Guided reading
The Control Yuan's corrective measure against the EPA on the Binnan EIA was a corrective measure passed in April 2000 by the Control Yuan's Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs, censuring the Environmental Protection Administration for hastily approving the environmental impact assessment of the Binnan Industrial Park.R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 55、94、101 [pp. 55, 94, 101]Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved(None, or not applicable)Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Note 75, note 103 (citing Control Yuan announcement of 2000-04-24, (八九)院台財字第 892200294 號 [ref. no. (89) Yuan-Tai-Tsai 892200294]), and the main text. The thesis gives 2000-04-17 in several places, but in one place cites 「監察院會議紀錄,2001/04/17」 ("Control Yuan meeting minutes, 2001/04/17").
- Evidence mix
Where to start reading
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
The Control Yuan's corrective measure against the EPA on the Binnan EIA was passed on April 17, 2000, by the Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs of the Control Yuan (30th meeting of the 3rd term), on a motion by three Control Yuan members, Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming, censuring the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan, for its handling of the environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park: it had not counted public holidays toward the review deadline, had used meeting conclusions that exceeded the authority granted by the parent law, had proceeded although the committee member with air-pollution expertise was absent, and had hastily approved the project although only four members attended and three of them opposed the use of the lagoon. The corrective text also criticized some members' long-standing low attendance.
Grounds of the measure
First items: The grounds of the corrective measure as…Another passage of the corrective text :…Reference number: Control Yuan announcem…MoreLess
- The grounds of the corrective measure as quoted in Chen Ya-fen's (陳雅芬) thesis R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 55、94、101 [pp. 55, 94, 101]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 55、94、101Note 75, note 103 (citing Control Yuan announcement of 2000-04-24, (八九)院台財字第 892200294 號 [ref. no. (89) Yuan-Tai-Tsai 892200294]), and the main text. The thesis gives 2000-04-17 in several places, but in one place cites 「監察院會議紀錄,2001/04/17」 ("Control Yuan meeting minutes, 2001/04/17").: Secondhand account
「行政院環境保護署辨理濱南工業區開發案環境影響評估審查,未將例假日併計為審查期限;又擅以會議結論,踰越母法授權,且於具有空氣污染防治專長之環境影響評估委員,未出席開會;另出席審查會之委員僅四人,且其中三人均反對使用潟湖情形下,仍草率通過環境影響評估,核有失當。」
("In conducting the environmental impact assessment review of the Binnan Industrial Park development project, the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan, did not count public holidays toward the review deadline; it also, on its own authority, used meeting conclusions that exceeded the authority granted by the parent law; the environmental impact assessment committee member with expertise in air-pollution control did not attend the meeting; and although only four members attended the review meeting, three of whom opposed the use of the lagoon, it still hastily approved the environmental impact assessment. This is found to be improper.")
- Another passage of the corrective text R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 55、94、101 [pp. 55, 94, 101]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 55、94、101Note 75, note 103 (citing Control Yuan announcement of 2000-04-24, (八九)院台財字第 892200294 號 [ref. no. (89) Yuan-Tai-Tsai 892200294]), and the main text. The thesis gives 2000-04-17 in several places, but in one place cites 「監察院會議紀錄,2001/04/17」 ("Control Yuan meeting minutes, 2001/04/17").: Secondhand account
「……然查部分審查委員長期出席率偏低(不論初審或大會審查),卻仍有寬裕時間接受該署之委託研究計畫,棄守環境影響評估把關之責任,然該署卻不思訂定相關法令以資規範,殊有未當。」
("...yet it was found that some review committee members have had low attendance over a long period [whether at preliminary review or at general meeting review], yet still had ample time to accept research projects commissioned by the Administration, abandoning their responsibility as gatekeepers of environmental impact assessment, while the Administration has not thought to establish relevant regulations to govern this. This is particularly improper.")
- Reference number: Control Yuan announcement of 2000-04-24, (八九)院台財字第 892200294 號 (ref. no. [89] Yuan-Tai-Tsai 892200294) R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 55、94、101 [pp. 55, 94, 101]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 55、94、101Note 75, note 103 (citing Control Yuan announcement of 2000-04-24, (八九)院台財字第 892200294 號 [ref. no. (89) Yuan-Tai-Tsai 892200294]), and the main text. The thesis gives 2000-04-17 in several places, but in one place cites 「監察院會議紀錄,2001/04/17」 ("Control Yuan meeting minutes, 2001/04/17").. Secondhand account
- Tsai Lung-yu's (蔡隆郁) thesis records it as a resolution of the 30th meeting of the 3rd term of the Control Yuan's Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs R002SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁),《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"] (國立中山大學政治學研究所在職專班 [In-service Master's Program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University] master's thesis, 2005), p. 139Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 139The main text reproduces both Control Yuan corrective measures verbatim.. Secondhand account
Effects
- 2000-04-26 The EPA convened a special task group on supplementary matters, and the chair ruled that 「基於監院糾正函,本未審查基礎轉變,請專家先對開發單位的補充資料提出書面意見後再議」 ("in view of the Control Yuan's corrective letter, the basis of the review has changed; experts are asked first to give written opinions on the developer's supplementary materials before further discussion") (Commercial Times) R004SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 218 [p. 218]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 218Appendix 4, news digest, entry for 2000-04-26, citing the Commercial Times (工商時報) of 2000-04-27.. Secondhand account
Differing accounts
- Review deadline: Chen Ya-fen's thesis writes that the review exceeded the 120-day deadline of Article 13 of the Environmental Impact Assessment Act and yet a resolution was passed to 「繼續審查」 ("continue the review") R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 55、94、101 [pp. 55, 94, 101]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 55、94、101Note 75, note 103 (citing Control Yuan announcement of 2000-04-24, (八九)院台財字第 892200294 號 [ref. no. (89) Yuan-Tai-Tsai 892200294]), and the main text. The thesis gives 2000-04-17 in several places, but in one place cites 「監察院會議紀錄,2001/04/17」 ("Control Yuan meeting minutes, 2001/04/17").. Secondhand accountFor the EPA's account when questioned, see Binnan Industrial Park.
- Corrective measure versus impeachment: in a 2003 interview Hsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) said 「彈劾案是我提的呀!主要是要彈劾時限的問題」 ("I was the one who proposed the impeachment! It was mainly to impeach over the deadline issue"); impeachment and corrective measures are different institutions, and the thesis does not say whether he was referring to the same case R003SourceKuo Hsien-ming (郭憲銘),《我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project](東海大學公共行政學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Public Administration, Tunghai University],2003),頁 137 [p. 137]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《An Examination of the Public Participation Process under Taiwan's Current Environmental Impact Assessment System: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project (我國現行環評制度下民眾參與過程之檢視:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 137Appendix 3: interview with Hsieh Chih-cheng.. Secondhand account
- Dates in the thesis: in one place the year of the meeting is given differently R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 55、94、101 [pp. 55, 94, 101]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 55、94、101Note 75, note 103 (citing Control Yuan announcement of 2000-04-24, (八九)院台財字第 892200294 號 [ref. no. (89) Yuan-Tai-Tsai 892200294]), and the main text. The thesis gives 2000-04-17 in several places, but in one place cites 「監察院會議紀錄,2001/04/17」 ("Control Yuan meeting minutes, 2001/04/17").. Secondhand account
See also
- 1987 to present・Postwar officialsMa Yi-kung⚖︎Environmental writer and former Control Yuan member
- 1987 to present・Postwar officialsKu Teng-meiControl Yuan member who moved to correct the Binnan EIA review
- 1987 to present・Postwar officialsChang Te-mingControl Yuan member who censured the Binnan EIA review
- 66th EIA plenary meeting on the Binnan case (1999)The EIA plenary that conditionally approved the Binnan caseContains 1 items
- Control Yuan corrective measure on the Binnan Industrial Park land sale (2000)County government rebuked for adding a guideline point for Binnan
- Binnan Industrial Park⚖︎A 1990s petrochemical and steel industrial park project at QiguContains 73 items
- 1987 to present・Postwar officialsTsai Hsun-hsiungFormer Minister of the Environmental Protection Administration
Reports that mention it
Hall of the Present6.5Present conditions and institutions / Industrial parks and pollution
The Binnan Industrial Park: The 16 Years It Was Held Back
A single development project merged from two conglomerates, two purposes, and one dedicated industrial port: proposed in 1993, passed its EIA in 1999, finalized by notice in 2006, and ended in 2009 through the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act — not because the EIA was overturned.
Continue from here
- Other EventsCase of Yang Ching-chi et al., Danei Branch⚖︎A 1950 White Terror case in Danei Township, Tainan County
- Related entriesMa Yi-kung⚖︎Environmental writer and former Control Yuan member
- Entries in the same hallTaiwan Alkali Anshun Plant⚖︎A former chlor-alkali plant and Taiwan's pollution site No. 1Contains 28 items