureau (水資源局), and the Tainan County Government, and only then learned that Changhua County had first designated the Changhua Coastal Industrial Park (彰濱工業區) and then used the park's boundary to delimit the coastal land that may not be held privately R008Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、李伸一委員提案糾正經濟部工業局及台南縣政府〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung and Lee Shen-yi against the Industrial Development Bureau, MOEA, and the Tainan County Government] (Binnan Industrial Park; addition of point 8 to the guidelines for delimiting coastal land not to be held privately), 2000-01-07Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3584Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
    7. 12-13The Control Yuan questioned the Environm…Official recordMoreLess
      The Control Yuan questioned the Environmental Protection Administration; the administration maintained that holidays and the days before the conclusions of the National Energy Conference (全國能源會議) were complete did not count, so that through 11-22 the actual review had taken 110 days, within the 120-day limit R012Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan] (environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park), 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Official record
    8. 12-15The 14th task-force meeting recommended …Secondhand accountSecondhand accountMoreLess
      The 14th task-force meeting recommended conditional approval, putting forward 28 items to be carried out, 7 opinions requiring supplementation or revision, and 10 supplementary resolutions R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand accountIt was chaired by deputy administrator Wu Yi-hsiung (吳義雄), and of the 15 committee members who should have attended, 4 signed in, and of the 15 experts and scholars, 5 signed in R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
    9. 12-17The 66th meeting of the Environmental Im…Official recordSecondhand accountMoreLess
      The 66th meeting of the Environmental Impact Assessment Review Committee passed it conditionally through an ad hoc motion, adopting 27 items to be carried out, 8 opinions requiring supplementation or revision, and 9 supplementary resolutions R001Source環境部 [Ministry of Environment] Environmental Impact Assessment Document Search System: the Binnan group of cases 0850201A (1,873 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical), 0850641A (1,036 ha, Yieh Loong Group), 0940502A (1,732.05 ha, Great East Asia Petrochemical, committee date 1999-12-17); Qigu Industrial Park 0800132A; Tainan Technology Industrial Park 0810082AOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The four area figures are different documents from different stages and cannot be added together; where a single figure is needed, the 1,732.05 ha of 0940502A is used.R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Official recordA civil-society record states that the meeting was convened at 2:30 p.m. R014Source看守台灣協會 [Taiwan Watch Institute], Huang Huan-chang (黃煥彰),〈反對濱南工業區開發案〉[Opposing the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project], 2009-06-11Original URLhttps://www.taiwanwatch.org.tw/node/219Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    10. 12-21Taipei Times (page 2) report: environmen…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Taipei Times (page 2) report: environmental groups said the Binnan environmental impact assessment was hastily passed by 9 members of the Environmental Protection Administration's 29-member assessment committee, and pointed out that the project's daily water demand was 190,000 tons against an existing estimate that could supply only 80,000 tons, and that carbon dioxide emissions exceeded 20.7 million tons; Su Huan-chih said the assessment was passed to please certain consortia and local Kuomintang factions (paraphrase of the English-language wording). The 9 attendees match the attendance recorded on this page for the 66th meeting (1999-12-17) R015SourceTaipei Times,Chiu Yu-tzu〈Activists slam official Web site showing Spoonbills〉(1999-12-21)[Taipei Times, Chiu Yu-tzu, "Activists slam official Web site showing Spoonbills", 1999-12-21]Original URLhttps://www.taipeitimes.com/News/local/archives/1999/12/21/0000015832Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—English-language news report; statements by environmental groups and politicians.. Secondhand account
  10. 2000–2004
    1. From 2000-01-07Five years of wrangling over the final v…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Five years of wrangling over the final version, with many confirmation meetings R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
    2. 2000-01-07The Committee on Finance and Economic Af…Official recordMoreLess
      The Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs of the Control Yuan (監察院) passed a censure proposed by Control Yuan members Ma Yi-kung (馬以工) and Lee Shen-yi (李伸一), censuring the Industrial Development Bureau of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and the Tainan County Government: at its county affairs meeting of 1997-12-08, the Tainan County Government had added point 8 to the guidelines for delimiting coastal land not to be held privately, clearing the way for the Binnan Industrial Park R008Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、李伸一委員提案糾正經濟部工業局及台南縣政府〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung and Lee Shen-yi against the Industrial Development Bureau, MOEA, and the Tainan County Government] (Binnan Industrial Park; addition of point 8 to the guidelines for delimiting coastal land not to be held privately), 2000-01-07Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3584Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
      1. Grounds for the censure: under the Land Act (《土地法》) certain land may not be held privately, yet under the Enforcement Rules of the Statute for Upgrading Industries (《促進產業升級條例施行細則》) industrial-park land may be sold, 「形成行政命令與法律二者顯不相容」 ("so that the administrative order and the law are plainly incompatible"); the exclusion clause of point 8, 「經政府專案核准重大計畫,不適用該要點」 ("major projects approved by the government as special cases are not subject to these guidelines"), 「顯然意圖循彰濱工業區之模式,為濱南工業區之開發案解套」 ("plainly intends to follow the model of the Changhua Coastal Industrial Park in clearing the way for the Binnan Industrial Park development project") R008Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、李伸一委員提案糾正經濟部工業局及台南縣政府〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung and Lee Shen-yi against the Industrial Development Bureau, MOEA, and the Tainan County Government] (Binnan Industrial Park; addition of point 8 to the guidelines for delimiting coastal land not to be held privately), 2000-01-07Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3584Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
      2. The reproduced censure text bears the reference number (八九)院台財字第892200024號 R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
    3. 2000-01-07On the same day, the Environmental Prote…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      On the same day, the Environmental Protection Administration sent the review conclusions of the 66th meeting to the developers, asking them to submit supplementary materials R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
    4. 2000-04-17The Control Yuan passed a censure propos…Official recordMoreLess
      The Control Yuan passed a censure proposed by Control Yuan members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei (古登美), and Chang Te-ming (張德銘), censuring the Environmental Protection Administration: in conducting the Binnan environmental impact assessment review it had not counted weekends and holidays toward the review period, and its meeting conclusions exceeded the authority delegated by the parent law R012Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan] (environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park), 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
      1. Press release: counted in calendar days, the period from the 1998 supplementation and fee payment to the 13th preliminary review on 1999-11-22 already exceeded the 120 days of Article 13 of the Environmental Impact Assessment Act (《環境影響評估法》); the administration, excluding holidays, calculated it as 110 days; some review committee members with long-standing low attendance nonetheless had time to take on research projects commissioned by the administration R012Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan] (environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park), 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
      2. The reproduced censure text further records: the meeting was the 30th meeting of the third term of the Control Yuan's Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs; only one member of the EIA committee had expertise in air pollution control, and that member had no sign-in record at any of the review meetings; on 1999-12-15 only four committee members were present, three of whom opposed using any share of the lagoon, yet the administration still passed it; reference number (八九)院台財字第892200294號 R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
      3. Hsieh Chih-cheng records that after the censure, the administration amended Article 15 of the Enforcement Rules of the Environmental Impact Assessment Act and added Article 13-1 to the Act, which changed the dispute over the review period R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
    5. 2000-04-25Lin Su-chen (林素貞), professor in the Depa…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Lin Su-chen (林素貞), professor in the Department of Environmental Engineering at National Cheng Kung University, wrote a letter to the United Daily News asking why the administration was rushing to finalize the version under a caretaker cabinet R016Source環境資訊網絡電子報 [Environmental Information Network e-Newsletter], 2000-04-25, Lin Su-chen (林素貞) (professor, Department of Environmental Engineering, National Cheng Kung University),〈爭議大的濱南案 為何急於搞定?〉[Why the Rush to Settle the Highly Contested Binnan Case?] (originally a reader's letter in the United Daily News, April 25)Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/2000/04/0425/000425.htmRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    6. 2000-04-26The administration convened the 「濱南工業區開發…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The administration convened the 「濱南工業區開發計畫環境影響評估報告書定稿確認審查會議」 ("Review Meeting to Confirm the Final Version of the Environmental Impact Statement for the Binnan Industrial Park Development Plan") R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.R016Source環境資訊網絡電子報 [Environmental Information Network e-Newsletter], 2000-04-25, Lin Su-chen (林素貞) (professor, Department of Environmental Engineering, National Cheng Kung University),〈爭議大的濱南案 為何急於搞定?〉[Why the Rush to Settle the Highly Contested Binnan Case?] (originally a reader's letter in the United Daily News, April 25)Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/2000/04/0425/000425.htmRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    7. 2000-06-06 to 2001-01-12The written exchanges over confirming th…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The written exchanges over confirming the final version: on 06-06 the developers submitted materials on the eight opinions requiring supplementation or revision from the 66th meeting; on 08-07 the administration compiled 18 opinions and sent them to the developers; on 10-30 the developers replied in writing; on 11-29 and 2001-01-12 the 「八項應補充修正意見審查會議」 ("Review Meeting on the Eight Opinions Requiring Supplementation or Revision") was convened twice R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
    8. 2001-12-01Su Huan-chih was elected Tainan County M…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Su Huan-chih was elected Tainan County Magistrate R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    9. 2002-01-16Su Huan-chih, as county magistrate, wrot…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Su Huan-chih, as county magistrate, wrote to the Environmental Protection Administration asking it not to approve the record until the environmental impact assessment of the dedicated industrial port was finalized R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    10. 2002-07-09The Tainan County Government stated that…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Tainan County Government stated that it did not support the zoning approval and wrote to the Ministry of the Interior asking it to withdraw the land-use change case R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    11. 2002-10-14, 11-01The Council of Agriculture announced the…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Council of Agriculture announced the Zengwen River estuary (曾文溪口) as a Major Wildlife Habitat for the black-faced spoonbill; the Tainan County Government announced the Black-faced Spoonbill Reserve R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    12. 2003-11-21The Executive Yuan approved the boundari…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Executive Yuan approved the boundaries of the Southwest Coast National Scenic Area (雲嘉南濱海國家風景區) R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    13. 2004-12-16The Environmental Protection Administrat…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Environmental Protection Administration approved the final version under 環署綜字第 0930074745 號, without sending a copy to the Tainan County Government R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
  11. 2005
    1. 02-16The Kyoto Protocol (《京都議定書》) came into f…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Kyoto Protocol (《京都議定書》) came into force R006SourceChinese Wikipedia: 濱南工業區 [Binnan Industrial Park], 陳由豪 [Chen Yu-hao], 義联集團 [E-United Group], 林義守 [Lin Yi-shou]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%BF%B1%E5%8D%97%E5%B7%A5%E6%A5%AD%E5%8D%80Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    2. 04-19, 07-01, 08-11The Tainan County Government wrote three…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Tainan County Government wrote three times to the Environmental Protection Administration asking for a re-examination under Article 123 of the Administrative Procedure Act (《行政程序法》); on 05-30 the Environmental Protection Administration replied, suggesting that it go directly to the Ministry of Economic Affairs R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
    3. 09-21The Ministry of the Interior's reply rai…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Ministry of the Interior's reply raised the question of whether the industrial park and the Southwest Coast National Scenic Area were 「使用相容或競合」 ("compatible or competing in use") R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
    4. 12-03Su Huan-chih was re-elected Tainan Count…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Su Huan-chih was re-elected Tainan County Magistrate R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
  12. 2006
    1. 01-19The Environmental Protection Administrat…Official recordMoreLess
      The Environmental Protection Administration announced the review conclusions and the summary of the statement under 環署綜字第 0950006595 號, published on 01-24 in the Executive Yuan Gazette, vol. 12, no. 17 R018Source行政院公報 [Executive Yuan Gazette] vol. 012, no. 017 (2006-01-24): Environmental Protection Administration announcement 環署綜字第 0950006595 號 of the review conclusions and summary of the environmental impact statement for the Binnan Industrial Park development planOriginal URLhttps://gazette.nat.gov.tw/EG_FileManager/eguploadpub/eg012017/ch07/type3/gov60/num1/Eg.htmRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
    2. 02-17The Qigu Coastal Protection Association …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Qigu Coastal Protection Association and the Taiwan Environmental Protection Union (台灣環境保護聯盟) delivered a petition for administrative appeal to the Environmental Protection Administration R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.R019Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center], reports on the Binnan Industrial Park (1997–2011, 15 articles)Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    3. 08-15The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbi…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill (Sequel) (《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁(續篇)》) was published R019Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center], reports on the Binnan Industrial Park (1997–2011, 15 articles)Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    4. 10-26Pan Han-sheng (潘翰聲), a member of the Cen…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      Pan Han-sheng (潘翰聲), a member of the Central Executive Committee of the Green Party Taiwan, published a commentary with the Taiwan Environmental Information Center saying that the Binnan case was being 「在中鋼主導下重新審理」 ("re-examined under China Steel's leadership") and pushed forward by its subsidiary Chung Hung, and writing that the Regional Planning Committee had scheduled its review for the morning of the 27th R020Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center] public forum, Pan Han-sheng (潘翰聲) (member of the Central Executive Committee of the Green Party Taiwan (綠黨)),〈殭屍復活 國鳥不保──談濱南工業區開發案〉[The Zombie Rises, the National Bird in Peril: On the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project], 2006-10-26Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/node/15720Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—An opinion piece; the author was on the opposing side.. Secondhand account
    5. 11-09The 193rd meeting of the Regional Planni…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The 193rd meeting of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior sent back the feasibility planning report, its reasons including 「縣管土地未獲縣府之同意」 ("the county-administered land has not obtained the consent of the county government") R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.R014Source看守台灣協會 [Taiwan Watch Institute], Huang Huan-chang (黃煥彰),〈反對濱南工業區開發案〉[Opposing the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project], 2009-06-11Original URLhttps://www.taiwanwatch.org.tw/node/219Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    6. 11-10In the morning, environmental groups sta…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      In the morning, environmental groups staged a "Kicking the Globe Back and Forth" protest play at the gate of the Ministry of Economic Affairs; Pan Han-sheng (潘翰聲) led the slogans, and Liao Hsin-yi (廖新一) of the Environmental Protection Union spoke R021Source苦勞網 [Coolloud], Huang Shih-kai (黃詩凱),〈濱南案退回經濟部 環團諷刺官方互踢地球〉[Binnan Case Sent Back to the MOEA; Environmental Groups Mock Officials for Kicking the Globe Back and Forth], 2006-11-11Original URLhttps://www.coolloud.org.tw/node/60343Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    7. 12-04The Ministry of the Interior returned th…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Ministry of the Interior returned the case to the Ministry of Economic Affairs by letter 台內營字第 0950807299 號 R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
  13. 2007
    1. 10-18The Petitions and Appeals Committee of t…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Petitions and Appeals Committee of the Executive Yuan dismissed the developer's (Lien Ting Steel's) administrative appeal R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
  14. 2009
    1. 01-21In judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號, the Taipei …Secondhand accountMoreLess
      In judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號, the Taipei High Administrative Court (臺北高等行政法院) ruled in the developer's favor, ordering the Ministry of the Interior that it 「應作成決定」 ("shall make a decision"); the judgment names the plaintiff as Lien Ting Steel Co., Ltd. (聯鼎鋼鐵股份有限公司), with attorneys Yeh Yung-fang (葉永芳) and Liang Sui-chang (梁穗昌) as counsel and Lee Hsia-ching (李夏菁) as sub-agent R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.R022SourceTranscription on Hsieh Chih-cheng's website of Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號 (2009-01-21)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=455Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
    2. 04-09251st meeting of the Regional Planning C…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      251st meeting of the Regional Planning Committee: because the development site lay within 3 km of the Mashagou bathing beach, in the estuary area of the Daliao drainage channel, and within the Southwest Coast National Scenic Area, documents of consent from the competent authorities for those purposes had to be supplied R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
    3. 05-08The Ministry of the Interior set a deadl…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Ministry of the Interior set a deadline of 3 months for the supplementary documents (deadline 08-17) R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
    4. 08-17The deadline passed; the developer did n…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The deadline passed; the developer did not submit the supplementary documents R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
    5. 09-01By letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號, the Minis…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      By letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號, the Ministry of the Interior recommended that the Ministry of Economic Affairs reject the case, declaring the procedure terminated; any resubmission would be treated as a new case R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
    6. 10-15The Ministry of the Interior announced t…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      The Ministry of the Interior announced the establishment of Taijiang National Park, and the headquarters plaque was unveiled on 12-28; the book judges that 「台江國家公園的成立等同宣告濱南工業區開發計畫結束」 ("the establishment of Taijiang National Park was tantamount to declaring the Binnan Industrial Park development plan over") R017SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈最後記事〉[Final Chronicle] and Appendices A–E (resolutions of the 193rd and 251st meetings of the Regional Planning Committee of the Ministry of the Interior; Executive Yuan petition decision 院臺訴字第 0960092243 號; Taipei High Administrative Court judgment 96 年度訴字第 4176 號; letter 內授營綜字第 0980808544 號)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=444Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The appendices are transcriptions of the original official documents and judgment; see also the appendix pages ?p=449, ?p=452, ?p=455, ?p=458, and ?p=461.. Secondhand account
  15. 2026
    1. 08-26A report: fish ponds bought by Yieh Unit…Secondhand accountMoreLess
      A report: fish ponds bought by Yieh United Steel (燁聯) were left idle and their embankment breached, turning 50 ha of fish ponds into a disaster zone; Yieh United Steel belongs to the E-United Group (義联集團), the successor to the former Yieh Loong Group R023Source上下游 News&Market,〈天災人禍重創南部養殖業,燁聯鋼鐵購置魚塭,閒置潰堤釀災,50 公頃魚塭成災區〉[Natural and Man-Made Disasters Hit Southern Aquaculture Hard: Fish Ponds Bought by Yieh United Steel Left Idle, Embankment Breach Causes Disaster, 50 Hectares of Fish Ponds Become a Disaster Zone], 2026-08-26Original URLhttps://www.newsmarket.com.tw/blog/241944/Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—R006SourceChinese Wikipedia: 濱南工業區 [Binnan Industrial Park], 陳由豪 [Chen Yu-hao], 義联集團 [E-United Group], 林義守 [Lin Yi-shou]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%BF%B1%E5%8D%97%E5%B7%A5%E6%A5%AD%E5%8D%80Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account

Records in academic theses

5 itemsFirst items: Scale: the two investment plans were on …Background: in August 1986 former Tainan…The reductions at the conditional approv…MoreLess

Tsai Lung-yu's (蔡隆郁) 2005 master's thesis (in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University) analyzes the case through theories of the state; the figures and background it compiles are as follows R024SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁), 《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"], master's thesis, in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University (國立中山大學), 2005, pp. 1, 46, 48, 50, 95, 98, 135, 144, 153Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 1、46、48、50、95、98、135、144、153Master's thesis; its material comes from newspapers, journals, and official documents, with no interviews of its own.: Scholarly view

  1. Scale: the two investment plans were on 「台南縣七股鄉西側、台鹽鹽場第三區的土地,佔地約 2,360 公頃」 ("land in the third district of the Taiyen salt fields on the west side of Qigu Township, Tainan County, covering about 2,360 hectares"), with NT$260 billion for the seventh naphtha cracker and NT$128.3 billion for the steel mill; 「整個投資額高達台幣 3,800 多億元,可為台灣增加一年超過 1%的國民生產毛額」 ("the total investment came to more than NT$380 billion and could add over 1% a year to Taiwan's gross national product") (p. 1).
  2. Background: in August 1986 former Tainan County Magistrate Li Ya-chiao (李雅樵) proposed the "Qigu Area Comprehensive Development Plan" (七股地區綜合開發計畫), including a general amusement area, zoo and botanical garden, yacht marina, golf course, industrial zone, new town, and airport; 「『只吃鹽是不會長大的』這是李雅樵對七股鹽田地區必須要改變利用方式提高收益的看法」 ("'You won't grow up eating only salt' was Li Ya-chiao's view that the Qigu salt-field area had to change how it was used to raise its returns"); because the vision was too large and the county government could not sustain it, it was scaled down and the Qigu Industrial Zone was proposed separately (p. 46). See Qigu Industrial Park.
  3. The reductions at the conditional approval of 1999-12-17: 「以潟湖使用面積不得超過 5%,工業港另案進行環評,開發案規模由原 3,500 公頃,降為 1,379 公頃,投資金額降至 2,733 億元,年產值也減少為 2,538 億元」 ("with the area of lagoon used not to exceed 5% and the industrial harbor to undergo a separate EIA, the project was reduced from its original 3,500 hectares to 1,379 hectares, the investment to NT$273.3 billion, and the annual output value to NT$253.8 billion"); the seventh naphtha cracker's refining capacity was cut from 14 million to 7 million barrels a year, and Yieh Loong's blast furnaces from three to two (p. 144).
  4. The central government's stance: in May 1998 Hsu Wen-lung (許文龍) of Chi Mei, interviewed by the United Daily News, argued that limited land and water resources should be kept for high technology; the thesis writes 「許文龍的態度並且影響到李登輝總統對濱南案由贊成開發傾向中立」 ("Hsu Wen-lung's attitude also moved President Lee Teng-hui from favoring development of the Binnan project toward neutrality") (p. 135, citing the Economic Daily News, 1998-07-10).
  5. Outcome: the author considers that the Executive Yuan's approval on 24 January 2005 of CPC Corporation's Yunlin petrochemical technology park and Formosa Plastics' large steelworks 「已間接宣佈濱南案的命運」 ("had indirectly announced the fate of the Binnan project") (p. 95).

Discrepancies in the records

7 itemsFirst items: Who convened the land coordination of 19…On which day the "second preliminary rev…From which day the second-stage review p…MoreLess
  1. Who convened the land coordination of 1994-01-15:
    • "A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement": a four-party agreement among the Tainan County Government, Taiyen, Tuntex, and Yieh Loong R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
    • The 1993–1995 chapter: the Industrial Development Bureau invited the two conglomerates and Taiyen to coordinate R005SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement], 1993–1995 chapter (including the production record of《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast])Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=136Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.. Secondhand account
  2. On which day the "second preliminary review" of the second-stage EIA task force took place:
    • The original minutes label the meeting of 1998-07-09 the "second preliminary review" R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
    • Going by the sequence of the topic-by-topic reviews, the next meeting after 1998-04-07 was on 1998-04-24 R011SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], chapters on the second-stage environmental impact assessment review (including excerpts from the minutes of the 1998–1999 task-force meetings)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=438Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—See also https://jcshieh.tw/?p=433 and https://jcshieh.tw/?p=441. In the minutes, the scholars appear under codes (SK, SW, CH, YS, FK, HS).. Secondhand account
    • The review meeting dates listed in the Control Yuan censure text, for 1998 in order, are 04-24, 06-02, 06-15, 06-25, 07-09, and 07-17, without numbering R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
  3. From which day the second-stage review period ran:
    • 1998-02-18: Hsieh Chih-cheng records that the developers paid the fee that day; the censure text also says the developers 「復於八十七年二月十八日依環保署函示辦理」 ("then, on February 18 of [ROC] year 87, acted as instructed by the EPA's letter") R009SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈二階環評 輪番上場1998~1999〉[The Second-Stage EIA: One Round After Another, 1998–1999]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=433Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side.R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
    • 1998-02-19: the Control Yuan press release says 「自八十七年二月十九日補正評估書資料,並繳交審查費後」 ("from February 19 of [ROC] year 87, after the assessment documents were supplemented and the review fee paid") R012Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan] (environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park), 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
  4. How the review period should be counted:
    • The Control Yuan: counted in calendar days it already exceeded 120 days, and there is no legal basis for excluding holidays R012Source監察院 [Control Yuan],〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉[Censure Proposed by Control Yuan Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan] (environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park), 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
    • The Environmental Protection Administration (when questioned): excluding holidays and the days before the conclusions of the National Energy Conference were complete, the actual period was 110 days, within the limit R010SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉[The EIA Final Version: Many Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (reproduces the full text and reference numbers of the two Control Yuan censures: (八九)院台財字第892200024號 and 第892200294號; the final-version confirmation meetings of 2000–2001)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side; the censure texts are reproduced copies, as the Control Yuan website publishes only summaries in its press releases.. Secondhand account
  5. Positions in the November–December 1999 assessment dispute (paraphrased from Taipei Times's English-language reports):
    • Environmental groups and Su Huan-chih: the assessment process had clear shortcomings and the project was passed in haste, and the passage was said to be meant to please certain consortia and local Kuomintang factions R015SourceTaipei Times,Chiu Yu-tzu〈Activists slam official Web site showing Spoonbills〉(1999-12-21)[Taipei Times, Chiu Yu-tzu, "Activists slam official Web site showing Spoonbills", 1999-12-21]Original URLhttps://www.taipeitimes.com/News/local/archives/1999/12/21/0000015832Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—English-language news report; statements by environmental groups and politicians..
    • The developers: the lagoon share of the site had fallen from 29% to 19.8% R013SourceTaipei Times,頭版(1999-11-23)[Taipei Times, front page, 1999-11-23]Original URLhttps://www.taipeitimes.com/News/front/archives/1999/11/23/0000011865Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—English-language news report..
    • Local councilors or legislators: without development the residents have no future R013SourceTaipei Times,頭版(1999-11-23)[Taipei Times, front page, 1999-11-23]Original URLhttps://www.taipeitimes.com/News/front/archives/1999/11/23/0000011865Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—English-language news report..
    • County Magistrate Chen Tang-shan: development will indeed harm the environment R013SourceTaipei Times,頭版(1999-11-23)[Taipei Times, front page, 1999-11-23]Original URLhttps://www.taipeitimes.com/News/front/archives/1999/11/23/0000011865Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—English-language news report.. Secondhand account
  6. When the Qigu Industrial Zone EIA failed for the third time (written three ways in the same 2005 thesis by Tsai Lung-yu) R024SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁), 《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"], master's thesis, in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University (國立中山大學), 2005, pp. 1, 46, 48, 50, 95, 98, 135, 144, 153Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 1、46、48、50、95、98、135、144、153Master's thesis; its material comes from newspapers, journals, and official documents, with no interviews of its own.: Scholarly view
    • 1993-11-29: the EPA invited the relevant agencies and scholars to a re-review; 「這是七股工業區開發案第三度未通過環評審查,環保署將予結案不再審查」 ("this was the third time the Qigu Industrial Zone project failed its EIA review, and the EPA would close the case and not review it again") (p. 48).
    • 1994: 「該開發案環評報告在 1994 年第三度被環保署駁回宣告終結」 ("the project's EIA report was rejected by the EPA for the third time in 1994 and declared terminated") (p. 98).
    • January 1994: 「七股工業區的環境影響評估案,在 1994 年 1 月第三度被環保署駁回」 ("the Qigu Industrial Zone environmental impact assessment was rejected by the EPA for the third time in January 1994") (p. 153).
  7. How the total investment is given: Tsai Lung-yu (2005) gives 「3,800 多億元」 ("more than NT$380 billion") (p. 1) and, for July 1993, 「3,883 億資金」 ("NT$388.3 billion of capital") (p. 50); the steel-city plan Yieh Loong submitted to the Industrial Development Bureau in 1993 was NT$112 billion, which differs from the NT$128.3 billion for the steel mill recorded in the thesis R003SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智),《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill],〈反濱南記事〉[A Chronicle of the Anti-Binnan Movement]Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=464Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—The authors were participants on the opposing side; it is a day-by-day chronicle, and the facts in the book are treated as a participant's record.R024SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁), 《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"], master's thesis, in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University (國立中山大學), 2005, pp. 1, 46, 48, 50, 95, 98, 135, 144, 153Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 1、46、48、50、95、98、135、144、153Master's thesis; its material comes from newspapers, journals, and official documents, with no interviews of its own.. Secondhand accountScholarly view

See also

Reports that mention it

Hall of the Present6.5Present conditions and institutions / Industrial parks and pollution

The Binnan Industrial Park: The 16 Years It Was Held Back

A single development project merged from two conglomerates, two purposes, and one dedicated industrial port: proposed in 1993, passed its EIA in 1999, finalized by notice in 2006, and ended in 2009 through the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act — not because the EIA was overturned.

1553

Continue from here