Guided reading
The craniometric study of the human bones at Sicao Dazhong Temple is the morphological measurement of 42 skulls from the communal tomb behind the temple made by the Anthropology Section of the National Museum of Natural Science in November 2002; its 2006 report tentatively concluded that the skulls measured belong to Austronesian/East Asian populations, with no Europeans found.R001SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, prefaceOriginal URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Photographed from the printed book; personal names checked against the photographs.
- Evidence mix
Where to start reading
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
The craniometric study of the human bones at Sicao Dazhong Temple is a physical-anthropology study by the Anthropology Section of the National Museum of Natural Science of the bones in the communal tomb behind the temple. Taking advantage of the Sicao Dazhong Temple's clearing of the remains, the Anthropology Section of the National Museum of Natural Science measured 42 skulls from the communal tomb behind the temple between November 18 and 29, 2002: 40 were provisionally identified as male and 2 as adolescents aged 12 to 18, and the first 35 were used for statistical analysis [R003]. Using three methods (principal component, cluster and discriminant analysis) and comparing them with cranial data for Taiwan's Indigenous peoples and world populations, the discriminant analysis assigned the 35 skulls as 21 Austronesian, 14 East Asian and 0 European [R004]. The report concluded that 「初步獲致四草人骨皆屬於南島/東亞人群的結果,並無歐洲人在其中」 ("the preliminary result is that the Sicao human bones all belong to Austronesian/East Asian populations, with no Europeans among them"), while stating plainly that only a very small part of the kept bones was measured, that 17.8% of Europeans would be misclassified as non-European, and that the reference data included neither Dutch nor Siraya people, so it did not rule out that European bones remain in the tomb [R005]. This is the inference of one study; it stands alongside the temple's and elders' account of Dutch soldiers' remains, and Huang Tien-chuan's stele inscription identifying them as those killed in battle or drowned at sea in the Ming and Qing periods.
Relationship map
Background
First items: Discovery: the report says 「民國六十一年三月…Huang Tien-chuan's stele inscription: th…The Dutch soldier account: in the sevent…MoreLess
The report's introduction summarizes the accounts of these bones current at the time R002SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 5Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 5The introduction and the full text of Huang Tien-chuan's (黃典權) 〈海靈佳城〉 ("Hailing Jiacheng") stele inscription, checked against the photographs.R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7:
- Discovery: the report says 「民國六十一年三月,大眾廟擴建時掘地發現,出土於骨甕之中」 ("discovered in March of ROC year 61 [1972] when the ground was dug during the expansion of the Dazhong Temple, unearthed in bone urns"); local hearsay held that some leg bones were especially long and might belong to Dutchmen R002SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 5Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 5The introduction and the full text of Huang Tien-chuan's (黃典權) 〈海靈佳城〉 ("Hailing Jiacheng") stele inscription, checked against the photographs..Secondhand account
- Huang Tien-chuan's stele inscription: the then Sicao Village chief Wu Lien-pang (吳連榜) invited Huang Tien-chuan (黃典權) of the Tainan City Historical Commission to inspect the site. Huang saw that the leg bones 「有痕若斲」 ("bore marks as if hacked") and that the remains had 「蠣殼貼附」 ("oyster shells stuck to them"), and inferred that they were victims of Ming–Qing battles or people drowned and washed ashore; on the question of 「雜有外籍之人骨」 ("foreign human bones mixed in") he wrote 「余以直接文獻難稽,未敢贊一辭」 ("since direct documentary evidence is hard to find, I dare not say a word"), and inscribed the four characters 「海靈佳城」 ("a fine resting place for the sea spirits") to give them peace R002SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 5Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 5The introduction and the full text of Huang Tien-chuan's (黃典權) 〈海靈佳城〉 ("Hailing Jiacheng") stele inscription, checked against the photographs..Scholarly view
- The Dutch soldier account: in the seventeenth century Sicao was Beishanwei Island (北汕尾島), where there is a site suspected to be a Dutch sea fort; in 1661 the troops of Chen Ze (陳澤), under Koxinga (Zheng Chenggong, 鄭成功), fought a major battle here with the Dutch garrison. The report's authors considered that the claim of Dutch bones in the tomb was 「並非絕無可能,但也未經確認」 ("not entirely impossible, but also unconfirmed") R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.Scholarly view
- Through oral transmission and media reports this account had become deeply rooted: 「曾有人帶荷蘭教授前來考察,建議荷蘭政府應建館,保護戰歿士兵骨骸」 ("someone once brought a Dutch professor to investigate, who suggested that the Dutch government should build a hall to protect the remains of the fallen soldiers"); on February 21, 2006, the United Daily News (《聯合報》) reported that Wu Tai-shan (吳泰山), chairman of the Sicao Dazhong Temple, planned to build a Koxinga–Dutch Ancient Battlefield History Museum (鄭荷古戰場文史館) displaying replicas of the bones bearing blade wounds R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.Secondhand account
- Two other accounts: Yeh Chun-jung (葉春榮), associate research fellow at the Institute of Ethnology, Academia Sinica (中央研究院), and a historian proposed two possibilities: Siraya (西拉雅族) people, or laborers brought by the Dutch from Southeast Asia R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.Secondhand account
- The report therefore listed four possibilities: Han Chinese, Dutch, Siraya and Southeast Asian laborers R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.
Course of events
First items: MethodsResultsMoreLess
- Dates: November 18 to 29, 2002, 10 working days in all R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.Scholarly view
- Occasion: the Anthropology Section 「特別情商四草大眾廟管理委員會,藉著廟方清理骨骸的機會」 ("made a special request to the Sicao Dazhong Temple Management Committee, taking the opportunity of the temple's clearing of the remains") to carry out the measurements R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.Scholarly view
- Personnel R001SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, prefaceOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 序Photographed from the printed book; personal names checked against the photographs.R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7:
- Principal investigator: Ho Chuan-kun (何傳坤).
- Cranial measurement and on-site supervision: Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑).
- Measurers: Ho Chia-hsiu (何佳修) and Tsou Teng-lu (鄒騰露).
- Skull photography: Chao Chi-ming (趙啓明).
- Statistical analysis: Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬) (described in the book as a professor at the Graduate Institute of Anthropology, Tzu Chi University).
- Publication: published in December 2006 by the National Museum of Natural Science, with a case-by-case measurement table for all 42 skulls; part of the content had been presented earlier, in December 2005, at a Pingpu peoples academic conference held by the Tainan County Cultural Affairs Bureau, and the report states that the results in the book take precedence R001SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, prefaceOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 序Photographed from the printed book; personal names checked against the photographs..
Methods
- Why skulls: the report says the skull is less affected by acquired environmental factors and stably reflects differences between populations, whereas measurements of limb bones such as stature change from generation to generation R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.Scholarly view
- Sample: 42 skulls were measured; 40 were provisionally identified as male, and the other 2 were adolescents aged 12 to 18 whose sex could not be determined; only the first 35 were used for statistical analysis R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.Scholarly view
- Reference data R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7:
- Cranial data for five groups of Taiwan's Indigenous peoples published by Pietrusewsky and Chang Ching-fang (張菁芳) in 2003 (Atayal 泰雅, Bunun 布農, Babuza 貓霧捒, Pazeh 巴則海, and Shisanhang 十三行).
- Howells's 1989 world population data: three groups (medieval Norway (Norse), Hungary (Zalavar) and an Austrian mountain village (Berg)) indirectly representing the Dutch; Atayal and the Philippines representing the Siraya and Southeast Asian laborers; and Hainan (海南) and the Yin ruins at Anyang (安陽殷墟) representing the Han Chinese.
- Variables: 12 in all: cranial length, cranial base length, cranial height, cranial breadth, maximum frontal breadth, biauricular breadth, biasterionic breadth, nasal height, nasal breadth, orbital height, orbital breadth, and maxillo-alveolar breadth R004SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 8–13 (Tables 1–3, Figures 1–4)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 8–13.
- Analyses: principal component analysis, cluster analysis and discriminant analysis R004SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 8–13 (Tables 1–3, Figures 1–4)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 8–13.
Results
- Means of the 35 Sicao skulls (mm): cranial length 179.6, cranial breadth 141.5, cranial height 140.5, cranial base length 99.3, nasal height 53.5, nasal breadth 26.5 R004SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 8–13 (Tables 1–3, Figures 1–4)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 8–13.Scholarly view
- Principal component analysis: the second and third principal components separate Europeans from Austronesians/East Asians, and on both the Sicao data are 「與南島/東亞族群相近,與歐洲族群較遠」 ("close to Austronesian/East Asian populations and farther from European populations") R004SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 8–13 (Tables 1–3, Figures 1–4)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 8–13.Scholarly view
- Cluster analysis: the two methods gave inconsistent results. In the Complete-method dendrogram Sicao is close to the Austronesian/East Asian groups, while in the Ward method it is close to the European groups; at this step the report suggested that 「四草人骨不屬於單一族群,而是多族群的集合人骨」 ("the Sicao bones do not belong to a single population but are a collection of bones from multiple populations") R004SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 8–13 (Tables 1–3, Figures 1–4)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 8–13.Scholarly view
- Discriminant analysis R004SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 8–13 (Tables 1–3, Figures 1–4)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 8–13:Scholarly view
- First a self-test on the Howells data: the correct classification rate for "non-European" skulls (Austronesian and East Asian combined) was 95.7%, and for European skulls 82.2%.
- In other words, the probability of a non-European being misclassified as European is 4.3%, and of a European being misclassified as non-European 17.8%.
- The 35 Sicao skulls: 21 Austronesian (60.0%), 14 East Asian (40.0%), 0 European.
- Sex and age: the report's preface says these bones are 「幾乎都是男性,並以青、壯年居多」 ("almost all male, mostly young adults and adults in their prime"); the main text lists only 40 males and 2 adolescents and does not explain the method or distribution of age determination R001SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, prefaceOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 序Photographed from the printed book; personal names checked against the photographs.R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 6–7.
Conclusions and limitations
First items: Conclusion: 「本研究初步獲致四草人骨皆屬於南島/東亞人群的結果…Limitations listed by the report itself :Recommendation: the most direct verifica…MoreLess
- Conclusion: 「本研究初步獲致四草人骨皆屬於南島/東亞人群的結果,並無歐洲人在其中」 ("this study has obtained the preliminary result that the Sicao human bones all belong to Austronesian/East Asian populations, with no Europeans among them") R005SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 14Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 14.Scholarly view
- Limitations listed by the report itself R005SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 14Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 14:Scholarly view
- The European component needs further confirmation: only 35 skulls were measured, 「僅佔四草大眾廟收藏人骨的極小部分,極可能確實有歐洲人骨藏於其中,但本次研究並未測量到」 ("only a very small part of the human bones kept at the Sicao Dazhong Temple; it is quite possible that European bones are indeed among them but were not measured in this study"); the 17.8% misclassification rate could also cause Europeans to be classified as Austronesian or East Asian; and the Howells data contain no Dutch, so they can represent them only indirectly.
- East Asians and Austronesians are hard to separate: cranial measurement can distinguish only broad regions, not populations within a region, so "Han Chinese" and "Austronesian (including Siraya)" cannot be told apart in this study.
- No Siraya reference sample: at the time there were no cranial measurement data or genetic data for the Siraya; the report cites seventeenth-century Dutch records saying the Siraya were on average a head taller than the Dutch, so their cranial form may differ greatly from other Austronesian groups.
- Recommendation: the most direct verification would be to enlarge the measured sample and then distinguish the populations with genetic methods such as ancient DNA R005SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 14Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 14.
- By the report's own account, what this study can answer is that "the morphology of the 35 skulls measured is closer to Austronesian/East Asian populations"; it cannot be used to assert that there are no Dutch in the tomb at all, nor can it distinguish Han Chinese, Siraya or Southeast Asian laborers.
Measurement table
- Section 7 of the report lists 42 cases, ST001 to ST042, each with 58 measurements (cranial length, cranial breadth, arcs and chords, face, orbit, nose, palate, foramen magnum, biauricular breadth and so on), with measurement items following Wu Rukang (吳汝康) et al., 《人體骨骼測量方法》 (Methods of Human Osteometry) R006SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 17–21 (measurement table of the Sicao skulls)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 17–21The measurement table was reproduced column by column by this site from the photographs..
- A few cells in the original table deviate clearly from the other individuals (for example ST033 cranial length 217 mm, ST038 midfacial breadth 10 mm) and are suspected to be misprints in the original book; they are reproduced here as printed R006SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 17–21 (measurement table of the Sicao skulls)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City (臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析)》p. 17–21The measurement table was reproduced column by column by this site from the photographs..Unverified
Accounts from different sides
- Other years are also given for the discovery of the remains and the building of the tomb, including 1971, 1972, 1975, 1980 and 1984; see Hailing Jiacheng and Sicao Dazhong Temple.
- The identity of Zhenhai Da Yuanshuai (鎮海大元帥, Great Sea-Guarding Marshal) (Chen You 陳酉, generalization, or a deity named after Chen Ze) is a question about the deity's origin, and is a separate matter from the population affinity of the bones in the tomb; see Zhenhai Yuanshuai (Sea-Guarding Marshal).
- For the fighting around Beishanwei in 1661, see the Koxinga–Dutch War (鄭荷之戰, 1661–1662).
See also
- Hailing Jiacheng⚖︎The bone tomb behind the Sicao Dazhong Temple
- Sicao Dazhong Temple⚖︎The temple of the Great Marshal Zhenhai in Sicao, Annan DistrictContains 11 items
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansHo Chuan-kunDirector of the Sicao Dazhong Temple skull measurement
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansLiu Ke-hungResearcher who measured the Sicao skulls
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansChen Shu-juoThe anthropologist who analyzed the Sicao skull data
- Postwar to 1987・Scholars and local historiansHuang Tien-chuanMember of the Tainan City Historical Commission
- Postwar to 1987・Elected representatives and officialsWu Lien-pangChief of Sicao Village
- 1987 to present・Temple leadersWu Tai-shanFormer chair of the Sicao Dazhong Temple committee
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansYeh Chun-jungThe scholar who proposed the Siraya and Southeast Asian laborer hypotheses for the Sicao bones
- SirayaA Pingpu people of the Tainan plain
- The Koxinga–Dutch War (1661–1662)⚖︎Koxinga's conquest of Taiwan, 1661–1662
- Dutch and Zheng eras・Military figuresChen ZeGeneral under Koxinga
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansHo Chia-hsiuMeasurer of the Sicao skulls
- History of Sicao Dazhong TempleThe founding, ossuary and rituals of Sicao Dazhong Temple
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansChang Ching-fang (張菁芳)Physical anthropologist
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansChao Chi-mingPhotographer of the Sicao skulls
- Zhenhai Yuanshuai (Sea-Guarding Marshal)Principal deity of the Sicao Dazhong TempleContains 1 items
- 1987 to present・Scholars and local historiansTsou Teng-luMeasurer of the Sicao skulls
Differing accounts
The origin of the human bones in the communal tomb of the Sicao Dazhong Temple
- Account 1Local hearsay that some leg bones were especially long and might belong to Dutchmen; the temple and elders call it the Dutch Tomb, holding the bones of Dutch soldiers killed in the Siege of Fort Zeelandia (sources for each are in the Hailing Jiacheng entry)R002SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 5Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—The introduction and the full text of Huang Tien-chuan's (黃典權) 〈海靈佳城〉 ("Hailing Jiacheng") stele inscription, checked against the photographs.
- Account 2The remains of those killed in battle or drowned and washed ashore in the Ming and Qing periods; on the claim of foreign bones, 「直接文獻難稽,未敢贊一辭」 ("direct documentary evidence is hard to find, and I dare not say a word") (Huang Tien-chuan's 〈海靈佳城〉 stele inscription)R002SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 5Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—The introduction and the full text of Huang Tien-chuan's (黃典權) 〈海靈佳城〉 ("Hailing Jiacheng") stele inscription, checked against the photographs.
- Account 3Two further proposals: Siraya people, or laborers brought by the Dutch from Southeast Asia (Yeh Chun-jung and others)R003SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, pp. 6–7Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—
- Account 4The 35 skulls measured all belong to Austronesian/East Asian populations by discriminant analysis, with no Europeans found; but only a very small part was measured, and other European bones are not ruled out (National Museum of Natural Science report, 2006)R005SourceHo Chuan-kun (何傳坤), Liu Ke-hung (劉克竑) and Chen Shu-juo (陳叔倬), 《臺南市四草大眾廟收藏人骨顱骨型態測量分析》[Craniometric Analysis of the Human Skulls Kept at Sicao Dazhong Temple, Tainan City], 國立自然科學博物館 [National Museum of Natural Science], 2006, p. 14Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—
The report itself also states that the Ward-method dendrogram of the cluster analysis placed the Sicao data close to European populations, and at one point it suggested the bones were a mixed multi-population assemblage; its final conclusion rests mainly on the discriminant analysis.
Reports that mention it
Hall of Faith3.4Faith / Temple histories
Sicao Dazhong Temple
Two sets of founding dates are given, 1700 and 1801/1817, and there are three accounts of who the principal deity, the Zhenhai Da Yuanshuai, really was; the ossuary mound behind the temple keeps the Sino-Dutch war of 1661 present on this sandbar.
Continue from here
- Sicao: other EventsTaijiang Black-faced Spoonbill Season⚖︎The annual spoonbill season events of Taijiang National Park
- Took place atSicao Dazhong Temple⚖︎The temple of the Great Marshal Zhenhai in Sicao, Annan DistrictContains 11 items
- Entries in the same hallOrthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple⚖︎Mazu temple of Tuchengzi, host of the Tuchengzi Incense ProcessionContains 18 items