Guided reading
Five generations of projects on the same plot of land, from the incinerator's 1989 EIA case number to the replacement furnace and the Chengxi Circular Economy Park of 2026. Residents protested from 1991 on and won compensation funds and compensation facilities; Phase 4 was suspended because of protests; the landfill caught fire four times within a year, and black water appeared in a tidal ditch in 2026. The wetland beside the landfill has four further stories: a two-year reversal on dioxin in sediment, the backfilling of fish farm ponds, poaching and enforcement, and a rejected ecotourism proposal.R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.
- Current status
- The replacement furnace on the site of the old incinerator began trial operation in 2026 and is scheduled to start operating in 2027, with the old furnace's service extended by 8 to 10 years R017Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西焚化更新爐預定明年正式營運 黃偉哲:有效提升全市垃圾處理量能〉[Chengxi Renewal Incinerator Scheduled to Begin Formal Operation Next Year; Huang Wei-che: Effectively Raising the City's Garbage Treatment Capacity], 2026-10-28Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=8843812Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R018Source聯合報 [United Daily News],〈新焚化爐明年啟用!安南承擔全台南逾半垃圾去化量 遭怨不公〉[New Incinerator Opens Next Year! Annan Bears Over Half of All Tainan's Garbage Disposal, Drawing Complaints of Unfairness], 2025-11-16, reporter Wu Shu-ling (吳淑玲)Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7326/9142116Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—; the Chengxi Circular Economy Park (1150041V, 14 ha) voluntarily entered a second-stage EIA, announced on 2026-05-29 R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.; the landfill caught fire 4 times within roughly a year, and in June black water appeared in the tidal ditch at the Qingcaolun embankment, with fish farmers and the Environmental Protection Bureau each holding to their own account R015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—R016Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island], episode 1371,〈黑水哪裡來〉[Where Does the Black Water Come From?], 2026-08-16Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/12065Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—
- Key figures
- 5 (1989–2026)EIA case numbers on the same plotR001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.
- NT$82.86 million, 12 villagesCompensation funds approved (ROC years 111–113, per year)R011Source臺南市安南區公所 [Annan District Office, Tainan City],〈111年度城西垃圾掩埋場(含焚化廠)營運回饋金 113年4月使用情形月報表〉[Monthly Report on the Use of Operating Compensation Funds for the Chengxi Landfill (Including the Incinerator), ROC Year 111, April of Year 113] (same format for years 112 and 113)Original URLhttps://w3fs.tainan.gov.tw/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQvcmVsZmlsZS8yNjI5Ni84NjM2ODgyLzJjZTIyNGFkLWFhMzgtNGJkZC1hNzUxLTk1YjMzN2JiZmM3MC5wZGY%3D&n=MTEz5bm0NOaciOS9v%2BeUqOaDheW9ouaciOWgseihqC3ln47opb8oMSkucGRmRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)The amounts approved for each village are the same in all three years, totaling NT$82,860,000 a year.
- a little over NT$298.75 millionCompensation facilities, final costR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) corrective measure on the Chengxi compensation facility (formal contract name 「臺南市夢幻水城營運管理契約」[Tainan City Dream Water City Operation and Management Contract], i.e. the Chengxi branch of the Shuiduoduo Water Park [水多多樂園]; construction began July 2000 [ROC year 89], completed June 2004 [ROC year 93], final cost a little over NT$298.75 million; the 2015 corrective measure criticized it for 「縱任……故意荒廢設施設備」 ["allowing ... the deliberate abandonment of facilities and equipment"] and 「無視該回饋設施長期閒置」 ["ignoring the long-term idleness of the compensation facility"])Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19During the off-season when it was closed to business, residents of 11 villages including Chengdong Village could use it free of charge with a compensation-village resident ID card.
- about 1,000 jiaFish ponds affected by the black waterR014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 6.82 ng-TEQ/kgSediment dioxin lower limit (exceeded in ROC year 105)R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
- Evidence mix
Why it matters
This plot on the Chengxi Village coast has passed through five identities in thirty-seven years, from incinerator and landfill to circular economy park R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.. Around 1991 the city government landfilled garbage in fish ponds along the Zengwen River; residents protested en masse and blocked the garbage trucks, winning compensation funds of more than NT$80 million a year and a water park. The park was later censured by the Control Yuan for long idleness and closed in 2020 R009Source監察院調查報告 100財調0015 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 100財調0015] (investigated by Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄), 100/02/15 [2011-02-15]): the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau's handling of garbage compensation fundsOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/52552Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Case page: https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=1089 .R008Source監察院糾正案文 104財正0017 [Control Yuan Corrective Measure 104財正0017] (proposed by Lee Yueh-te and Chen Ching-tsai; deliberated 104/11/04 [2015-11-04], announced 104/11/12 [2015-11-12])Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=4585Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R020Source自由時報 [Liberty Times],〈台南「水多多」宣布停業 環局:朝共融式公園設計規劃〉[Tainan's "Shuiduoduo" Announces Closure; Environmental Bureau: Planning Toward an Inclusive Park Design], 2020-06-04, reporter Wang Shu-hsiu (王姝琇)Original URLhttps://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/3187066Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. In 2016 Phase 4 was to be opened in the windbreak forest belt and was suspended amid protests; in 2025–2026 the landfill caught fire repeatedly and black water welled up in the tidal ditch R014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—R015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—R016Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island], episode 1371,〈黑水哪裡來〉[Where Does the Black Water Come From?], 2026-08-16Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/12065Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Right beside the landfill lies the Chengxi wetland; a report commissioned by Taijiang National Park lists three pollution sources — the Chengxi Incinerator, the Tainan Technology Industrial Park and the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant — alongside three settlements: Chengxi, Luermen and Tucheng R004SourceThe five Chengxi thematic reports (766 pp.), including 《城西濕地水文》[Hydrology of the Chengxi Wetland], 《兩棲爬蟲》[Amphibians and Reptiles], 《哺乳類》[Mammals], and 《陸蟹》[Land Crabs], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park HeadquartersOriginal URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Page 14 of *Hydrology* is the only place in the Taijiang National Park Headquarters' commissioned reports that lists the three pollution sources alongside the three settlements..
Main actors
Local government 1
- Environmental Protection Bureau, Tainan City Government (臺南市政府環境保護局)Developer and competent authority for all five generations of works; competent authority for the compensation fundsR001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.
Control Yuan 2
- Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄)Investigated in 2011 the failure to put the compensation funds on a legal footingR009Source監察院調查報告 100財調0015 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 100財調0015] (investigated by Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄), 100/02/15 [2011-02-15]): the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau's handling of garbage compensation fundsOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/52552Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Case page: https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=1089 .
- Lee Yueh-te (李月德), Chen Ching-tsai (陳慶財)Censured the "long idleness" of the compensation facilities in 2015R008Source監察院糾正案文 104財正0017 [Control Yuan Corrective Measure 104財正0017] (proposed by Lee Yueh-te and Chen Ching-tsai; deliberated 104/11/04 [2015-11-04], announced 104/11/12 [2015-11-12])Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=4585Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Local residents 3
- People of the Chengxi areaProtested en masse around 1991; when the incinerator's construction began in 1995 there were "repeated protests and blockades"R007Source監察院調查報告 104財調0040 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 104財調0040] (investigated by Lee Yueh-te (李月德) and Chen Ching-tsai (陳慶財), deliberated 2015-11-04), full text: management and operation of the compensation facilities of the Chengxi IncineratorOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/48718Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)「自民國(下同)83年7月1日起改將垃圾掩埋於城西里垃圾掩埋場,且自84年5月1日起動工興建城西垃圾焚化廠」 ("from 1 July [ROC year] 83 (and likewise below) garbage was instead landfilled at the Chengxi Village landfill, and from 1 May [year] 84 construction of the Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant began").
- Yen Wen-cheng (嚴文正)Chief of Chengxi Village; led residents to inspect the derelict compensation facilities in 2012; signed the eco-friendly fish pond letter of intent in 2018R019Source公視新聞 [PTS News],〈廠商放任荒廢 親水樂園變垃圾場〉[Left to Decay by the Operator, a Water Park Becomes a Garbage Dump], 2012-08-06Original URLhttps://news.pts.org.tw/article/217361Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 12 villages of Annan DistrictRecipients of the compensation funds; Chengxi Village receives the most, NT$20.36 million a yearR011Source臺南市安南區公所 [Annan District Office, Tainan City],〈111年度城西垃圾掩埋場(含焚化廠)營運回饋金 113年4月使用情形月報表〉[Monthly Report on the Use of Operating Compensation Funds for the Chengxi Landfill (Including the Incinerator), ROC Year 111, April of Year 113] (same format for years 112 and 113)Original URLhttps://w3fs.tainan.gov.tw/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQvcmVsZmlsZS8yNjI5Ni84NjM2ODgyLzJjZTIyNGFkLWFhMzgtNGJkZC1hNzUxLTk1YjMzN2JiZmM3MC5wZGY%3D&n=MTEz5bm0NOaciOS9v%2BeUqOaDheW9ouaciOWgseihqC3ln47opb8oMSkucGRmRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)The amounts approved for each village are the same in all three years, totaling NT$82,860,000 a year.
Elected representatives 1
- Kuo Ching-hua (郭清華)Called for the old furnace to be scrapped within 8 years of the replacement furnace starting up and the site turned into a parkR018Source聯合報 [United Daily News],〈新焚化爐明年啟用!安南承擔全台南逾半垃圾去化量 遭怨不公〉[New Incinerator Opens Next Year! Annan Bears Over Half of All Tainan's Garbage Disposal, Drawing Complaints of Unfairness], 2025-11-16, reporter Wu Shu-ling (吳淑玲)Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7326/9142116Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Scholars 1
- Chang Yuan-mou (張原謀), Huang Wen-po (黃文伯)National University of Tainan; opposed Phase 4 in 2016R014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
National park 1
- Taijiang National Park HeadquartersCommissioned habitat-creation and ecological surveys of the Chengxi wetlandR003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
Commissioned survey team 1
- Habitat-creation project teamRecommended leasing or buying the Chengxi Street hotspot ponds; warned ecotourism crowds would scare waterbirdsR003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
Points of contention
These are the questions people have argued over. Each side's account is set out as stated; this site does not rule on them.
1With garbage having nowhere to go, should Phase 4 of the landfill be opened in the windbreak forest belt?2
- City government (2016)
The Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis completed review in 2015; 6.88792 ha after subdivision of the development siteR001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.
- Scholars including Chang Yuan-mou and Huang Wen-po
Opposed Phase 4, arguing that the windbreak belt should be seen from the standpoint of the whole ecosystem; Deputy Mayor Tseng Shu-cheng (曾旭正) announced that the whole project was suspendedR014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- City government (2016)
2Once the replacement furnace starts up, should the old furnace be retired on schedule?2
- City Councilor Kuo Ching-hua
The new and old furnaces together would handle about 64% of the city's garbage; the old furnace should be scrapped within 8 years and the site rebuilt as a parkR018Source聯合報 [United Daily News],〈新焚化爐明年啟用!安南承擔全台南逾半垃圾去化量 遭怨不公〉[New Incinerator Opens Next Year! Annan Bears Over Half of All Tainan's Garbage Disposal, Drawing Complaints of Unfairness], 2025-11-16, reporter Wu Shu-ling (吳淑玲)Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7326/9142116Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau
Extending the old furnace's service by 8 to 10 years would better ensure that the temporarily stored garbage is clearedR018Source聯合報 [United Daily News],〈新焚化爐明年啟用!安南承擔全台南逾半垃圾去化量 遭怨不公〉[New Incinerator Opens Next Year! Annan Bears Over Half of All Tainan's Garbage Disposal, Drawing Complaints of Unfairness], 2025-11-16, reporter Wu Shu-ling (吳淑玲)Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7326/9142116Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- City Councilor Kuo Ching-hua
3Did the black water in the tidal ditch in 2026 seep out of the landfill?3
- SGS testing commissioned by fish farmers
COD 212, BOD 64.1, ammonia nitrogen 26.0 mg/LR015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- Third-party testing
Chia Nan University of Pharmacy and Science judged it "suspected leachate"; another testing body "found none"R014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- Environmental Protection Bureau Director Hsu Jen-tse (許仁澤)
Answered accusations of illicit discharge by "staking my official post" on itR015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- SGS testing commissioned by fish farmers
4Is the Chengxi wetland sediment clean enough for habitat creation?2
- ROC year 105 (2016) survey
Dioxin at the tidal-creek, wetland and windbreak stations exceeded the lower limit; "not suitable for immediate habitat creation"R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
- ROC year 106 (2017) re-test
All four stations "did not exceed the lower limit or the total limit", but the windbreak station was not resampledR003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
- ROC year 105 (2016) survey
5Should the national park lease or buy the abandoned fish ponds that are being filled in, to protect them?2
- Commissioned survey report
Recommended negotiating with private pond owners to protect the Chengxi Street hotspot "by lease or purchase"R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
- Taijiang National Park Headquarters (2020)
Neither leased nor bought, turning instead to "voluntary participation plus ecosystem-service allowance"R005Source《109 年度國際遷移物種生態友善棲地營造試驗計畫》[2020 (ROC year 109) Pilot Project for Eco-friendly Habitat Creation for International Migratory Species], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (printed pp. 33, 38, 55, 56)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Coordinates, daily water levels, and bird monitoring for the pilot fish farm pond in Chengxi; the original wording is 「飛越魚塭」 ("flying over the fish pond"), not 「停棲覓食」 ("perching and foraging").
- Commissioned survey report
6Should Chengxi be developed for ecotourism?3
- Chief of the Planning and Management Section, Taijiang National Park Headquarters
Asked whether the Chengxi bird hotspots could be assessed as ecotourism sitesR003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
- Project team
The hotspots are mostly roadside private ponds; "too many visitors easily frighten the waterbirds"R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.
- Land Crab report (2020)
The Cardisoma carnifex population at Qingcaolun could support land-crab ecotourism by Chengxi Village residents, a win for all three partiesR004SourceThe five Chengxi thematic reports (766 pp.), including 《城西濕地水文》[Hydrology of the Chengxi Wetland], 《兩棲爬蟲》[Amphibians and Reptiles], 《哺乳類》[Mammals], and 《陸蟹》[Land Crabs], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park HeadquartersOriginal URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Page 14 of *Hydrology* is the only place in the Taijiang National Park Headquarters' commissioned reports that lists the three pollution sources alongside the three settlements.
- Chief of the Planning and Management Section, Taijiang National Park Headquarters
Turning points
- 1989Incinerator EIA (0780652A, 14.5 ha)R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.
- 1991Garbage landfilled in fish ponds along the Zengwen River; residents protest en masseR009Source監察院調查報告 100財調0015 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 100財調0015] (investigated by Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄), 100/02/15 [2011-02-15]): the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau's handling of garbage compensation fundsOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/52552Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Case page: https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=1089 .
- 1994-07-01Nanshalun landfill saturated; garbage shipped to ChengxiR007Source監察院調查報告 104財調0040 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 104財調0040] (investigated by Lee Yueh-te (李月德) and Chen Ching-tsai (陳慶財), deliberated 2015-11-04), full text: management and operation of the compensation facilities of the Chengxi IncineratorOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/48718Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)「自民國(下同)83年7月1日起改將垃圾掩埋於城西里垃圾掩埋場,且自84年5月1日起動工興建城西垃圾焚化廠」 ("from 1 July [ROC year] 83 (and likewise below) garbage was instead landfilled at the Chengxi Village landfill, and from 1 May [year] 84 construction of the Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant began").
- 2015Control Yuan censures the compensation facilities; Phase 4 EIA difference analysis (Phase 4 never built)R008Source監察院糾正案文 104財正0017 [Control Yuan Corrective Measure 104財正0017] (proposed by Lee Yueh-te and Chen Ching-tsai; deliberated 104/11/04 [2015-11-04], announced 104/11/12 [2015-11-12])Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=4585Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 2016Phase 4 sparks protests; the deputy mayor announces the whole project suspendedR014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 2025–2026The landfill catches fire 4 times within about a yearR015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 2026Replacement furnace in trial operation; Chengxi Circular Economy Park enters second-stage EIA; black water in the tidal ditchR017Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西焚化更新爐預定明年正式營運 黃偉哲:有效提升全市垃圾處理量能〉[Chengxi Renewal Incinerator Scheduled to Begin Formal Operation Next Year; Huang Wei-che: Effectively Raising the City's Garbage Treatment Capacity], 2026-10-28Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=8843812Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Where to start reading
- EntryChengxi Landfill and IncineratorThe Chengxi Landfill and Incinerator is a group of waste-disposal facilities in the coastal windbreak forest belt of Chengxi Village, Annan District, Tainan, comprising the Chengxi Refuse Incinerator completed in 1999, the sanitary landfill phases in use since 1994, and a replacement furnace that began trial operation in 2026.
- EntryChengxi Windbreak ForestThe Chengxi Windbreak Forest is a coastal windbreak forest between the Luermen and Zengwen river mouths in Chengxi Village, Annan District, about 4.5 km long, the largest in Tainan City and the largest habitat of the Hoppo cicada.
- EntryBrown Land Crab (Cardisoma carnifex)The brown land crab (Cardisoma carnifex) is a large land crab of the family Cardisomatidae with a carapace up to 13 cm wide; the population of Qingcaolun and Chengxi on the south bank of the Zengwen River in Taijiang is the largest known in Taiwan.
- Reports 6.2The Taiwan Alkali Anshun PlantA complete chronology from the plant's founding in 1938 to the site-wide verification of 2026, for Taiwan's first designated remediation site, D00001. This page also covers the two-year reversal in sediment downstream in the Luermen River, the full procedure of one inter-agency site inspection, and the Jian'an Substitute Elementary School (1947–1971).
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
What it is
The same plot of land, starting with an incinerator in 1989, has passed through five identities in thirty-seven years.
History
Case numbers of the five generations of projects R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.: Official record
- 1989 0780652A Incinerator, 14.5 hectares
- 1997 0860011V Phase 3, 10.7 hectares
- 2003 0920011V General industrial waste including ash residue, 7 hectares; notice 南市環管字第 09204009040 號 of 2003-04-28
- 2015 1040088V Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 hectares after subdivision of the development site; Phase 4 was never actually built
- 2026 1150041V Chengxi Circular Economy Park (城西循環園區), 14 hectares, voluntarily entering second-stage environmental impact assessment (EIA); notice of 2026-05-29
There are two further downstream treatment facilities for Chengxi ash residue R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], case numbers of the five generations on the same Chengxi plot (0780652A, 1989, incinerator, 14.5 ha/0860011V, 1997, Phase 3, 10.7 ha/0920011V, 2003, general industrial waste including ash residue, 7 ha, notice of 2003-04-28, 南市環管字第 09204009040 號/1040088V, 2015, Phase 4 environmental impact difference analysis, 6.88792 ha/1150041V, 2026, Chengxi Circular Economy Park, 14 ha, voluntarily entering second-stage EIA, notice of 2026-05-29); also 0920161A bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant and 0920401A fly-ash melting and reuse plantOriginal URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Ministry of Environment EIA document search system; the full text of the review conclusions of the original 1989 EIA is not attached in the system.:
- 0920161A Bottom-ash primary screening and reuse plant (1.2 hectares, 2003-06-17)
- 0920401A Fly-ash melting and reuse plant (0.7 hectares, 2004-01-30)
Compensation won through protest
First items: 1994-07-01 The Nanshalun Landfill (南沙崙掩埋…1995-05-01 Construction of the Chengxi R…Control Yuan: construction began on 1995…MoreLess
Chengxi's garbage story began with a protest that blocked the garbage trucks.
The Control Yuan's 2011 investigation report puts it this way: 「80年間臺南市政府為解決該市70多萬人口垃圾問題,於城西地區曾文溪沿岸魚塭填埋垃圾,當地居民不滿家園遭受污染,群體抗爭,阻擋垃圾車進場」 ("in [ROC year] 80 [1991], to solve the garbage problem of the city's more than 700,000 people, the Tainan City Government landfilled garbage in fish ponds along the Zengwen River in the Chengxi area; local residents, unhappy that their homes were being polluted, protested en masse and blocked the garbage trucks from entering"); only after the city government and residents agreed on compensation terms did it 「順利解決垃圾掩埋問題」 ("smoothly resolve the garbage landfill problem") R009Source監察院調查報告 100財調0015 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 100財調0015] (investigated by Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄), 100/02/15 [2011-02-15]): the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau's handling of garbage compensation fundsOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/52552Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Case page: https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=1089 .. Official record
The next two dates come from the Control Yuan's 2015 report R007Source監察院調查報告 104財調0040 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 104財調0040] (investigated by Lee Yueh-te (李月德) and Chen Ching-tsai (陳慶財), deliberated 2015-11-04), full text: management and operation of the compensation facilities of the Chengxi IncineratorOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/48718Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—「自民國(下同)83年7月1日起改將垃圾掩埋於城西里垃圾掩埋場,且自84年5月1日起動工興建城西垃圾焚化廠」 ("from 1 July [ROC year] 83 (and likewise below) garbage was instead landfilled at the Chengxi Village landfill, and from 1 May [year] 84 construction of the Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant began").: Official record
- 1994-07-01 The Nanshalun Landfill (南沙崙掩埋場) reached capacity, and the former Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau began landfilling garbage at the Chengxi (城西) Village landfill instead.
- 1995-05-01 Construction of the Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant began; residents believed it would affect local quality of life and sanitation, and there were 「屢有抗爭圍堵行動」 ("repeated protests and blockades").
To this day there are three accounts of when the incinerator's construction began and ended R007Source監察院調查報告 104財調0040 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 104財調0040] (investigated by Lee Yueh-te (李月德) and Chen Ching-tsai (陳慶財), deliberated 2015-11-04), full text: management and operation of the compensation facilities of the Chengxi IncineratorOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/48718Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—「自民國(下同)83年7月1日起改將垃圾掩埋於城西里垃圾掩埋場,且自84年5月1日起動工興建城西垃圾焚化廠」 ("from 1 July [ROC year] 83 (and likewise below) garbage was instead landfilled at the Chengxi Village landfill, and from 1 May [year] 84 construction of the Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant began").R013SourceChinese Wikipedia: 城西垃圾焚化廠 [Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/zh-tw/%E5%9F%8E%E8%A5%BF%E5%9E%83%E5%9C%BE%E7%84%9A%E5%8C%96%E5%BB%A0Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Its history section cites only one source, the Ministry of Environment's 「臺南市城西焚化廠建廠摘述」 ("Summary of the Construction of the Chengxi Incinerator, Tainan City"), whose original page is now a login page.R012SourceOld website of Tucheng Elementary School, local-studies subsite, pages 〈菅仔埔的春天〉[Spring in Jianaipu] and 〈城西焚化爐〉[The Chengxi Incinerator] (snapshot of 2002-03-20) (Wayback Machine snapshot; the original site has been closed)Original URLhttps://web.archive.org/web/20020320204505/http://www.tcps.tn.edu.tw:80/teach/country/factory_burngarbage.htmRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The school page cites no source; 「85 年 8 月完工啟用」 ("completed and put into service in August [ROC year] 85") may have been a planned date; unverified.:
- Control Yuan: construction began on 1995-05-01. Official record
- Wikipedia: the contract was awarded on 1993-04-29 (given in the infobox as the start of construction), the contractor entered the work site only on 1995-01-11, the furnace was lit on 1998-05-21, and construction was formally completed on 1999-02-16. Secondhand account
- Old Tucheng Elementary School website (2002 Wayback Machine snapshot): 「於民國八十三年元月四日開工,八十五年八月完工啟用」 ("construction began on January 4 of ROC year 83 [1994], and it was completed and put into service in August of [ROC year] 85 [1996]"). Unverified
Compensation funds were budgeted from fiscal year 83 (1994) and disbursed to the villages through the Annan District Office (安南區公所) R009Source監察院調查報告 100財調0015 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 100財調0015] (investigated by Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄), 100/02/15 [2011-02-15]): the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau's handling of garbage compensation fundsOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/52552Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Case page: https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=1089 .. In 2011 they came to NT$82.62 million a year, or more than NT$600 for every metric ton of garbage treated, above the standard of NT$200 per ton, which is why the Control Yuan investigated the long delay in putting them on a legal footing R009Source監察院調查報告 100財調0015 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 100財調0015] (investigated by Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄), 100/02/15 [2011-02-15]): the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau's handling of garbage compensation fundsOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/52552Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Case page: https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=1089 .. In 2012 the city government issued regulations on the compensation funds, under which NT$30 million a year is reserved for school lunches and schooling subsidies; the recipient villages are the 12 villages of Chengdong (城東), Chengxi, Chengnan (城南), Chengbei (城北), Chengzhong (城中), Qingcao (青草), Shalun (砂崙), Xuedong (學東), Sicao (四草), Mazugong (媽祖宮), Yantian (鹽田), and Luer (鹿耳) R010Source《臺南市垃圾焚化廠及掩埋場營運階段提供回饋金辦法》[Tainan City Regulations on Compensation Funds During the Operation of Refuse Incinerators and Landfills] (promulgated by the Tainan City Government 101-01-02 [2012-01-02], amended 114-02-19 [2025-02-19])Original URLhttps://www.tnepb.gov.tw/upload/%E8%87%BA%E5%8D%97%E5%B8%82%E5%9E%83%E5%9C%BE%E7%84%9A%E5%8C%96%E5%BB%A0%E5%8F%8A%E6%8E%A9%E5%9F%8B%E5%A0%B4%E7%87%9F%E9%81%8B%E9%9A%8E%E6%AE%B5%E6%8F%90%E4%BE%9B%E5%9B%9E%E9%A5%8B%E9%87%91%E8%BE%A6%E6%B3%95.pdfRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record For fiscal years 111 to 113 (2022–2024), the amount approved on the district office's monthly reports was NT$82.86 million each year, with Chengxi Village receiving the most at NT$20.36 million and Qingcao Village next at NT$9 million R011Source臺南市安南區公所 [Annan District Office, Tainan City],〈111年度城西垃圾掩埋場(含焚化廠)營運回饋金 113年4月使用情形月報表〉[Monthly Report on the Use of Operating Compensation Funds for the Chengxi Landfill (Including the Incinerator), ROC Year 111, April of Year 113] (same format for years 112 and 113)Original URLhttps://w3fs.tainan.gov.tw/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQvcmVsZmlsZS8yNjI5Ni84NjM2ODgyLzJjZTIyNGFkLWFhMzgtNGJkZC1hNzUxLTk1YjMzN2JiZmM3MC5wZGY%3D&n=MTEz5bm0NOaciOS9v%2BeUqOaDheW9ouaciOWgseihqC3ln47opb8oMSkucGRmRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The amounts approved for each village are the same in all three years, totaling NT$82,860,000 a year.. Official record
The compensation facility
MoreLess
The formal contract name is the "Tainan City Dream Water City Operation and Management Contract" (「臺南市夢幻水城營運管理契約」), i.e. the Chengxi branch of the Shuiduoduo Water Park (水多多樂園); construction began in July 2000 (ROC year 89) and was completed in June 2004 (ROC year 93), at a final cost of a little over NT$298.75 million. In 2015 the Control Yuan (監察院) issued a corrective measure, using the wording 「縱任……故意荒廢設施設備」 ("allowing ... the deliberate abandonment of facilities and equipment") and 「無視該回饋設施長期閒置」 ("ignoring the long-term idleness of the compensation facility") R002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) corrective measure on the Chengxi compensation facility (formal contract name 「臺南市夢幻水城營運管理契約」[Tainan City Dream Water City Operation and Management Contract], i.e. the Chengxi branch of the Shuiduoduo Water Park [水多多樂園]; construction began July 2000 [ROC year 89], completed June 2004 [ROC year 93], final cost a little over NT$298.75 million; the 2015 corrective measure criticized it for 「縱任……故意荒廢設施設備」 ["allowing ... the deliberate abandonment of facilities and equipment"] and 「無視該回饋設施長期閒置」 ["ignoring the long-term idleness of the compensation facility"])Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19During the off-season when it was closed to business, residents of 11 villages including Chengdong Village could use it free of charge with a compensation-village resident ID card.R008Source監察院糾正案文 104財正0017 [Control Yuan Corrective Measure 104財正0017] (proposed by Lee Yueh-te and Chen Ching-tsai; deliberated 104/11/04 [2015-11-04], announced 104/11/12 [2015-11-12])Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=4585Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
The park went by three names: Dream Water City (夢幻水城), Tainan Shuidingdang (台南水叮噹), and the Chengxi branch of the Shuiduoduo Water Park. In the summer of 2012, when it still had not opened, Chengxi Village chief Yen Wen-cheng (嚴文正) led residents inside to look; the lazy river was overgrown with algae and full of garbage. He said: 「變成垃圾河 這種水不用 一定要整理掉」 ("it's become a garbage river; this water is no use, it has to be cleaned up") R019Source公視新聞 [PTS News],〈廠商放任荒廢 親水樂園變垃圾場〉[Left to Decay by the Operator, a Water Park Becomes a Garbage Dump], 2012-08-06Original URLhttps://news.pts.org.tw/article/217361Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account In June 2020, after the Environmental Protection Bureau's search for an operator went through 「招標公告5次、流標5次」 ("5 tender notices, 5 failed tenders"), Shuiduoduo announced its closure R020Source自由時報 [Liberty Times],〈台南「水多多」宣布停業 環局:朝共融式公園設計規劃〉[Tainan's "Shuiduoduo" Announces Closure; Environmental Bureau: Planning Toward an Inclusive Park Design], 2020-06-04, reporter Wang Shu-hsiu (王姝琇)Original URLhttps://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/3187066Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account When the BOT contract for the replacement furnace was signed in 2023, the city government planned the site as an all-ages inclusive park and a venue for environmental education and local revitalization R021Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西垃圾焚化廠更新爐BOT簽約 預計115年完工營運 黃偉哲盼如期完工〉[BOT Contract Signed for the Chengxi Refuse Incinerator Renewal Furnace, Expected to Be Completed and Operating in (ROC Year) 115; Huang Wei-che Hopes for On-Time Completion], 2023-02-03Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=7947980Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Phase 4, fires, and black water
- In 2016, Phase 4 was to be opened in the Chengxi windbreak forest belt, with a total area of 14 hectares, 7 hectares to be developed first; the scholars Chang Yuan-mou (張原謀) and Huang Wen-po (黃文伯) opposed it, and Deputy Mayor Tseng Shu-cheng (曾旭正) announced that the whole project was suspended R014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- From 2025-11-30 the landfill's garbage piles caught fire again and again; by 2026-01-08 there had been 4 fires within about a year, and the Environmental Protection Bureau switched to 24-hour patrols by staff R015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- On 2026-06-19 and 06-20, black water appeared in the tidal ditch at the Qingcaolun (青草崙) embankment, affecting about 1,000 jia (甲, a traditional land unit of about 0.97 hectare) of fish ponds in the Annan Gangxi aquaculture area (安南港西養殖區) R014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—R016Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island], episode 1371,〈黑水哪裡來〉[Where Does the Black Water Come From?], 2026-08-16Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/12065Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- SGS testing commissioned by fish farmers: COD 212, BOD 64.1, ammonia nitrogen 26.0 mg/L R015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.
- Chia Nan University of Pharmacy and Science (嘉南藥理大學) judged it 「疑似滲出水」 ("suspected leachate"); another testing body 「未發現」 ("found none") R014Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island],〈掩埋台江〉[Burying Taijiang] (2016-04-04) and〈海岸上的生態樂園|台南城西防風林〉[An Ecological Paradise on the Coast: The Chengxi Windbreak Forest, Tainan] (2017-09-04)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/2463Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.
- Environmental Protection Bureau Director Hsu Jen-tse (許仁澤) answered accusations of illicit discharge by 「賭上烏紗帽」 ("staking my official post") on it R015Source中央社 [Central News Agency], 工商時報 [Commercial Times], 中時 [China Times], and 公視新聞 [PTS News]: reports on the Chengxi landfill fires and the black-water incident, 2025-11 to 2026-07Original URLhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9612AwZ1WIRetrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.
The replacement furnace
First items: 2023-02-03 Contract signed, with operati…2023-12-28 Construction formally began (…2026-02-10 Ignition ceremony; 03-09 furn…MoreLess
The old incinerator had been running for more than 20 years and could treat only 600 metric tons a day, so the city government is building a replacement furnace on the original site under a BOT arrangement R021Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西垃圾焚化廠更新爐BOT簽約 預計115年完工營運 黃偉哲盼如期完工〉[BOT Contract Signed for the Chengxi Refuse Incinerator Renewal Furnace, Expected to Be Completed and Operating in (ROC Year) 115; Huang Wei-che Hopes for On-Time Completion], 2023-02-03Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=7947980Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 2023-02-03 Contract signed, with operation expected in ROC year 115 (2026) R021Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西垃圾焚化廠更新爐BOT簽約 預計115年完工營運 黃偉哲盼如期完工〉[BOT Contract Signed for the Chengxi Refuse Incinerator Renewal Furnace, Expected to Be Completed and Operating in (ROC Year) 115; Huang Wei-che Hopes for On-Time Completion], 2023-02-03Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=7947980Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—.
- 2023-12-28 Construction formally began (per the city government's 2026 news release) R017Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西焚化更新爐預定明年正式營運 黃偉哲:有效提升全市垃圾處理量能〉[Chengxi Renewal Incinerator Scheduled to Begin Formal Operation Next Year; Huang Wei-che: Effectively Raising the City's Garbage Treatment Capacity], 2026-10-28Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=8843812Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—.
- 2026-02-10 Ignition ceremony; 03-09 furnace drying; 05-21 trial operation with waste feed; continuous-operation performance testing in December R017Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西焚化更新爐預定明年正式營運 黃偉哲:有效提升全市垃圾處理量能〉[Chengxi Renewal Incinerator Scheduled to Begin Formal Operation Next Year; Huang Wei-che: Effectively Raising the City's Garbage Treatment Capacity], 2026-10-28Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=8843812Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—.
- 2026-10-28 The city government now says formal operation will begin in ROC year 116 (2027), treating 900 metric tons a day R017Source臺南市政府新聞 [Tainan City Government news release],〈城西焚化更新爐預定明年正式營運 黃偉哲:有效提升全市垃圾處理量能〉[Chengxi Renewal Incinerator Scheduled to Begin Formal Operation Next Year; Huang Wei-che: Effectively Raising the City's Garbage Treatment Capacity], 2026-10-28Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=8843812Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—.
City Councilor Kuo Ching-hua (郭清華) calculated that with both the new and old furnaces running, Annan would handle about 64% of the whole city's garbage, and called for the old furnace to be scrapped within 8 years and the site rebuilt as a park; the Environmental Protection Bureau plans instead to extend the old furnace's service by 8 to 10 years to clear about 820,000 metric tons of temporarily stored garbage R018Source聯合報 [United Daily News],〈新焚化爐明年啟用!安南承擔全台南逾半垃圾去化量 遭怨不公〉[New Incinerator Opens Next Year! Annan Bears Over Half of All Tainan's Garbage Disposal, Drawing Complaints of Unfairness], 2025-11-16, reporter Wu Shu-ling (吳淑玲)Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7326/9142116Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account

Sediment and fish farm ponds in the Chengxi Wetland
First items: A two-year reversal on dioxin in sedimentBackfilled fish farm ponds and "lease or purchase"Eco-friendly fish farm pondsMoreLess
A two-year reversal on dioxin in sediment
The conclusion for 2016 (ROC year 105) was that dioxin levels in the sediment at the tidal-creek, wetland, and windbreak-forest stations exceeded the lower limit of 6.82 ng-TEQ/kg in the Regulations on Classified Management and Use Restrictions under Sediment Quality Indicators (《底泥品質指標之分類管理及用途限制辦法》), while mercury did not exceed the standard; 「因為戴奧辛濃度高於規定下限值,不適宜立即做棲地營造」 ("because the dioxin concentration is above the prescribed lower limit, it is not suitable to carry out habitat creation immediately") R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.. The 2017 (ROC year 106) retest found none of the four stations over the limit (0.64/0.97/1.33/3.36 ng-TEQ/kg; 0.10–0.28 pg-TEQ/g w.w. in fish and shrimp tissue, against a limit of 6.5), concluding that they 「皆未超過下限值或總合限值」 ("all did not exceed the lower limit or the total limit") R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.. Official recordUnverifiedThe combination of sampling stations differed between the two years: in 2016 the stations over the limit were the windbreak-forest and tidal-creek stations, and in 2017 the windbreak-forest station was not resampled.
Hydrology of the Chengxi Wetland (《城西濕地水文》) also lists three pollution sources alongside three settlements: 「鄰近城西濕地的村落包括城西聚落、鹿耳門社區及土城聚落等;環境中潛在的汙染源則有城西里西側的城西垃圾焚化廠、鹿耳門溪東側的台南科技工業區以及廢棄的台鹼安順廠」 ("the villages near the Chengxi Wetland include the Chengxi settlement, the Luermen Community, and the Tucheng settlement; potential pollution sources in the environment are the Chengxi Incinerator on the west side of Chengxi Village, the Tainan Technology Industrial Park on the east side of the Luermen River, and the abandoned Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant") R004SourceThe five Chengxi thematic reports (766 pp.), including 《城西濕地水文》[Hydrology of the Chengxi Wetland], 《兩棲爬蟲》[Amphibians and Reptiles], 《哺乳類》[Mammals], and 《陸蟹》[Land Crabs], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park HeadquartersOriginal URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Page 14 of *Hydrology* is the only place in the Taijiang National Park Headquarters' commissioned reports that lists the three pollution sources alongside the three settlements.. This passage leads directly into 6.2.
Backfilled fish farm ponds and "lease or purchase"
The official report reads: 「目前各熱點棲地皆維持原有棲地外型或是養殖模式,唯有城西街熱點棲地有重大改變。城西街熱點棲地為廢棄魚塭,目前有部分魚塭面積已經回填底土……後續建議管理單位與私人魚塭地主協商,是否能以承租或購買方式,保護整塊城西街熱點棲地」 ("at present every hotspot habitat retains its original form or aquaculture mode; only the Chengxi Street hotspot habitat has undergone major change. The Chengxi Street hotspot habitat consists of abandoned fish farm ponds, part of whose area has now been backfilled with soil ... it is recommended that the managing agency negotiate with the private fish pond landowners as to whether the entire Chengxi Street hotspot habitat can be protected by lease or purchase") R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.. Official record
But the official position retreated within a year: the second advisory panel meeting of 2020 (2020-05-06 [ROC 109-05-06], held at the Chengxi Village Activity Center) resolved only that 「城西里廢棄魚塭部分,台江國家公園可評估是否進行管理,依據魚塭現況劃分 ABC 等級,進行生態友善棲地營造規劃」 ("regarding the abandoned fish ponds in Chengxi Village, Taijiang National Park may assess whether to manage them, classify them into grades A, B, and C according to their present condition, and plan the creation of eco-friendly habitat"); by the end of 2020, the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (台江處) had neither leased nor purchased the land, and had switched to a 「自願參與+生態服務津貼」 ("voluntary participation plus ecosystem-service allowance") approach R005Source《109 年度國際遷移物種生態友善棲地營造試驗計畫》[2020 (ROC year 109) Pilot Project for Eco-friendly Habitat Creation for International Migratory Species], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (printed pp. 33, 38, 55, 56)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Coordinates, daily water levels, and bird monitoring for the pilot fish farm pond in Chengxi; the original wording is 「飛越魚塭」 ("flying over the fish pond"), not 「停棲覓食」 ("perching and foraging")..
Eco-friendly fish farm ponds
The fish farm pond offered by the chief of Chengxi Village (城西里): total area 13 hectares, of which 2.9 hectares were offered for eco-friendly habitat creation; Grade C (ordinary fish pond); stocked with milkfish, milkfish fry, and whiteleg shrimp; official coordinates 23.06546098 N/120.09742583 E R005Source《109 年度國際遷移物種生態友善棲地營造試驗計畫》[2020 (ROC year 109) Pilot Project for Eco-friendly Habitat Creation for International Migratory Species], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (printed pp. 33, 38, 55, 56)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Coordinates, daily water levels, and bird monitoring for the pilot fish farm pond in Chengxi; the original wording is 「飛越魚塭」 ("flying over the fish pond"), not 「停棲覓食」 ("perching and foraging").. The report writes 「魚塭在整池時間,每池約可出現 50 隻以上黑面琵鷺」 ("during pond preparation, more than 50 black-faced spoonbills can appear at each pond") and 「整池時間在每年 10 月份,與黑面琵鷺度冬期(9 月–3 月)重疊」 ("pond preparation takes place each October, overlapping with the black-faced spoonbill's wintering period (September–March)") R005Source《109 年度國際遷移物種生態友善棲地營造試驗計畫》[2020 (ROC year 109) Pilot Project for Eco-friendly Habitat Creation for International Migratory Species], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (printed pp. 33, 38, 55, 56)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Coordinates, daily water levels, and bird monitoring for the pilot fish farm pond in Chengxi; the original wording is 「飛越魚塭」 ("flying over the fish pond"), not 「停棲覓食」 ("perching and foraging").. Five days of pond-drying monitoring from 2020-10-19 to 10-23 (ROC 109/10/19–10/23): water levels of 10/12/15/12/10 centimeters, bird species 34/33/30/25/35, individuals 398/143/470/212/174; black-faced spoonbills were marked "yes" on three days, but the original wording is 「飛越魚塭」 ("flying over the fish pond") R005Source《109 年度國際遷移物種生態友善棲地營造試驗計畫》[2020 (ROC year 109) Pilot Project for Eco-friendly Habitat Creation for International Migratory Species], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (printed pp. 33, 38, 55, 56)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Coordinates, daily water levels, and bird monitoring for the pilot fish farm pond in Chengxi; the original wording is 「飛越魚塭」 ("flying over the fish pond"), not 「停棲覓食」 ("perching and foraging").. Official recordIn the official record, the black-faced spoonbills flew over on these five days and did not land in this pilot pond. Details of the scheme: an ecosystem-service allowance of NT$5,000 per hectare per 5 days (originally to be named 「漁獲損失補償」, "compensation for catch losses"); only 2 unified identity signs were installed in all of Taijiang, one of them in Chengxi R005Source《109 年度國際遷移物種生態友善棲地營造試驗計畫》[2020 (ROC year 109) Pilot Project for Eco-friendly Habitat Creation for International Migratory Species], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (printed pp. 33, 38, 55, 56)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Coordinates, daily water levels, and bird monitoring for the pilot fish farm pond in Chengxi; the original wording is 「飛越魚塭」 ("flying over the fish pond"), not 「停棲覓食」 ("perching and foraging").. The village chief (lizhang, 里長) signed the letter of intent in 2018; its four commitments (rotational pond drying, lowering water levels, not harvesting the leftover trash fish, and not disturbing birds) were written into the formal principles for eco-friendly habitat creation in 2020 R006Source《台江地區無形文化資產暨文獻資料蒐集計畫成果報告書》[Final Report of the Project to Collect Intangible Cultural Heritage and Documentary Materials of the Taijiang Area], Table 2-01 (list of the chiefs of 25 villages, p. 29), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters, 2020Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The statement 「城西里里長 2018 年與台管處簽署參與生態友善棲地魚塭營造合作意向書」 ("in 2018 the chief of Chengxi Village signed a letter of intent with the park headquarters to cooperate in creating eco-friendly habitat fish ponds") comes from the remarks column of this table..

Official records of poaching, vandalism, and enforcement
First items: Throughout 2018 (ROC year 107) Pump air …2018-11-20 (ROC 107/11/20) Sluice gate b…2019-02-20 (ROC 108/2/20) Sluice gate bo…MoreLess
Seven dated official records R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.R004SourceThe five Chengxi thematic reports (766 pp.), including 《城西濕地水文》[Hydrology of the Chengxi Wetland], 《兩棲爬蟲》[Amphibians and Reptiles], 《哺乳類》[Mammals], and 《陸蟹》[Land Crabs], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park HeadquartersOriginal URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Page 14 of *Hydrology* is the only place in the Taijiang National Park Headquarters' commissioned reports that lists the three pollution sources alongside the three settlements.: Official record
- Throughout 2018 (ROC year 107) Pump air intakes were maliciously filled with water and damaged.
- 2018-11-20 (ROC 107/11/20) Sluice gate boards were pulled out, ending the trial two days early.
- 2019-02-20 (ROC 108/2/20) Sluice gate boards were stolen.
- Around June 2019 (ROC year 108) An automatic camera on the Qingcaolun Seawall (青草崙堤防) bicycle path was stolen.
- 2019-10-31 (ROC 108/10/31) Weeding by burning was witnessed directly on a fish pond embankment.
- 2019-11-18 (ROC 108/11/18) A closed double sluice gate was damaged, and a repaired earthen embankment was dug through.
- 2020-06-23 (ROC 109/6/23) The police were notified; 3 poachers were caught, and more than 70 captured brown land crabs were released.
The official report writes: 「本區因無圍牆隔離,時常有許多盜獵者前來放置網具捕獵……最大盜獵網具為百尺流刺網……系列計畫期間移除本區約 15-20 件盜獵網具」 ("because this area has no fence to isolate it, many poachers often come to set nets ... the largest poaching net was a hundred-foot gill net ... during the series of projects, about 15–20 poaching nets were removed from this area") R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.. The authorities also attributed the 2019 decline in fish, shrimp, snails, and shellfish in Chengxi directly to poaching, and the pattern of "fish collapsing, snails and shellfish holding steady" is precisely the evidence for that attribution R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown..
Official recordOn the recommendation to remove dogs and cats or control their populations, the deputy director of the Taijiang National Park Headquarters wrote in the review comments 「如經評估暫無法執行,可先刪除」 ("if assessment shows it cannot be carried out for now, it may be deleted for the time being"); this item does not appear in the formal recommendations R004SourceThe five Chengxi thematic reports (766 pp.), including 《城西濕地水文》[Hydrology of the Chengxi Wetland], 《兩棲爬蟲》[Amphibians and Reptiles], 《哺乳類》[Mammals], and 《陸蟹》[Land Crabs], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park HeadquartersOriginal URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Page 14 of *Hydrology* is the only place in the Taijiang National Park Headquarters' commissioned reports that lists the three pollution sources alongside the three settlements..
Official discussions of ecotourism
MoreLess
At the final review on 2019-12-12 (ROC 108/12/12), the section chief of the Planning and Management Section of the Taijiang National Park Headquarters asked 「針對城西地區鳥類利用熱點調查,是否可評估後續為生態旅遊景點之適宜性」 ("with regard to the survey of bird-use hotspots in the Chengxi area, could the suitability of these sites as ecotourism destinations be assessed in the future?"); the project team replied 「目前城西鳥類熱點為道路邊之魚塭,開放生態旅遊後,人潮過多容易驚嚇水鳥,建議持續關注熱點棲地狀況」 ("at present the bird hotspots in Chengxi are roadside fish ponds; if they were opened to ecotourism, large crowds would easily frighten the waterbirds; we recommend continued monitoring of the hotspot habitats"), and noted that 「大部分城西濕地周緣鳥類熱點為私人魚塭」 ("most of the bird hotspots around the Chengxi Wetland are private fish ponds") R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.. Official record At the same time, the Taijiang National Park Headquarters listed 「台江推廣城西社區生態旅遊」 ("Taijiang promoting community ecotourism in Chengxi") among the achievements of its Homeland Protection Circle (家園守護圈) assistance program; and Land Crabs (《陸蟹》, 2020) went further, arguing that the brown land crab population in the Qingcaolun area could become the basis for land crab ecotourism developed by the residents of Chengxi Village, creating a 「陸蟹、居民及管理處三贏」 ("triple win for the land crabs, the residents, and the park headquarters") R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.R004SourceThe five Chengxi thematic reports (766 pp.), including 《城西濕地水文》[Hydrology of the Chengxi Wetland], 《兩棲爬蟲》[Amphibians and Reptiles], 《哺乳類》[Mammals], and 《陸蟹》[Land Crabs], commissioned by the Taijiang National Park HeadquartersOriginal URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Page 14 of *Hydrology* is the only place in the Taijiang National Park Headquarters' commissioned reports that lists the three pollution sources alongside the three settlements..
Differing accounts
- Three accounts of when the incinerator's construction began and ended: Control Yuan, construction began 1995-05-01; Wikipedia, contract awarded 1993-04-29, contractor entered the site 1995-01-11, completed 1999-02-16; old Tucheng Elementary School website, construction began 1994-01-04, completed and put into service 1996-08 R007Source監察院調查報告 104財調0040 [Control Yuan Investigation Report 104財調0040] (investigated by Lee Yueh-te (李月德) and Chen Ching-tsai (陳慶財), deliberated 2015-11-04), full text: management and operation of the compensation facilities of the Chengxi IncineratorOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/48718Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—「自民國(下同)83年7月1日起改將垃圾掩埋於城西里垃圾掩埋場,且自84年5月1日起動工興建城西垃圾焚化廠」 ("from 1 July [ROC year] 83 (and likewise below) garbage was instead landfilled at the Chengxi Village landfill, and from 1 May [year] 84 construction of the Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant began").R013SourceChinese Wikipedia: 城西垃圾焚化廠 [Chengxi Refuse Incineration Plant]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/zh-tw/%E5%9F%8E%E8%A5%BF%E5%9E%83%E5%9C%BE%E7%84%9A%E5%8C%96%E5%BB%A0Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—Its history section cites only one source, the Ministry of Environment's 「臺南市城西焚化廠建廠摘述」 ("Summary of the Construction of the Chengxi Incinerator, Tainan City"), whose original page is now a login page.R012SourceOld website of Tucheng Elementary School, local-studies subsite, pages 〈菅仔埔的春天〉[Spring in Jianaipu] and 〈城西焚化爐〉[The Chengxi Incinerator] (snapshot of 2002-03-20) (Wayback Machine snapshot; the original site has been closed)Original URLhttps://web.archive.org/web/20020320204505/http://www.tcps.tn.edu.tw:80/teach/country/factory_burngarbage.htmRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The school page cites no source; 「85 年 8 月完工啟用」 ("completed and put into service in August [ROC year] 85") may have been a planned date; unverified.. Unverified
- The year the compensation facility was completed: the Control Yuan gives June of ROC year 93 (2004); the Shuiduoduo closure notice gives completion in ROC year 91 (2002) R002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) corrective measure on the Chengxi compensation facility (formal contract name 「臺南市夢幻水城營運管理契約」[Tainan City Dream Water City Operation and Management Contract], i.e. the Chengxi branch of the Shuiduoduo Water Park [水多多樂園]; construction began July 2000 [ROC year 89], completed June 2004 [ROC year 93], final cost a little over NT$298.75 million; the 2015 corrective measure criticized it for 「縱任……故意荒廢設施設備」 ["allowing ... the deliberate abandonment of facilities and equipment"] and 「無視該回饋設施長期閒置」 ["ignoring the long-term idleness of the compensation facility"])Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19During the off-season when it was closed to business, residents of 11 villages including Chengdong Village could use it free of charge with a compensation-village resident ID card.R020Source自由時報 [Liberty Times],〈台南「水多多」宣布停業 環局:朝共融式公園設計規劃〉[Tainan's "Shuiduoduo" Announces Closure; Environmental Bureau: Planning Toward an Inclusive Park Design], 2020-06-04, reporter Wang Shu-hsiu (王姝琇)Original URLhttps://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/3187066Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—.
- Dioxin in sediment: the 2016 conclusion was that levels exceeded the lower limit and that the site was 「不適宜立即做棲地營造」 ("not suitable for immediate habitat creation"); the 2017 retest found that all four stations 「皆未超過下限值或總合限值」 ("did not exceed the lower limit or the total limit") R003Source《台江國家公園及其周緣緩衝區多樣性棲地營造與評估計畫》[Project for the Creation and Assessment of Diverse Habitats in Taijiang National Park and Its Surrounding Buffer Zone] (1/4)–(4/4), commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters (臺江國家公園管理處) (ROC years 105–108 [2016–2019], three volumes, 1,018 pp.; (2/4) Table 6-87, p. 233; (4/4) pp. 21, 141, 146–147, 157, 215, 299, 304, 338)Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The full text has not been obtained; the station-by-station dioxin measurements for 2016 (ROC year 105) are unknown.. Unverified
- There are four sets of official figures for recommended water levels; the differences stem from "wetland tidal creeks vs. fish pond troughs" and "multiple guilds vs. black-faced spoonbills specifically." Unverified
- 2019 wetland trial 5–15 centimeters
- 2020 fish pond measurements 15–20 centimeters more common
- Recommendation of the Wild Bird Society of Tainan (臺南市野鳥學會) 20–30 centimeters
- 109-C19, citing the 2004 Sicao Refuge (四草保護區) plan 10–40 centimeters
Behind this door is the internal site, with profiles of people and local comments. The internal site is deployed separately.