The Unverified List and the Library Visit List

Official recordUnverified
243

Verification status of the entries on this page

  • Verified
  • Partially verified
  • Not covered by sources
  • Verified: the source was found and checked
  • Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

What has not yet been settled is published item by item, and so is what has already been exhausted online. This page is for people who would like to help.R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)

What has not yet been settled, we list item by item; what has already been exhausted online, we also list item by item. This page is for people who would like to help.

What the unverified list looks like

Official recordThe unverified list is tracked in three categories: "year/figure," "name/existence," and "claim" R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—. Every item carries its status, and a status can move in only four ways: closed out, escalated, shut, or added. Every item is reviewed at each update, and about eighty are currently still open R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—.

Official record"Closed out" and "shut" must be read separately. Closed out means the answer was found; shut means the search went as far as it could and the answer is "it cannot be found" or "this database has no such field" R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—. One topic this site has shut, for example, is the body-size sequence of a certain crab: the two public biodiversity databases do not even have a field in which body-size figures could be entered, so that line of research was shut, and the related account will permanently remain a local oral account R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—. UnverifiedAnother kind of shutting is when image resolution hits its ceiling: the photographs of two particular inscriptions exist in a report only as low-resolution embedded images, re-rendering the whole page is already the limit, and the small characters cannot be read. Without going to the site or finding a high-resolution source elsewhere, they cannot be obtained R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—.

Official recordThe list also records cases where "the question itself was overturned." For example, this site originally had an open item, "the year a certain market was formed cannot be found"; after five official registers were opened, it turned out that this market does not exist in the official system at all. It was not that the year could not be found; the question was the wrong one R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—.

Fourteen items exhausted online

10 items1994First items: Not found by a search engine does not mean not in the databaseMoreLess

Official recordThe "exhausted online" list records two things for each item: why it cannot be obtained online, and what routes remain R002SourceList of items "exhausted online; requiring photography of paper copies or another channel" (14 items, each recording "why it cannot be obtained online" and "feasible routes")Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—. The value of this column is that it spares the next person from walking down the same dead end. "Could not be obtained" and "nothing found" are two different things: the former means the file exists but cannot be got at; the latter means it was searched for and genuinely is not there R002SourceList of items "exhausted online; requiring photography of paper copies or another channel" (14 items, each recording "why it cannot be obtained online" and "feasible routes")Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—R006SourceThe PDF of 《台灣濕地》 [Taiwan Wetlands] no. 60 has been downloaded in full, but the extracted text is entirely garbled (the cmap is corrupted; it is not that there is no text layer); OCR is requiredOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.

Official recordSome representative reasons R002SourceList of items "exhausted online; requiring photography of paper copies or another channel" (14 items, each recording "why it cannot be obtained online" and "feasible routes")Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—:

  1. Downloading the full text of a batch of government research reports requires a graphical CAPTCHA, and most are marked as restricted to in-library reading or requiring an application.
  2. The 1994 announcement of a certain protected area was issued by the city government, earlier than the first year covered by the online gazette; the statutory plan explicitly states that it is 「置於臺南市政府供查閱」 ("kept at the Tainan City Government for inspection") and it has not been digitized.
  3. The agency website for a certain statutory plan has failed site-wide, and every path returns the same template page.
  4. The file of the conservation and wise-use plan for a certain wetland of importance is nearly 40 MB, and the server does not support segmented downloading, so the connection reliably freezes halfway.

Official recordThree other cases are problems of licensing and of the files themselves:

  1. The original 1933 edition of the Directory of Shrines and Temples of Tainan Prefecture (臺南州祠廟名鑑) is cataloged in a digital archive, but its license status is 「不開放授權」 ("not openly licensed") and no images are provided, so the only route is the reprint in the 5th-floor Reference Room R004Source《臺南州祠廟名鑑》 [Directory of Shrines and Temples of Tainan Prefecture] confirmed unobtainable online (Taiwan Memory catalogs the original 1933 edition, but its license status is 「不開放授權」 [not openly licensed], and image browsing and downloading are not provided); the 5th-floor Reference Room has a 2002 reprintOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.
  2. The scans of the whole of Tainan Culture (臺南文化) 7:3, the "Luermen special issue" (鹿耳門專號), are not online, and every naming variant returns a server error; yet all thirteen research articles in the polemical exchange over the Luermen (鹿耳門) orthodoxy dispute are in this issue R005SourcePage images of the original issue of 《臺南文化》 [Tainan Culture] 7:3, the 「鹿耳門專號」 [Luermen special issue], unobtainable (the database has not put the scans of this issue online, and every naming variant returns HTTP 500)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.
  3. The PDF of Taiwan Wetlands (台灣濕地) no. 60 has been downloaded in full, but the extracted text is entirely garbled. The character map is corrupted; it is not that there is no text layer, and it can only be read with optical character recognition R006SourceThe PDF of 《台灣濕地》 [Taiwan Wetlands] no. 60 has been downloaded in full, but the extracted text is entirely garbled (the cmap is corrupted; it is not that there is no text layer); OCR is requiredOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.

Not found by a search engine does not mean not in the database

Official recordMost historical source systems run by government agencies and research institutions are searched through on-site forms, and ordinary search engines cannot reach the result pages. Getting 0 results with a search engine's site: operator only means "not indexed by the search engine"; it cannot be written up as "nothing found" R010SourceItem-by-item checks of online historical source systems (國家檔案資訊網 [National Archives Information Network], 國史館臺灣文獻館 [Taiwan Historica], 地方議會議事錄總庫 [Database of Local Council Proceedings], 立法院公報 [Legislative Yuan Gazette], 監察院 [Control Yuan], 司法院 [Judicial Yuan], 環評書件 [environmental impact assessment documents], 政府公報 [government gazettes], and the collections of the institutes of Academia Sinica and of museums)Original URLhttps://mcc.digital.th.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. The situation for each system this site has checked R010SourceItem-by-item checks of online historical source systems (國家檔案資訊網 [National Archives Information Network], 國史館臺灣文獻館 [Taiwan Historica], 地方議會議事錄總庫 [Database of Local Council Proceedings], 立法院公報 [Legislative Yuan Gazette], 監察院 [Control Yuan], 司法院 [Judicial Yuan], 環評書件 [environmental impact assessment documents], 政府公報 [government gazettes], and the collections of the institutes of Academia Sinica and of museums)Original URLhttps://mcc.digital.th.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—:

  1. Not reachable by search engines; you must search inside the system: the National Archives Information Network (國家檔案資訊網), Taiwan Historica's Documents and Archives Search System (國史館臺灣文獻館文獻檔案查詢系統), the Academia Historica Archives and Artifacts Search System (國史館檔案史料文物查詢系統), the Database of Local Council Proceedings (地方議會議事錄總庫), the Legislative Yuan Gazette Image Retrieval System (立法院公報影像檢索系統), the Environmental Impact Assessment Document Search System (環評書件查詢系統), the Government Gazette Information Network (政府公報資訊網), and the search systems of the Institute of Taiwan History, the Institute of Modern History, the Institute of History and Philology, and the Institute of Ethnology at Academia Sinica (中研院臺史所、近史所、史語所、民族所).
  2. Individual item pages are open to search engines and can be found directly: Control Yuan investigation reports (監察院調查報告), the Union Catalog of Digital Archives Taiwan (數位典藏與學習聯合目錄), the National Museum of Taiwan History Collections (國立臺灣歷史博物館典藏網), and the National Cultural Memory Bank (國家文化記憶庫).
  3. The Database of Local Council Proceedings only provides digital images for viewing; the rights to the proceedings belong to each local council, and anyone wishing to cite the images must apply to the council that holds the originals.

The National Central Library list: the route for a single visit

3 itemsFirst items: The 2nd-floor new Chinese books area: fo…Requests from the closed stacks: this ar…The 5th-floor Reference and Government I…MoreLess

Official recordThe paper half is concentrated at the main building of the National Central Library (國家圖書館), and this site has organized it into a route that can be completed in a single visit R003SourceList for a single visit to the main building of the 國家圖書館 [National Central Library] (No. 20, Zhongshan South Road, Zhongzheng District, Taipei City; four books in the 2nd-floor new Chinese books area, 14 books requested from the closed stacks, three reference works in the 5th-floor Reference and Government Information Room, with call numbers and the chapters to be photographed)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-18Snapshot timestamp—Holdings status is as at the time of the search.. The rules first: bring an ID card to apply for a reader's card on the 1st floor; no holdings may be borrowed, and everything is read in the library; photography is for research purposes, and only the chapters needed are to be photographed R003SourceList for a single visit to the main building of the 國家圖書館 [National Central Library] (No. 20, Zhongshan South Road, Zhongzheng District, Taipei City; four books in the 2nd-floor new Chinese books area, 14 books requested from the closed stacks, three reference works in the 5th-floor Reference and Government Information Room, with call numbers and the chapters to be photographed)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-18Snapshot timestamp—Holdings status is as at the time of the search..

Official recordThe route has three stops R003SourceList for a single visit to the main building of the 國家圖書館 [National Central Library] (No. 20, Zhongshan South Road, Zhongzheng District, Taipei City; four books in the 2nd-floor new Chinese books area, 14 books requested from the closed stacks, three reference works in the 5th-floor Reference and Government Information Room, with call numbers and the chapters to be photographed)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-18Snapshot timestamp—Holdings status is as at the time of the search.:

  1. The 2nd-floor new Chinese books area: four books on open shelves, including two monographs on the Tucheng Incense Procession (土城香) published in 2024 and one study of the context of Mazu (媽祖) belief.
  2. Requests from the closed stacks: this area is closed-access, so all request slips should be submitted at once on arrival, and books take about twenty to thirty minutes to arrive. There are fourteen books on the list, sorted by priority; the top three are on the Tuchengzi Incense Procession (土城仔香), the coastal settlements along Provincial Highway 17, and the temple gazetteer of the Shengmu Temple (聖母廟).
  3. The 5th-floor Reference and Government Information Room: reference works on open shelves, including the reprint of the Directory of Shrines and Temples of Tainan Prefecture and the place-name gazetteer.

Official recordNext to every book is written "what to photograph," not just the title. For example, the book on troupe culture is structured as seven troupes with three sections each; the list specifies that the sections on historical origins and present state of transmission must be photographed for all seven chapters, but the sections on formations and their lore only for three of them, because founding year, tradition-bearers and present state are the fields this site most lacks R003SourceList for a single visit to the main building of the 國家圖書館 [National Central Library] (No. 20, Zhongshan South Road, Zhongzheng District, Taipei City; four books in the 2nd-floor new Chinese books area, 14 books requested from the closed stacks, three reference works in the 5th-floor Reference and Government Information Room, with call numbers and the chapters to be photographed)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-18Snapshot timestamp—Holdings status is as at the time of the search.. UnverifiedThe holdings status on the list is the live value at the time of the search; please check the catalog again before setting out R003SourceList for a single visit to the main building of the 國家圖書館 [National Central Library] (No. 20, Zhongshan South Road, Zhongzheng District, Taipei City; four books in the 2nd-floor new Chinese books area, 14 books requested from the closed stacks, three reference works in the 5th-floor Reference and Government Information Room, with call numbers and the chapters to be photographed)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-18Snapshot timestamp—Holdings status is as at the time of the search..

For people who would like to help

3 itemsFirst items: A few things this site does not doThe three most useful thingsMoreLess

A few things this site does not do

Official recordSo that people who want to help know where the lines are, this site's practice is also set out clearly here: no telephone interviews R008SourceVerification methods this site does not use (the author's instruction: no telephone interviews, no fieldwork; registrations of roadside stalls and night-market vendors are not checked, since "nothing found" is the norm)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—; field visits are carried out by the author in person, and what is heard on site is recorded verbatim, marked "local residents' oral account," and presented alongside the written sources but kept separate from them; it is not used as evidence to prove facts R009SourceThis site's editorial policy (revised 2026-10-28: the author carries out field visits in person; informal conversations in the field are recorded verbatim, marked as local residents' oral accounts, and presented alongside the written sources but kept separate from them)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Business registrations of roadside stalls and night-market vendors are not checked. Most such vendors are unregistered, so "nothing found" is the norm and is not regarded as insufficient verification R008SourceVerification methods this site does not use (the author's instruction: no telephone interviews, no fieldwork; registrations of roadside stalls and night-market vendors are not checked, since "nothing found" is the norm)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—. Official recordThere is also a "manual verification list" of items that can only be confirmed in a logged-in environment or on site; on this site those items are marked "requires a logged-in environment" rather than "not done" R007SourceManual verification list (items that can only be confirmed in a logged-in environment or on site)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—.

The three most useful things

Unverified

  1. Go to the National Central Library and photograph the chapters on the list, especially the festival chronologies, the formation dates and ancestral origins of each jiaotou (角頭, neighborhood unit). None of these is anywhere online; they are only in two monographs R003SourceList for a single visit to the main building of the 國家圖書館 [National Central Library] (No. 20, Zhongshan South Road, Zhongzheng District, Taipei City; four books in the 2nd-floor new Chinese books area, 14 books requested from the closed stacks, three reference works in the 5th-floor Reference and Government Information Room, with call numbers and the chapters to be photographed)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-18Snapshot timestamp—Holdings status is as at the time of the search..
  2. Full-text searching of local newspapers from 1999 to 2003. Several of this site's event memories and old names of activities are stuck in this period, which the free online databases do not cover R002SourceList of items "exhausted online; requiring photography of paper copies or another channel" (14 items, each recording "why it cannot be obtained online" and "feasible routes")Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-19Snapshot timestamp—.
  3. A second account from local people. Most entries in this hall currently have only one speaker and need a second local person for comparison R001SourceMaster unverified list (tracked item by item in three categories, "year/figure," "name/existence" and "claim"; each round records items closed out, items shut and items added; about eighty items are currently still open)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-23Snapshot timestamp—.
See more →

Behind this door is the internal site, with profiles of people and local comments. The internal site is deployed separately.