Theses
The chronic health effects for residents with concurrent exposure to dioxin and methylmercury living near an deserted PCP and chloralkali factory in Tainan (某廢棄鹼氯及五氯酚工廠附近居民甲基汞及戴奧辛共同暴露評估暨慢性健康影響研究)
A doctoral dissertation of July 2009, supervised by Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋); 361 pages in PDF. It is the parent study of the health research on residents of the Anshun Plant contaminated area: from September 2004 to January 2009 it collected blood from 2,359 residents for dioxin, total mercury, methylmercury and biochemical tests, together with neurological examinations. Chapter 1 compiles the history, processes and environmental contamination data of the Anshun Plant, and the postscript is the author's first-person account of taking part in the discovery of the contamination and the setting of the compensation reference values.
1. Bibliographic details
- Title
- 《The chronic health effects for residents with concurrent exposure to dioxin and methylmercury living near an deserted PCP and chloralkali factory in Tainan (某廢棄鹼氯及五氯酚工廠附近居民甲基汞及戴奧辛共同暴露評估暨慢性健康影響研究)》
- English title
- The chronic health effects for residents with concurrent exposure to dioxin and methylmercury living near an deserted PCP and chloralkali factory in Tainan
- Also known as
- 《某廢棄鹼氯及五氯酚工廠附近居民甲基汞及戴奧辛共同暴露評估暨慢性健康影響研究》、《Chronic Health Effects for Residents with Concurrent Exposure to Dioxin and Methylmercury Living near a Deserted PCP and Chlor-alkali Factory in Tainan》
- Authors
- Chang Jung-wei (張榮偉) author;Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋) chief compiler
- Publisher
- 國立成功大學醫學院環境醫學研究所 [Institute of Environmental Medicine, College of Medicine, National Cheng Kung University](博士論文 [doctoral dissertation])
- Year
- 2009
Chang Jung-wei's (張榮偉) doctoral dissertation of July 2009, Institute of Environmental Medicine, College of Medicine, National Cheng Kung University, supervised by Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋).
Bibliographic details
- Title: 《某廢棄鹼氯及五氯酚工廠附近居民甲基汞及戴奧辛共同暴露評估暨慢性健康影響研究》.
- English title as printed: The chronic health effects for residents with concurrent exposure to dioxin and methylmercury living near an deserted PCP and chloralkali factory in Tainan ("an deserted" as in the original).
- Author: Chang Jung-wei (張榮偉), who signs his name in journals as Jung-Wei Chang; supervisor: Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋).
- Institution: Institute of Environmental Medicine, College of Medicine, National Cheng Kung University; doctoral dissertation.
- Date: July 2009 (ROC year 98); the acknowledgments are dated 2009/7/23.
- Length: 361 pages in PDF; the tables are at printed pp. 183–277, and appendices 1 to 6 (consent form, cognitive screening instrument, health and diet questionnaires, accepted papers, biochemistry report format) run to PDF p. 361.
- Keywords: methylmercury, dioxin, cognitive ability, insulin resistance, metabolic syndrome, interaction, ten-year cardiovascular disease risk.
Note on page numbers
- Citations on this site give the printed page of the dissertation. In the main text the PDF page is the printed page plus 18 (PDF p. 19 = printed p. 1).
- The acknowledgments are separately numbered 1–2 (PDF pp. 11–12); the Chinese abstract begins at printed p. I, PDF p. 13.
Chapters
- Chapter 1, Background (printed pp. 1–48): origins of the study; an introduction to the CPDC Anshun Plant; survey results for environmental media and aquatic organisms near the plant; the health hazards of mercury and dioxin; co-exposure.
- Chapter 2, Hypotheses; Chapter 3, Methods (printed pp. 52–71).
- Chapter 4, Results (printed pp. 72–104); Chapter 5, Discussion (printed pp. 105–118); Chapter 6, Conclusions and recommendations (printed pp. 119–124).
- Postscript (printed pp. 125–128); references; tables; appendices.
Main content
- Plant history and processes: a chlor-alkali plant was established in 1942, making caustic soda and chlorine by mercury-cathode electrolysis of brine; sodium pentachlorophenolate was first produced on a trial basis in 1964; in 1969 the company built "a sodium pentachlorophenolate plant then billed as the largest in East Asia, able to produce four metric tons a day" (當時號稱東亞最大可日產四公噸的五氯酚鈉工廠); production stopped in June 1979, when "nearly 5,000 kg of sodium pentachlorophenolate was sealed in storage on the plant grounds" (封存了近 5000 公斤五氯酚鈉於廠區內); the plant closed in 1982; and in 2004 the Tainan City Government designated it a contamination control site (printed pp. I, 1–3).
- Environmental data: total mercury in the sediment of the Luermen River and the seawater reservoir, and dioxin in the plant grounds and in fish from the reservoir (compiled from earlier surveys, printed pp. 3–6, 184–188).
- A table of blood dioxin among residents of 12 villages in Annan District (Table 1-1-2, printed p. 184).
- This study: from September 2004 to January 2009, blood was collected from 2,359 people, a participation rate of 82.6%; blood dioxin averaged 37.5 pg WHO98-TEQDF/g lipid with a median of 23.2, total mercury averaged 11.0 µg/L, and methylmercury made up about 90% of total mercury (printed pp. 72, 84–87, 93–95).
- Findings: the high-methylmercury group scored lower on cognitive screening; dioxin was associated with peripheral nerve conduction, insulin resistance and ten-year cardiovascular risk; those with both high dioxin and high total mercury had a higher risk of insulin resistance (odds ratio for the interaction term 2.1) (printed pp. 119–121).
- Postscript: the author records in the first person how blood tests on residents around the Chengxi Incinerator led to the Anshun Plant contamination, and how the farming ban, the stigma on local catches and the setting of the compensation reference values came about (printed pp. 125–128).
Points to watch when using it
- Chapter 1 of the main text swaps the mean blood dioxin levels of Xiangong and Luer villages: the text says Xiangong, Luer, Sicao and Yantian were "87.8, 77.6, 41.1 and 52.9 respectively," but Table 1-1-2 gives Luer Village 87.8 (31 people) and Xiangong Village 77.6 (45 people) (printed pp. 1, 184). Citations follow the table.
- The main text says "14.0% of residents had blood dioxin below 64," but Table 4-6-2 gives a cumulative 85.97% below 64, so 14.0% must be the share at 64 pg or above (printed pp. 93, 245). Citations follow the table.
- The quantity of sodium pentachlorophenolate left behind: this dissertation says "nearly 5,000 kg," while Lin Wu-ting's (林霧霆) 2004 master's thesis from the same research group says "about 5,000 tons"; the question is unverified.
- The postscript is the author's personal testimony and reflection, and this site marks it as the author's own account when citing it.
- The Fisheries Agency survey for ROC year 90 was classified as not public; the dissertation reports its figures at second hand, and the original cannot be verified.
- Personal data: this site cites only the statistics and group-level accounts in the dissertation.
About the author
- Chang Jung-wei (張榮偉): the author of this dissertation, later an associate professor at the Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University (see the person entry). The acknowledgments record that he began his first sampling at the newly opened health room in Xiangong Village and stayed at NCKU after graduating to continue the CPDC projects (PDF pp. 11–12).
- Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋): the supervisor, director of the NCKU Research Center for Environmental Trace Toxic Substances.
- Teachers and helpers named in the acknowledgments (PDF pp. 11–12):
- Teachers: Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋), Su Huey-jen (蘇慧貞), Chen Hsiu-ling (陳秀玲), Pai Ming-chyi (白明奇, physician), Guo How-ran (郭浩然), Wu Cheng-lung (吳政龍, physician), Wang Ying-jan (王應然), Ou Hung-yi (歐弘毅, physician) and Liao Pao-chi (廖寶琦).
- Hu Shu-chen (胡淑貞), director of the Tainan City Public Health Bureau, secretary Wang Min-hua (王敏華) and technician Wu Yu-hsiang (吳玉香); Lo Miao-ling (羅妙玲) of the Tainan City Government Social Affairs Bureau.
- The "CPDC Health Care Medical Expert Advisory Committee" (中石化健康照護醫療專家諮詢委員會); the village chiefs of Xiangong, Luer and Sicao, the local self-help association and former Taiwan Alkali employees (unnamed).
Cited on this site
- Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant, Anshun Plant seawater reservoir, Luermen River and Zhufagang.
- Dioxin, Methylmercury and Pentachlorophenol.
- Mazugong Village, Luer Village, Sicao Village, Health room attached to the Annan District Health Center, Chengxi Landfill and Incinerator and 64-picogram high-concentration standard.
- Chang Jung-wei and Ching-Chang Lee.
2. Authors
3. Copyright status
- Category: Protected by copyright
- Rights holder: Chang Jung-wei (張榮偉) (author of the dissertation)
- How this site uses it: Summarized with short quotations and page numbers cited.
- Basis: A degree thesis is the author's work; the author is living or the work is still within the term of protection.
4. Where to find it
5. Pages on this site citing this work
- 64-picogram high-concentration standardTermsp. 93、126、245
- Annan District Affiliated Health RoomInstitutions and Schoolsp. 52、實頁 11
- Anshun Plant Seawater ReservoirPlacesp. 3–5、187–188、78、206
- Chang Jung-weiPeoplep. 誌謝 1–2、72、126–127
- Chengxi Landfill and IncineratorInstitutions and Schoolsp. 1、73、125
- Ching-Chang LeePeoplep. 封面、誌謝 1
- DioxinTermsp. 23、34–38、114、93–95、109–110、125
- Guo How-ranPeoplep. 實頁 11–12
- History of the Taijian Anshun PlantTermsp. 1–3、125–127、72–95、119–121
- Huang Huan-changPeoplep. 3
- Luer VillagePlacesp. 1、184、2、52–53、226
- Luermen RiverPlacesp. 2–4、125
- Mazugong VillagePlacesp. 1、184、2、52–53、226
- MethylmercuryTermsp. 2、3、105、109、6、35–38、3–4、84–87、119–121
- PentachlorophenolTermsp. I、1–3、125
- Sicao VillagePlacesp. 1、184、2、52–53、226
- Su Huey-jen (蘇慧貞)People
- Taiwan Alkali Anshun PlantInstitutions and Schoolsp. 1–3
- ZhufagangPlacesp. I、78、126
6. People recorded in this work
- Guo How-ranp. 實頁 11–12
- Huang Huan-changp. 3
- Ching-Chang Leep. 封面、誌謝 1
- Su Huey-jen (蘇慧貞)
- Chang Jung-weip. 誌謝 1–2、72、126–127