66th EIA plenary meeting on the Binnan case (1999)

Secondhand account
061

Verification status of the entries on this page

  • Verified
  • Partially verified
  • Not covered by sources
  • Verified: the source was found and checked
  • Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

Guided reading

The 66th EIA plenary meeting on the Binnan case was the 66th meeting of the Environmental Impact Assessment Review Committee of the Environmental Protection Administration, held on 17 December 1999, which conditionally approved the Binnan Industrial Park development by way of an "ad hoc motion."R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 56 [p. 56]Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved(None, or not applicable)Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Main text, citing Hsieh Chun-hsiung (謝俊雄) 2000 and Lin Chuang-ying (林壯穎) 2000.

Evidence mix
Verification
  • ✓ Verified 0
  • ◑ Partially verified 6
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources 1
Source type
  • Secondhand account 13
✓ ◑ ⊗
  • ✓ Verified: the source was found and checked
  • ◑ Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.

Relationship map

  • Places
  • Events
  • People, shops and terms

The 66th EIA plenary meeting on the Binnan case was the 66th meeting of the Environmental Impact Assessment Review Committee of the Executive Yuan's Environmental Protection Administration, held on 17 December 1999 and chaired by Administrator Tsai Hsun-hsiung, which by way of an "ad hoc motion" (「臨時提案」) conditionally approved the second-stage EIA of the Binnan Industrial Park development R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 56 [p. 56]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 56Main text, citing Hsieh Chun-hsiung (謝俊雄) 2000 and Lin Chuang-ying (林壯穎) 2000.R004SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁),《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"](國立中山大學政治學研究所在職專班碩士論文 [master's thesis, in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University],2005),頁 130、138 [pp. 130, 138]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 130、138Note 271 (citing the Economic Daily News (經濟日報) of 1999-12-18) and note 298.. Secondhand account It resolved that no more than 5% of the Qigu Lagoon could be used and that the northern tidal inlet must not be blocked, with the developer required to keep the inlet open by artificial means R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 56 [p. 56]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 56Main text, citing Hsieh Chun-hsiung (謝俊雄) 2000 and Lin Chuang-ying (林壯穎) 2000.. Opponents questioned whether the timing was linked to the presidential election and the Hsing Piao bills affair, while Tsai Hsun-hsiung said the decision was the committee members' consensus R003SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 104–105 [pp. 104–105]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 104–105Main text and note 115, citing the United Daily News (聯合報) of 2000-01-16.. In April 2000 the Control Yuan censured the EPA over this review.

Course of events

3 items1999First items: 1999-12-17 Chen Ya-fen's (陳雅芬) thesis : …Tsai Lung-yu's (蔡隆郁) thesis, citing the …At the 14th preliminary review meeting t…MoreLess
  1. 1999-12-17 Chen Ya-fen's (陳雅芬) thesis R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 56 [p. 56]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 56Main text, citing Hsieh Chun-hsiung (謝俊雄) 2000 and Lin Chuang-ying (林壯穎) 2000.:Secondhand account

    「環保署在無任何地方反對人士列席旁聽的情況之下,以『臨時提案』方式,有條件通過濱南案,會中決議:使用七股潟湖面積不得超過百分之五,且不得堵塞北潮口,開發單位應採人工方式維持北潮口暢通,讓潟湖的生態不致因工業區開發而受影響」 ("Without any local opponents present to observe, the EPA conditionally approved the Binnan case by way of an 'ad hoc motion'. The meeting resolved that the area of Qigu Lagoon used may not exceed five percent, that the northern tidal inlet may not be blocked, and that the developer shall keep the northern tidal inlet open by artificial means, so that the lagoon's ecology is not affected by the development of the industrial park.")

  2. Tsai Lung-yu's (蔡隆郁) thesis, citing the Economic Daily News (經濟日報) of 1999-12-18: the proportion of the lagoon to be used was reduced to 5%, the area used by the industrial park was cut to about 1,000 hectares, and the industrial port would be developed under the lead of the Industrial Development Bureau; although the Council of Agriculture would designate a conservation area, the committee members still required the developer to keep monitoring the Black-faced spoonbill R004SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁),《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"](國立中山大學政治學研究所在職專班碩士論文 [master's thesis, in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University],2005),頁 130、138 [pp. 130, 138]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 130、138Note 271 (citing the Economic Daily News (經濟日報) of 1999-12-18) and note 298..Secondhand account
  3. At the 14th preliminary review meeting two days earlier, on 1999-12-15, only 4 review committee members attended (the legal minimum); a scholar interviewed in Chen Ya-fen's thesis said there were 30 committee members in all and that in the fourteen preliminary reviews attendance 「未有一次達半數以上」 ("never once reached more than half") R002SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 93–95 [pp. 93–95]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93–95Main text and notes 102–104..Secondhand account

Accounts

5 itemsFirst items: Legislator Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智) handed out…EPA Minister Tsai Hsun-hsiung (蔡勳雄), who…A member of the expert panel (United Dai…MoreLess
  1. Legislator Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智) handed out leaflets outside the meeting venue that day, asking whether 「為了興票案和陳由豪做了某些利益交換?是為總統大選綁樁」 ("some exchange of interests was made with Chen Yu-hao (陳由豪) for the sake of the Chung Hsing Bills case? Was it to lock in support for the presidential election") R003SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 104–105 [pp. 104–105]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 104–105Main text and note 115, citing the United Daily News (聯合報) of 2000-01-16..Secondhand account
  2. EPA Minister Tsai Hsun-hsiung (蔡勳雄), who chaired the meeting: the conditional approval was 「環評委員的合識,不是他個人決定」 ("the consensus of the EIA committee members, not his personal decision") R003SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 104–105 [pp. 104–105]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 104–105Main text and note 115, citing the United Daily News (聯合報) of 2000-01-16..Secondhand account
  3. A member of the expert panel (United Daily News (聯合報), 2000-01-16): 「到最後階段,幕僚作業強勢運作,配合開發單位的氣氛明顯」 ("in the final stage, the staff work was run forcefully, and the atmosphere of accommodating the developer was obvious") R003SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 104–105 [pp. 104–105]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 104–105Main text and note 115, citing the United Daily News (聯合報) of 2000-01-16..Secondhand account
  4. A scholar interviewee said that on December 16 she learned through private channels that the case would be passed the next day, and on the 17th she 「闖關會場」 ("forced her way into the meeting venue"); she also said a committee member she knew had jokingly told her 「別再出席了」 ("not to attend anymore") R002SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 93–95 [pp. 93–95]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93–95Main text and notes 102–104.R003SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 104–105 [pp. 104–105]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 104–105Main text and note 115, citing the United Daily News (聯合報) of 2000-01-16..Secondhand account
  5. The author of Tsai Lung-yu's thesis argues that the timing of the approval was related to the effort to create an atmosphere of prioritizing the economy before the 2000 presidential election (the thesis author's inference) R005SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁),《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"](國立中山大學政治學研究所在職專班碩士論文 [master's thesis, in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University],2005),頁 130、150 [pp. 130, 150]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 130、150The thesis author's inference..Secondhand account

Differing accounts

  1. The number of attached items:
    1. Chen Ya-fen's thesis, citing Lin Chuang-ying (林壯穎): 「夾帶了 28 條建議開發單位辦理事項、8 項定稿本需修訂項目與 10 項附帶建議」 ("it carried with it 28 items the developer was advised to carry out, 8 items to be revised in the final version, and 10 supplementary recommendations") R001SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 56 [p. 56]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 56Main text, citing Hsieh Chun-hsiung (謝俊雄) 2000 and Lin Chuang-ying (林壯穎) 2000..Secondhand account
    2. Tsai Lung-yu's thesis: 「並列 27 項條件……補充事項計八項……附帶建議九項」 ("27 conditions were listed... supplementary items numbered eight... supplementary recommendations, nine") R004SourceTsai Lung-yu (蔡隆郁),《台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例》[The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit"](國立中山大學政治學研究所在職專班碩士論文 [master's thesis, in-service master's program, Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University],2005),頁 130、138 [pp. 130, 138]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The analysis of the State autonomy after democratization of Taiwan - case study of "Bin-nan industril exploit" (台灣民主化後國家機關自主性分析:以濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 130、138Note 271 (citing the Economic Daily News (經濟日報) of 1999-12-18) and note 298..Secondhand account
  2. Which meeting it was at which only four committee members attended, three of whom opposed use of the lagoon: in one place Chen Ya-fen's thesis gives the 14th preliminary review on 12-15, while in another the account follows the 12-17 plenary R002SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 93–95 [pp. 93–95]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 93–95Main text and notes 102–104..Secondhand account
  3. The Deputy Magistrate of Tainan County (interviewee C in Chen Ya-fen's thesis) said 「該案於八十九年十一月廿九日環評會議中決議:有條件通過」 ("the case was resolved at the EIA meeting of November 29, ROC year 89 [2000]: conditionally approved"), which differs from 1999-12-17; 2000-11-29 was the review meeting for the final version R006SourceChen Ya-fen (陳雅芬),《地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例》[A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County](國立中正大學政治學系碩士論文 [master's thesis, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University],2002),頁 148 [p. 148]Original URL—Retrieved—Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《A Study of Local Democracy and Sustainable Development: The Case of the Binnan Industrial Park Development Project in Tainan County (地方民主與永續發展之研究:以台南縣濱南工業區開發案為例)》p. 148Appendix 2, interview with interviewee C (Deputy Magistrate of Tainan County)..Secondhand account

See also

Reports that mention it

Hall of the Present6.5Present conditions and institutions / Industrial parks and pollution

The Binnan Industrial Park: The 16 Years It Was Held Back

A single development project merged from two conglomerates, two purposes, and one dedicated industrial port: proposed in 1993, passed its EIA in 1999, finalized by notice in 2006, and ended in 2009 through the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act — not because the EIA was overturned.

1553

Continue from here