Guided reading
Milkfish farming area has shrunk by a third in ten years, 330 hectares of fish farm ponds sit on illegal land-use categories, and no solar panels are to go west of Provincial Highway 61. Yet not one of the fishery–solar and ground-mounted solar projects in this area has an EIA case number — not because environmental impact assessment failed to do its job, but because the law at the time did not require one.R001SourceTwo accounts of the year the old temple was finally destroyed: 1871 (Tongzhi 10), consistent across the Luermen Tianhou Temple side, three places in the three volumes of the Place-Name Trilogy, and the Ministry of the Interior's (內政部) standard place-name database; the current history on the official website of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple gives 1831 (Daoguang 11)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19That the law did not require an EIA for this does not mean that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job.
- Time span
- 2024–20262 years
- Current status
- Not one of the fishery–solar or ground-mounted solar sites in this area has an EIA case number; over the Xiao Erjia case, the Control Yuan has impeached the former Economic Development Bureau director, a Bureau of Energy division director and the Bureau of Energy director-general, and has issued corrective measures against the Energy Administration and the Tainan City Government R002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.R007Source監察院 [Control Yuan] corrective case 114財正0003 (proposed by Lin Wen-cheng [林文程], Pasuya Poiconx [浦忠成], and Chao Yung-ching [趙永清]; corrective measures against the Energy Administration of the Ministry of Economic Affairs [經濟部能源署] and the Tainan City Government [臺南市政府]), 2025-03-05Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBox.aspx?n=134&CSN=2&page=7&PageSize=20Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. As of October 2026, the Xiao Erjia case and the Taiyen Green Energy case were still at first instance in the Tainan District Court, and the Disciplinary Court had suspended the impeachment case pending the criminal judgment R018Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈監察院彈劾案件懲戒法院裁定停止審理一覽表〉[List of Control Yuan Impeachment Cases in Which the Disciplinary Court Has Ruled to Suspend Proceedings] (version of 2026-09-30 [115 年 9 月 30 日版], item 6)Original URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/77205Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R019Source聯合報 [United Daily News] (reporter Shao Hsin-chieh [邵心杰]), 〈台南光電弊案今下午開庭 同案被告經發局專員揭聯審秘辛〉[Tainan Solar Corruption Case Goes to Court This Afternoon; Co-defendant Economic Development Bureau Specialist Reveals Inside Story of Joint Review], 2026-05-20Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7321/9515459Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R017Source天地傳媒 [Tiandi Media (TDNS)] republication of the 臺灣臺南地方法院 [Taiwan Tainan District Court] press release on ruling 114 Chin-Chung-Su No. 2 (114 年度金重訴字第 2 號) (2026-09-21 extension of exit and sea-travel restrictions and electronic monitoring)Original URLhttps://tdns.net.tw/news_view.php?new_sn=143975Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—.
- Key figures
- 96.15% (139 of 156)Share of the five Liyang companies' cases with backdated documentsR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.
- NT$9.1 billionExpected 20-year generation revenue of Liyang's sitesR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.
- NT$460 million → NT$2.14 million actually receivedCompensation for timber on Taisugar's Qigu FarmR003SourceThe shrinking timber compensation for converting afforested land on the Taisugar (台糖) Qigu Farm to solar (NT$460 million → NT$65.71 million → NT$2.14 million actually collected; cancellation of 146 ha of lowland afforestation and repayment of NT$52.64 million in afforestation subsidies); the Tainan City Government (臺南市政府) fined Qigu solar project sites 12 times, totaling NT$1.68 millionOriginal URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19A different district from Tucheng, but the same system operating on the periphery of Taijiang.
- 17,609 panels (37 sites)Solar panels damaged in Tainan by Typhoon DanasR005SourceStatistics on solar damage from Typhoon Danas (丹娜絲颱風) (37 project sites in Tainan, 17,609 panels, 352.2 metric tons, 7.044 MW; Qigu wind-resistance design of 37.5 m/s vs. actual Beaufort force 16 gusts of 50.1–56.0 m/s)Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The gap between the wind-resistance design value and the actual wind speed is a set of figures that can be cited directly.
- Evidence mix
Why it matters
The Qigu and Beimen solar cases are not in Tucheng, but they show how one and the same system operates around the edge of Taijiang R003SourceThe shrinking timber compensation for converting afforested land on the Taisugar (台糖) Qigu Farm to solar (NT$460 million → NT$65.71 million → NT$2.14 million actually collected; cancellation of 146 ha of lowland afforestation and repayment of NT$52.64 million in afforestation subsidies); the Tainan City Government (臺南市政府) fined Qigu solar project sites 12 times, totaling NT$1.68 millionOriginal URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19A different district from Tucheng, but the same system operating on the periphery of Taijiang.. This page brings three things together: the sites were exempt from EIA under the law of the time R001SourceTwo accounts of the year the old temple was finally destroyed: 1871 (Tongzhi 10), consistent across the Luermen Tianhou Temple side, three places in the three volumes of the Place-Name Trilogy, and the Ministry of the Interior's (內政部) standard place-name database; the current history on the official website of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple gives 1831 (Daoguang 11)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19That the law did not require an EIA for this does not mean that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job., fish-pond registration had long been out of step with actual land use R006SourceOfficial threat narrative (conversion of shallow-flat fish ponds to deep ponds is unfavorable to black-faced spoonbill foraging; fish pond registrations are not updated, so changes can only be detected by satellite imagery); milkfish farming area down by a third in ten years, fish prices doubled, 330 ha of fish farm ponds on illegal land-use categories, no solar west of Provincial Highway 61Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Statistical years follow the original tables., and the Control Yuan found backdated applications and shrinking timber compensation R002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.R003SourceThe shrinking timber compensation for converting afforested land on the Taisugar (台糖) Qigu Farm to solar (NT$460 million → NT$65.71 million → NT$2.14 million actually collected; cancellation of 146 ha of lowland afforestation and repayment of NT$52.64 million in afforestation subsidies); the Tainan City Government (臺南市政府) fined Qigu solar project sites 12 times, totaling NT$1.68 millionOriginal URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19A different district from Tucheng, but the same system operating on the periphery of Taijiang..{{官方文獻}} Official records also note the line "no solar west of Provincial Highway 61" R006SourceOfficial threat narrative (conversion of shallow-flat fish ponds to deep ponds is unfavorable to black-faced spoonbill foraging; fish pond registrations are not updated, so changes can only be detected by satellite imagery); milkfish farming area down by a third in ten years, fish prices doubled, 330 ha of fish farm ponds on illegal land-use categories, no solar west of Provincial Highway 61Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Statistical years follow the original tables..
Main actors
Control Yuan 1
- Control YuanImpeachment and corrective measures in 114財調0012; investigation of timber compensation on Taisugar's Qigu FarmR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.
Central government 2
- Environmental Protection AdministrationDetermined under the law that the sites were exempt from EIAR001SourceTwo accounts of the year the old temple was finally destroyed: 1871 (Tongzhi 10), consistent across the Luermen Tianhou Temple side, three places in the three volumes of the Place-Name Trilogy, and the Ministry of the Interior's (內政部) standard place-name database; the current history on the official website of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple gives 1831 (Daoguang 11)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19That the law did not require an EIA for this does not mean that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job.
- Bureau of Energy director-general and division directorImpeached by the Control YuanR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.
Local government 2
- Former director of the Tainan City Economic Development BureauImpeached by the Control YuanR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.
- Tainan City GovernmentFined Qigu solar sites 12 times, NT$1.68 million in totalR003SourceThe shrinking timber compensation for converting afforested land on the Taisugar (台糖) Qigu Farm to solar (NT$460 million → NT$65.71 million → NT$2.14 million actually collected; cancellation of 146 ha of lowland afforestation and repayment of NT$52.64 million in afforestation subsidies); the Tainan City Government (臺南市政府) fined Qigu solar project sites 12 times, totaling NT$1.68 millionOriginal URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19A different district from Tucheng, but the same system operating on the periphery of Taijiang.
Developers 2
- Five companies of the Liyang group139 of 156 cases filed with backdated documentsR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.
- Taiwan Sugar CorporationConverted afforested land on its Qigu Farm to solar; 146 hectares of lowland afforestation deregisteredR003SourceThe shrinking timber compensation for converting afforested land on the Taisugar (台糖) Qigu Farm to solar (NT$460 million → NT$65.71 million → NT$2.14 million actually collected; cancellation of 146 ha of lowland afforestation and repayment of NT$52.64 million in afforestation subsidies); the Tainan City Government (臺南市政府) fined Qigu solar project sites 12 times, totaling NT$1.68 millionOriginal URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19A different district from Tucheng, but the same system operating on the periphery of Taijiang.
National park 1
- Taijiang National Park HeadquartersOfficial threat narrative: shallow fish ponds deepened, to the detriment of black-faced spoonbill foragingR006SourceOfficial threat narrative (conversion of shallow-flat fish ponds to deep ponds is unfavorable to black-faced spoonbill foraging; fish pond registrations are not updated, so changes can only be detected by satellite imagery); milkfish farming area down by a third in ten years, fish prices doubled, 330 ha of fish farm ponds on illegal land-use categories, no solar west of Provincial Highway 61Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Statistical years follow the original tables.
Local residents 2
- Luzhugou community, BeimenThe solar farm comes within 10 meters of homes; the information session was held at Erchonggang, 5 km awayR004SourceThe statutory EIA-exempt path in the Luzhugou (蘆竹溝) case (Zone 34 designated in September 2017 [ROC year 106], five designation principles, the solar farm only 10 m from the nearest home at its closest point, the briefing held at Erchonggang [二重港] 5 km away)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Can serve as a comparison case of "procedurally lawful but extremely close."
- Qigu village chiefs and the residents' self-help associationLaunched the "Oppose Improper Solar, Save Qigu" petition in November 2023 and delivered 11,505 signatures to the city government on 2024-01-04R014Source公視新聞網 [PTS News Network] (Chen Huan-yu [陳奐宇], Chen Hsien-kun [陳顯坤]), 〈七股開發光電農地魚塭破碎化 萬人連署反對不當種電〉[Solar Development in Qigu Fragments Farmland and Fish Ponds; Ten Thousand Sign Petition Against Improper Solar Installation], 2024-01-04Original URLhttps://news.pts.org.tw/article/674801Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Judiciary 1
- Taiwan Tainan District CourtXiao Erjia case (113 Su No. 349 [113 年度訴字第 349 號]) and Taiyen Green Energy case (114 Chin-Chung-Su No. 2 [114 年度金重訴字第 2 號]) on trial at first instanceR019Source聯合報 [United Daily News] (reporter Shao Hsin-chieh [邵心杰]), 〈台南光電弊案今下午開庭 同案被告經發局專員揭聯審秘辛〉[Tainan Solar Corruption Case Goes to Court This Afternoon; Co-defendant Economic Development Bureau Specialist Reveals Inside Story of Joint Review], 2026-05-20Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7321/9515459Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Points of contention
These are the questions people have argued over. Each side's account is set out as stated; this site does not rule on them.
1None of the solar sites had an EIA. Was that a failure of oversight?2
- Control Yuan investigation report
The EPA lawfully determined the sites exempt from EIA, and as non-co-location projects they needed no environmental and social review; it was the law that did not require an EIA, not the EIA system failing to checkR001SourceTwo accounts of the year the old temple was finally destroyed: 1871 (Tongzhi 10), consistent across the Luermen Tianhou Temple side, three places in the three volumes of the Place-Name Trilogy, and the Ministry of the Interior's (內政部) standard place-name database; the current history on the official website of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple gives 1831 (Daoguang 11)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19That the law did not require an EIA for this does not mean that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job.
- What happened at Luzhugou
The procedure was lawful, but the solar farm comes within 10 meters of homes, while the information session was held at Erchonggang, 5 km awayR004SourceThe statutory EIA-exempt path in the Luzhugou (蘆竹溝) case (Zone 34 designated in September 2017 [ROC year 106], five designation principles, the solar farm only 10 m from the nearest home at its closest point, the briefing held at Erchonggang [二重港] 5 km away)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Can serve as a comparison case of "procedurally lawful but extremely close."
- Control Yuan investigation report
Turning points
Click a year to jump to it in the full timeline below.
- 2017-09Area 34 near Luzhugou, Beimen, was designated, setting ground-mounted solar on the legal path to EIA exemptionR004SourceThe statutory EIA-exempt path in the Luzhugou (蘆竹溝) case (Zone 34 designated in September 2017 [ROC year 106], five designation principles, the solar farm only 10 m from the nearest home at its closest point, the briefing held at Erchonggang [二重港] 5 km away)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Can serve as a comparison case of "procedurally lawful but extremely close."
- 2024-04-26Tainan District Prosecutors Office indicts 15 people in the Xiao Erjia caseR015Source臺灣臺南地方檢察署 [Taiwan Tainan District Prosecutors Office] press release, 〈南檢偵辦轄內太陽光電業者力 O 集團與公務員共謀圖利等案提起公訴〉[Tainan Prosecutors Indict Solar Operator Li-O Group and Public Officials for Conspiring to Confer Illegal Benefits, among Other Charges], 2024-04-26Original URLhttps://www.tnc.moj.gov.tw/media/357057/1130426%E5%8D%97%E6%AA%A2%E5%81%B5%E8%BE%A6%E5%8A%9Bo%E9%9B%86%E5%9C%98%E5%A4%AA%E9%99%BD%E5%85%89%E9%9B%BB%E6%A1%88%E5%81%B5%E6%9F%A5%E7%B5%82%E7%B5%90%E4%B8%A6%E6%8F%90%E8%B5%B7%E5%85%AC%E8%A8%B4%E6%96%B0%E8%81%9E%E7%A8%BF.pdf?mediaDL=trueRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 2025Control Yuan report 114財調0012 impeached the former Economic Development Bureau director and two Bureau of Energy officialsR002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.
- 2025-05-01Disciplinary Court suspends the impeachment case pending the criminal judgmentR018Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈監察院彈劾案件懲戒法院裁定停止審理一覽表〉[List of Control Yuan Impeachment Cases in Which the Disciplinary Court Has Ruled to Suspend Proceedings] (version of 2026-09-30 [115 年 9 月 30 日版], item 6)Original URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/77205Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Where to start reading
- EntryQigu Solar DevelopmentThe Qigu solar development is the series of development projects and disputes that arose from about 2017 as solar power was installed on salt fields, fish ponds and Taisugar farmland in Qigu District, Tainan, including the Taisugar Qigu Farm, "small two-jia" and Dachaogou cases; in 2022 the Ministry of Economic Affairs promised a cap on total solar in Qigu.
- EntryProvincial Highway 61Provincial Highway 61 (the West Coast Expressway) is an expressway along Taiwan's west coast whose Tainan section currently ends at the Shifen Interchange in Qigu District; the Zengwen River Bridge, which will cross the river to meet Taijiang Boulevard in Annan District, broke ground in December 2022 and is expected to be finished by the end of 2029.
- EntryBlack-faced spoonbill (Platalea minor)The black-faced spoonbill (Platalea minor) is a large wading bird of the ibis family with a flat, lute-shaped black bill; Taiwan is its most important wintering ground, and the Zengwen River estuary and the Tucheng fish ponds in Taijiang are among its main habitats.
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
What it is
- This page covers fishery–solar co-location and ground-mounted solar in the Qigu (七股) and Beimen (北門) area: how they were exempt from EIA under the law of the time, where the competent authorities' review went wrong, and what local fish farmers and village chiefs say R001SourceTwo accounts of the year the old temple was finally destroyed: 1871 (Tongzhi 10), consistent across the Luermen Tianhou Temple side, three places in the three volumes of the Place-Name Trilogy, and the Ministry of the Interior's (內政部) standard place-name database; the current history on the official website of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple gives 1831 (Daoguang 11)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19That the law did not require an EIA for this does not mean that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job.R002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.R013Source報導者 [The Reporter], 〈當光電包圍漁村:七股漁電共生風波再起,居民在抗議什麼?〉[When Solar Surrounds a Fishing Village: Qigu's Fishery–Solar Controversy Flares Again — What Are Residents Protesting?] (text by Lin Yu-yu [林雨佑]), 2022-11-10Original URLhttps://www.twreporter.org/a/qigu-fishery-electricity-symbiosisRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- The project sites are not in Tucheng, but Annan District (安南區), where Tucheng lies, was also among the first fishery–solar pilot zones; for a detailed chronology and the names of those involved, see the entry "Qigu Solar Development" (七股光電開發).
The statutory EIA-exempt path
Not one of the fishery–solar co-location (aquavoltaics, 漁電共生) and ground-mounted solar (photovoltaic) power (光電) project sites in this area has an environmental impact assessment (EIA, 環評) case number R001SourceTwo accounts of the year the old temple was finally destroyed: 1871 (Tongzhi 10), consistent across the Luermen Tianhou Temple side, three places in the three volumes of the Place-Name Trilogy, and the Ministry of the Interior's (內政部) standard place-name database; the current history on the official website of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple gives 1831 (Daoguang 11)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19That the law did not require an EIA for this does not mean that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job.. Official record The Control Yuan (監察院) investigation report states: 「經環保署依法判認免實施環境影響評估,且因非屬漁電共生類型,尚無須辦理環境與社會檢核」 ("the Environmental Protection Administration determined in accordance with the law that no environmental impact assessment was required, and because it is not of the fishery–solar co-location type, no environmental and social review is required either") R001SourceTwo accounts of the year the old temple was finally destroyed: 1871 (Tongzhi 10), consistent across the Luermen Tianhou Temple side, three places in the three volumes of the Place-Name Trilogy, and the Ministry of the Interior's (內政部) standard place-name database; the current history on the official website of the Orthodox Luermen Shengmu Temple gives 1831 (Daoguang 11)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19That the law did not require an EIA for this does not mean that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job.. In other words, it was that the law at the time did not require an EIA, not that environmental impact assessment failed to do its job.

The numbers on the aquaculture side
Milkfish farming area has fallen by a third in ten years while fish prices have doubled; the land-use category of 330 hectares of fish farm ponds is not lawful; and on the policy side, no solar panels are to be installed west of Provincial Highway 61 (台61線) R006SourceOfficial threat narrative (conversion of shallow-flat fish ponds to deep ponds is unfavorable to black-faced spoonbill foraging; fish pond registrations are not updated, so changes can only be detected by satellite imagery); milkfish farming area down by a third in ten years, fish prices doubled, 330 ha of fish farm ponds on illegal land-use categories, no solar west of Provincial Highway 61Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Statistical years follow the original tables.. Official record The authorities' own threat narrative has two strands: the conversion of shallow-flat fish ponds into deep ponds is unfavorable to black-faced spoonbill (黑面琵鷺) foraging; and fish pond registrations do not change with actual use, so the competent authorities can only detect changes through satellite imagery R006SourceOfficial threat narrative (conversion of shallow-flat fish ponds to deep ponds is unfavorable to black-faced spoonbill foraging; fish pond registrations are not updated, so changes can only be detected by satellite imagery); milkfish farming area down by a third in ten years, fish prices doubled, 330 ha of fish farm ponds on illegal land-use categories, no solar west of Provincial Highway 61Original URLhttps://www.tjnp.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Statistical years follow the original tables.. Unverified These two strands are the premise for understanding "why solar was able to come in" — the actual use of land and its registered status have long been out of step.
An administrative dissection of the Qigu project sites
MoreLess
The Control Yuan's impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 found that of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group (力暘集團), 139 were backdated, or 96.15 percent; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with an installed capacity of 92.8 MW and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over twenty years; those impeached included the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy (能源局), and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy R002SourceControl Yuan (監察院) impeachment and corrective case 114財調0012 (of 156 cases filed by five companies of the Liyang Group [力暘集團], 139 were backdated, 96.15%; changes were completed for 124 project sites, with 92.8 MW installed and expected generation revenue of NT$9.1 billion over 20 years; impeachment of the former director of the Economic Development Bureau, a division chief of the Bureau of Energy, and the director-general of the Bureau of Energy)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Control Yuan corrective-case database.. Official record The timber compensation for converting afforested land on the Taisugar (台糖) Qigu (七股) Farm to solar shrank at every step: NT$460 million → NT$65.71 million → NT$2.14 million actually collected; in addition, 146 hectares of lowland afforestation were canceled and NT$52.64 million in afforestation subsidies repaid; the Tainan City Government (臺南市政府) fined Qigu solar project sites 12 times, totaling NT$1.68 million R003SourceThe shrinking timber compensation for converting afforested land on the Taisugar (台糖) Qigu Farm to solar (NT$460 million → NT$65.71 million → NT$2.14 million actually collected; cancellation of 146 ha of lowland afforestation and repayment of NT$52.64 million in afforestation subsidies); the Tainan City Government (臺南市政府) fined Qigu solar project sites 12 times, totaling NT$1.68 millionOriginal URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19A different district from Tucheng, but the same system operating on the periphery of Taijiang..
The Luzhugou (蘆竹溝) case shows what the statutory 「免環評」 ("EIA-exempt") path looks like: Zone 34 was designated in September 2017 (ROC year 106) according to five principles, the nearest point of the solar farm is only 10 meters from a home, and the briefing was held at Erchonggang (二重港), 5 kilometers away R004SourceThe statutory EIA-exempt path in the Luzhugou (蘆竹溝) case (Zone 34 designated in September 2017 [ROC year 106], five designation principles, the solar farm only 10 m from the nearest home at its closest point, the briefing held at Erchonggang [二重港] 5 km away)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19Can serve as a comparison case of "procedurally lawful but extremely close.". Official record None of these is in Tucheng (土城), but they show how the same system operates on the periphery of Taijiang (台江).
Damage to project sites in the typhoon
Typhoon Danas (丹娜絲颱風) damaged 37 solar project sites in Tainan (臺南): 17,609 solar panels, 352.2 metric tons, 7.044 MW. The wind-resistance design value of the Qigu project sites was 37.5 m/s, while the actual gusts at the time reached Beaufort force 16, 50.1 to 56.0 m/s R005SourceStatistics on solar damage from Typhoon Danas (丹娜絲颱風) (37 project sites in Tainan, 17,609 panels, 352.2 metric tons, 7.044 MW; Qigu wind-resistance design of 37.5 m/s vs. actual Beaufort force 16 gusts of 50.1–56.0 m/s)Original URL—Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The gap between the wind-resistance design value and the actual wind speed is a set of figures that can be cited directly.. Official record
Citywide solar background figures
- As of 2023-12-31, Tainan had 「太陽光電同意備案共12,062件,備案容量達4.1GW」 ("a total of 12,062 approved solar PV filings, with a filed capacity of 4.1 GW"); the city government launched its Solar City (陽光電城) program in 2011 (ROC year 100), and the ground-mounted component of version 2.0 in 2019 included salt-industry land, water surfaces, and landfills R011Source臺南市政府經發局 [Economic Development Bureau, Tainan City Government] press release (statistics on approved solar PV filings), 2024-02-10Original URLhttps://www.tainan.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=13370&s=8618249Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- December 2019, the 「綠能屋頂全民參與」 (Green Energy Rooftops with Public Participation) promotion program: the contract for the six districts of West Central, Anping, Annan, East, South, and North went to California Energy Storage Co., Ltd. (加州儲能股份有限公司), with a feed-in tariff rebate of 10 percent; the contract for the Xinan area (溪南地區, including Jiangjun [將軍] and Qigu) went to Zhaomingsheng Co., Ltd. (兆明升股份有限公司), with a rebate of 13.8 percent R010SourceOperator announcement of Tainan's 「綠能屋頂全民參與」 [Green Energy Rooftops with Public Participation] promotion program (republished on a school website), 2019-12-07Original URLhttps://web.hmes.tn.edu.tw/modules/tadnews/index.php?nsn=717Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- As of the end of 2025, the filed capacity of rooftop solar PV was 2,194.6 MW, about 44 percent of the city's installed solar capacity; 81 percent of the 264 MW added in 2025 was rooftop R012Source自由時報 [Liberty Times] (reporter Lin Yao-wen [林耀文]), report on Tainan's filed rooftop solar capacity, 2026-02-27Original URLhttps://estate.ltn.com.tw/article/27041Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
Other Control Yuan reports
- 2022-09-07 111財調0034: the Hexun No. 1 Solar Farm (禾迅一號光電場) at Luzhugou, Beimen, from obtaining its electricity-enterprise preparation permit in February 2019 to completion in August 2021, held four briefings; the Control Yuan found that 「業者相關說明仍未臻周延詳盡,難謂妥適」 ("the operator's explanations were still not thorough or detailed, and can hardly be considered appropriate") R008Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report 111財調0034 (Hexun No. 1 Solar Farm [禾迅一號光電場], Luzhugou, Beimen [北門蘆竹溝]; deliberated 2022-09-07, published 09-13)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=28027Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 2025-03-05 114財正0003: corrective measures against the Energy Administration of the Ministry of Economic Affairs (經濟部能源署) and the Tainan City Government for setting, by meeting decision, review criteria for three types of case that circumvented the Xiao Erjia (小二甲) ban; the Tainan City Government did not announce until 2023-03-30 that all applications submitted after 2023-07-31 would be rejected R007Source監察院 [Control Yuan] corrective case 114財正0003 (proposed by Lin Wen-cheng [林文程], Pasuya Poiconx [浦忠成], and Chao Yung-ching [趙永清]; corrective measures against the Energy Administration of the Ministry of Economic Affairs [經濟部能源署] and the Tainan City Government [臺南市政府]), 2025-03-05Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBox.aspx?n=134&CSN=2&page=7&PageSize=20Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 2026-07-23 115財調0026: Typhoon Danas left 「累計全臺多達12萬片光電板遭重創」 ("a cumulative total of as many as 120,000 solar panels across Taiwan badly damaged") R009Source監察院 [Control Yuan] investigation report 115財調0026 (solar damage from Typhoon Danas [丹娜絲颱風]; deliberated 2026-07-23, published 07-27)Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=49722Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Key events in the judicial proceedings
First items: The Tainan District Prosecutors Office (…The Tainan District Prosecutors Office i…The Disciplinary Court (懲戒法院) ruled to s…MoreLess
- 2024
04-26The Tainan District Prosecutors Office (…MoreLess
The Tainan District Prosecutors Office (臺南地檢署) indicted in the Xiao Erjia case: former Economic Development Bureau director Chen Kai-ling (陳凱凌) and three other public officials, together with Bureau of Energy division director Lin Wen-hsin (林文信), for conferring illegal benefits under the Anti-Corruption Act; Liyang Group (力暘集團) president Ku Sheng-hui (古盛煇) and nine others were indicted as accomplices R015Source臺灣臺南地方檢察署 [Taiwan Tainan District Prosecutors Office] press release, 〈南檢偵辦轄內太陽光電業者力 O 集團與公務員共謀圖利等案提起公訴〉[Tainan Prosecutors Indict Solar Operator Li-O Group and Public Officials for Conspiring to Confer Illegal Benefits, among Other Charges], 2024-04-26Original URLhttps://www.tnc.moj.gov.tw/media/357057/1130426%E5%8D%97%E6%AA%A2%E5%81%B5%E8%BE%A6%E5%8A%9Bo%E9%9B%86%E5%9C%98%E5%A4%AA%E9%99%BD%E5%85%89%E9%9B%BB%E6%A1%88%E5%81%B5%E6%9F%A5%E7%B5%82%E7%B5%90%E4%B8%A6%E6%8F%90%E8%B5%B7%E5%85%AC%E8%A8%B4%E6%96%B0%E8%81%9E%E7%A8%BF.pdf?mediaDL=trueRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 2025
02-27The Tainan District Prosecutors Office i…MoreLess
The Tainan District Prosecutors Office indicted five people in the Taiyen Green Energy (臺鹽綠能) case, seeking sentences of 12 years for the former chairman and 10 years for the former general manager, with the loss calculated on the basis of service fees already paid at more than NT$396.36 million R016Source天地傳媒 [Tiandi Media (TDNS)] republication of the explanation of 臺灣臺南地方法院 [Taiwan Tainan District Court] ruling 114 Chin-Chung-Su No. 2 (114 年度金重訴字第 2 號) and the Tainan District Prosecutors Office press release on the indictment in the Taiyen Green Energy (臺鹽綠能) case, 2025-02-27Original URLhttps://www.tdns.net.tw/news_view.php?new_sn=76910Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account05-01The Disciplinary Court (懲戒法院) ruled to s…MoreLess
The Disciplinary Court (懲戒法院) ruled to suspend proceedings on the Xiao Erjia impeachment case (Yu Chen-wei [游振偉], Lin Wen-hsin, Chen Kai-ling) pending the criminal judgment R018Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈監察院彈劾案件懲戒法院裁定停止審理一覽表〉[List of Control Yuan Impeachment Cases in Which the Disciplinary Court Has Ruled to Suspend Proceedings] (version of 2026-09-30 [115 年 9 月 30 日版], item 6)Original URLhttps://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/77205Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 2026
01-15The Yabisi Solar (雅比斯光電) case at Dachaog…MoreLess
The Yabisi Solar (雅比斯光電) case at Dachaogou (大潮溝), Qigu: the Tainan City Government revoked its letter of consent on 2022-12-15, and the operator filed an administrative suit; the Supreme Administrative Court (最高行政法院) ruled 「原判決廢棄,發回高雄高等行政法院高等行政訴訟庭。」 ("The original judgment is vacated and remanded to the High Administrative Litigation Division of the Kaohsiung High Administrative Court.") R020Source最高行政法院 [Supreme Administrative Court] Judgment 113 Shang No. 479 (113 年度上字第 479 號) (Yabisi Solar [雅比斯光電] v. Tainan City Government; revocation of permit), 2026-01-15Original URLhttps://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TPAA,113,%E4%B8%8A,479,20260115,1Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record05-20The Xiao Erjia case was heard at the Tai…MoreLess
The Xiao Erjia case was heard at the Tainan District Court; all defendants appeared, and examination of witnesses was still under way R019Source聯合報 [United Daily News] (reporter Shao Hsin-chieh [邵心杰]), 〈台南光電弊案今下午開庭 同案被告經發局專員揭聯審秘辛〉[Tainan Solar Corruption Case Goes to Court This Afternoon; Co-defendant Economic Development Bureau Specialist Reveals Inside Story of Joint Review], 2026-05-20Original URLhttps://udn.com/news/story/7321/9515459Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account09-21After defendants in the Taiyen Green Ene…MoreLess
After defendants in the Taiyen Green Energy case Chen Chi-yu (陳啟昱), Su Kun-huang (蘇坤煌), and Su Chun-jen (蘇俊仁) were released on bail, their travel restrictions and electronic ankle monitors were extended by another eight months; the first instance was still on trial R017Source天地傳媒 [Tiandi Media (TDNS)] republication of the 臺灣臺南地方法院 [Taiwan Tainan District Court] press release on ruling 114 Chin-Chung-Su No. 2 (114 年度金重訴字第 2 號) (2026-09-21 extension of exit and sea-travel restrictions and electronic monitoring)Original URLhttps://tdns.net.tw/news_view.php?new_sn=143975Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand accountNone of the criminal cases above has yet…MoreLess
None of the criminal cases above has yet reached a first-instance judgment; an indictment is the prosecutor's allegation, not a court's judgment.
Local voices
First items: Interviews by The Reporter (報導者) in 2022:2023-11-24 Qigu village chiefs and the r…2024-01-04 The petition was delivered to…MoreLess
- Interviews by The Reporter (報導者) in 2022:
- Yang Hui-chin (楊惠欽), chair of the Qigu Coastal Land Resources Protection Association (七股沿海土地資源保護協會), on fish farmers who lease their ponds: 「一旦真的要開發了,地主改口叫你走,你就得走,不然可能就變成侵佔土地。」 ("Once development really comes, the landowner changes his tune and tells you to go, and you have to go, or else it may become illegal occupation of land.") R013Source報導者 [The Reporter], 〈當光電包圍漁村:七股漁電共生風波再起,居民在抗議什麼?〉[When Solar Surrounds a Fishing Village: Qigu's Fishery–Solar Controversy Flares Again — What Are Residents Protesting?] (text by Lin Yu-yu [林雨佑]), 2022-11-10Original URLhttps://www.twreporter.org/a/qigu-fishery-electricity-symbiosisRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- Wang Pi-chu (王弼主), youth community representative of Sangu Village (三股里): 「沒有(養殖)產業就不會有人住⋯⋯我好像可以預見20年後,這裡過年都沒有人煙,只有光電板。」 ("Without the [aquaculture] industry, no one will live here... I can almost foresee that in 20 years there will be no one here even at Lunar New Year, only solar panels.") R013Source報導者 [The Reporter], 〈當光電包圍漁村:七股漁電共生風波再起,居民在抗議什麼?〉[When Solar Surrounds a Fishing Village: Qigu's Fishery–Solar Controversy Flares Again — What Are Residents Protesting?] (text by Lin Yu-yu [林雨佑]), 2022-11-10Original URLhttps://www.twreporter.org/a/qigu-fishery-electricity-symbiosisRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- Lee Shu-wei (李書緯), senior manager of the energy business department at the developer HD Renewable Energy (泓德能源): 「主要是他們(指佔有戶)沒有意願回來(養殖),不是公司拒絕。」 ("Mainly it's that they [the occupying households] have no wish to come back [to aquaculture]; it's not that the company refused.") R013Source報導者 [The Reporter], 〈當光電包圍漁村:七股漁電共生風波再起,居民在抗議什麼?〉[When Solar Surrounds a Fishing Village: Qigu's Fishery–Solar Controversy Flares Again — What Are Residents Protesting?] (text by Lin Yu-yu [林雨佑]), 2022-11-10Original URLhttps://www.twreporter.org/a/qigu-fishery-electricity-symbiosisRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- 2023-11-24 Qigu village chiefs and the residents' self-help association launched the "Oppose Improper Solar, Save Qigu" (「反不當種電救七股」) ten-thousand-signature petition and held a pledge event at Longshan Temple (龍山宮) R021SourceNOWnews (reporter Chang Chen-hsing [張振興]), 〈陳昆和與七股里長宣布發起「反不當種電救七股」萬人聯署活動〉[Chen Kun-ho and Qigu Village Chiefs Announce a Ten-Thousand-Signature Petition, 'Oppose Improper Solar, Save Qigu'], 2023-11-24Original URLhttps://www.nownews.com/news/6308025Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- 2024-01-04 The petition was delivered to the Tainan City Government; the report wrote 「短短1個多月,連署人數達到11,505人」 ("in just over a month, the number of signatories reached 11,505") R014Source公視新聞網 [PTS News Network] (Chen Huan-yu [陳奐宇], Chen Hsien-kun [陳顯坤]), 〈七股開發光電農地魚塭破碎化 萬人連署反對不當種電〉[Solar Development in Qigu Fragments Farmland and Fish Ponds; Ten Thousand Sign Petition Against Improper Solar Installation], 2024-01-04Original URLhttps://news.pts.org.tw/article/674801Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- Chen Chung-cheng (陳中正), head of the Qigu District Village Chiefs' Association: 「沒有總量管制一直種,是要把我們七股種多少,是要種8成還是9成,你要有一個限制,因為我們七股所種的量已經超過每1個縣市的總和。」 ("Installing on and on with no cap on the total—how much of Qigu do they want to cover, 80 percent or 90 percent? You have to have a limit, because the amount installed in Qigu already exceeds the total of any single county or city.") R014Source公視新聞網 [PTS News Network] (Chen Huan-yu [陳奐宇], Chen Hsien-kun [陳顯坤]), 〈七股開發光電農地魚塭破碎化 萬人連署反對不當種電〉[Solar Development in Qigu Fragments Farmland and Fish Ponds; Ten Thousand Sign Petition Against Improper Solar Installation], 2024-01-04Original URLhttps://news.pts.org.tw/article/674801Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- Huang Chin-shih (黃進士), chief of Qigu Village (七股里): 「政府說不可耕種的土地才可以種電,但是來我們七股看看,看那些好的田地上面被種電,拿得到的案場這邊1塊、那邊1塊,旁邊的田地現在要怎麼辦。」 ("The government says only land that can't be farmed may have solar, but come and look at Qigu—look at the good farmland with solar on it, the sites they could get, one piece here, one piece there. What are the fields next to them supposed to do now?") R014Source公視新聞網 [PTS News Network] (Chen Huan-yu [陳奐宇], Chen Hsien-kun [陳顯坤]), 〈七股開發光電農地魚塭破碎化 萬人連署反對不當種電〉[Solar Development in Qigu Fragments Farmland and Fish Ponds; Ten Thousand Sign Petition Against Improper Solar Installation], 2024-01-04Original URLhttps://news.pts.org.tw/article/674801Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- Hsiao Fu-jen (蕭富仁), deputy director of the Economic Development Bureau: 「民國112年7月30日正式停止受理兩公頃以下的太陽光電申請案。」 ("As of July 30, ROC year 112 [2023], we formally stopped accepting solar PV applications for sites under two hectares.") R014Source公視新聞網 [PTS News Network] (Chen Huan-yu [陳奐宇], Chen Hsien-kun [陳顯坤]), 〈七股開發光電農地魚塭破碎化 萬人連署反對不當種電〉[Solar Development in Qigu Fragments Farmland and Fish Ponds; Ten Thousand Sign Petition Against Improper Solar Installation], 2024-01-04Original URLhttps://news.pts.org.tw/article/674801Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
Video
Videos were uploaded by their respective channels; titles and channel names follow the video pages. This site quotes only short excerpts with timecodes; the videos themselves are authoritative.
Behind this door is the internal site, with profiles of people and local comments. The internal site is deployed separately.