Guided reading
The Highway 61 Qigu section slag backfill case concerns the environmental pollution caused by furnace slag and dust-collector ash mixed into the roadbed backfill of the Qigu section of the West Coast Expressway (Provincial Highway 61) in Tainan; it was exposed by environmental groups and scholars in 2010, and the Control Yuan censured the Directorate General of Highways in 2011.R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.
- Evidence mix
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
The Highway 61 Qigu section slag backfill case (台61線七股段爐碴回填案) concerns the environmental pollution caused by furnace slag and dust-collector ash mixed into the roadbed backfill of sections WH75, WH76 and WH77-78 of the West Coast Expressway (Provincial Highway 61) at Qigu, Tainan R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.. Official record After environmental groups and scholars exposed it in 2010, county environmental sampling found lead above standard at only one bridge pier; the Tainan District Prosecutors Office investigated in separate cases, one of which established that the slag came from Weichih Steel, but the contractor and steelmaker escaped prosecution because the limitation period had expired R003Source自由時報 [Liberty Times] report (2010-06-08): results of the county environmental protection bureau's expanded samplingOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—News report; also checked.R004Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island] report (2011-02-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Television news; also checked.. In May 2011 the Control Yuan censured the Directorate General of Highways of the Ministry of Transportation and Communications for failing to stop the contractor from using slag-laced fill promptly, and for spending more than NT$8.65 million to hire a firm to remove it, adding to the public expense R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.R005Source監察院 [Control Yuan] press release (2011-05-10): censure of the Directorate General of Highways, Ministry of Transportation and CommunicationsOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official press release; also checked..
Background
The three contract sections of the West Coast Expressway, WH75, WH76 and WH77-78, were self-supervised by the Directorate General of Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications, between 1999-07 and 2004-11, and were contracted to Jenfa Construction (任發營造), Chiajung Construction (佳榮營造) and Yiching Construction (亦慶營造) respectively R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.. Official record
Course of events
First items: 2010-04-21 Report by the Taiwan Environm…2010-06-08 Liberty Times report: the cou…2010-07 At the earthen embankment at P7,…MoreLess
- 2010-04-21 Report by the Taiwan Environmental Information Center: Huang Huan-chang (黃煥彰), associate professor at Chung Hwa University of Medical Technology, described 「台61線簡直是爐渣掩埋場」 ("Highway 61 is simply a slag landfill"); residents said that what was dumped at four o'clock every morning was blackish-brown, and what was dumped a little later was white slag, still hot, which smoked when thrown into water R002Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center] report (2010-04-21): Huang Huan-chang says 「台61線簡直是爐渣掩埋場」 ("Highway 61 is simply a slag landfill")Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—News report; checked in addition to the Control Yuan report.. Secondhand account
- 2010-06-08 Liberty Times report: the county environmental protection bureau expanded its sampling (from April 20 to May 14, with samples taken at every kilometer along the whole line); fish-pond water quality, groundwater and soil were all found uncontaminated, and the suspected contamination was limited to one excess of lead at bridge pier number P7 (295.8K); the bureau's head of inspection said 「只查到路基爐碴並未直接來自中鋼,至於來源、回填數量、種類是否合乎規定,尚待查明」 ("it was only found that the roadbed slag did not come directly from China Steel; whether the source, the quantity of backfill and the type comply with regulations remains to be established"); environmental groups questioned the testing method, and the bureau replied 「環保署怎麼規定,就照規定檢測」 ("we test as the Environmental Protection Administration prescribes") R003Source自由時報 [Liberty Times] report (2010-06-08): results of the county environmental protection bureau's expanded samplingOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—News report; also checked.. Secondhand account
- 2010-07 At the earthen embankment at P7, Jenfa Construction completed removal of about 38.84 metric tons of a mixture of slag and dust-collector ash; 2011-01 at the earthen embankment south of P14, about 127.44 metric tons were removed; the city environmental protection bureau's tests still found excess zinc, and the matter is being handled under the Soil and Groundwater Pollution Remediation Act R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.. Official record
- 2010-12 Because Yiching Construction, the contractor for section WH77-78, was in financial difficulty, the Directorate General of Highways used more than NT$8.65 million of its budget to commission Kaisheng Industrial Co., Ltd. (凱盛實業股份有限公司) to clear and dispose of hazardous waste in the Qigu section R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.. Official record
- 2011-02-14 PTS Our Island reported: the Tainan District Prosecutors Office opened its own investigation in three cases, two of which have been concluded; in the first, the slag was confirmed to come from Weichih Steel (威致鋼鐵), but the contractor and the steel company were not pursued because the statute of limitations had expired; in the second, the source could not be found and only the contractor was indicted; the Directorate General of Highways was in the end not indicted R004Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island] report (2011-02-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Television news; also checked.. Secondhand account
- 2011-05-10 The Control Yuan passed the motion brought by Huang Huang-hsiung (黃煌雄) and Chien Lin Hui-chun (錢林慧君) to censure the Directorate General of Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications (100 Jiao-Zheng 0009): for failing to stop the contractor in time from using soil mixed with slag and dust-collector ash as roadbed backfill, causing serious environmental pollution and harming the public interest; for not seeking compensation from the defaulting contractor through legal channels, and for spending more than NT$8.65 million to commission a firm to clear it away, thereby increasing public expenditure, all of which was improper R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.R005Source監察院 [Control Yuan] press release (2011-05-10): censure of the Directorate General of Highways, Ministry of Transportation and CommunicationsOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official press release; also checked.. Official record
Judicial proceedings
- The investigation report records that the Tainan District Prosecutors Office indicted Yiching Construction, the contractor of section WH77-78, for violating the Waste Disposal Act R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.. Official record
- Jenfa Construction was not prosecuted because the statute of limitations had expired; the Southern Highway Construction Office (南工處) was not indicted for insufficient evidence of an offense; the Environmental Protection Administration's forensic result showed that the slag source resembled the oxidizing slag of Weichih Steel R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.. Official record
- The court outcome for Yiching Construction was not found; an indictment is not a finding of guilt. Unverified
Accounts
- Li Yin-chih (李銀治), a villager of Yancheng (鹽埕): 「那為什麼爐碴會到這裡?」 ("Then why did the slag end up here?") (PTS, 2011-02-14) R004Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island] report (2011-02-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Television news; also checked.Secondhand account
- Prosecutor Lin Chung-pin (林仲斌) (PTS report): 「除非我有更強烈的證據,證實公路總局知情,但是這是將近十年前的事情,我很難還原。」 ("Unless I have stronger evidence confirming that the Directorate General of Highways knew, but this was nearly ten years ago, and it is hard for me to reconstruct.") R004Source公視《我們的島》[Our Island] report (2011-02-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Television news; also checked.Secondhand account
- The Directorate General of Highways' account: this was the contractor's doing, and it did not know it was furnace slag R001Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report (100交調0025): on the petition concerning the use of slag as landfill in the Provincial Highway 61 West Coast Expressway projectOriginal URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/49330Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Control Yuan investigation report (PDF, downloaded and read as text); also checked against e-info of 2010-04-21, Liberty Times of 2010-06-08, PTS Our Island of 2011-02-14 and the Control Yuan press release of 2011-05-10.. Official record
- The early account of the environmental authorities: slag can serve as graded aggregate and is a lawful reuse (the Tainan County Environmental Protection Bureau's response when Huang Huan-chang made the disclosure in 2010-04) R002Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center] report (2010-04-21): Huang Huan-chang says 「台61線簡直是爐渣掩埋場」 ("Highway 61 is simply a slag landfill")Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—News report; checked in addition to the Control Yuan report.. Secondhand account
See also
- Provincial Highway 61The West Coast Expressway
- QiguDistrict of Tainan, spoonbill wintering ground
- The Taijiang Boulevard Converter Slag CaseThe case of converter slag in the Taijiang Boulevard embankment
- 1987 to present・Shops and businessesLai Tai-wenHead of Yi-Ching Construction
Continue from here
- Qigu: other EventsBinnan Industrial Park⚖︎A 1990s petrochemical and steel industrial park project at QiguContains 73 items
- Related entriesProvincial Highway 61The West Coast Expressway
- Entries in the same hallCase of Yang Ching-chi et al., Danei Branch⚖︎A 1950 White Terror case in Danei Township, Tainan County