Theses

The bioavailability of mercury in the aquatic organisms and mercury exposure of residents living in contaminated area (汞污染水域水生物之生物可利用性與其附近居民之汞暴露相關性研究)

Protected by copyrightCited 21 times

Master's thesis of October 2005, supervised by Ching-Chang Lee; the scanned PDF has 199 pages. From July to October 2003 the author collected 9 sediment samples, 58 fish and crab muscle samples and 20 fish viscera samples from the seawater reservoir of the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant, measured total mercury and calculated bioavailability factors; in 2004 he collected blood from 494 residents of Xiangong, Luer, Sicao, Yantian and other villages to measure total mercury, and compared the results with questionnaires and health examinations.

1. Bibliographic details

Title
《The bioavailability of mercury in the aquatic organisms and mercury exposure of residents living in contaminated area (汞污染水域水生物之生物可利用性與其附近居民之汞暴露相關性研究)》
English title
The bioavailability of mercury in the aquatic organisms and mercury exposure of residents living in contaminated area
Also known as
《汞污染水域水生物之生物可利用性與其附近居民之汞暴露相關性研究》、《The Bioavailability of Mercury in the Aquatic Organisms and Mercury Exposure of Residents Living in Contaminated Area》
Authors
Chuang Tsung-yu (莊宗育) author;Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋) chief compiler
Publisher
國立成功大學環境醫學研究所 [Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health, National Cheng Kung University](碩士論文 [master's thesis])
Year
2005

Chuang Tsung-yu's (莊宗育) master's thesis of October 2005, Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health, National Cheng Kung University (國立成功大學環境醫學研究所), supervised by Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋). Its subjects are the seawater reservoir of the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant (台鹼安順廠) and the residents nearby: it measures total mercury in the sediment, fish and crabs of the reservoir, estimates the proportion of mercury passing from the sediment into aquatic organisms, and then compares this with residents' blood total mercury, seafood consumption and health examinations.

Bibliographic details

  1. Title: 《汞污染水域水生物之生物可利用性與其附近居民之汞暴露相關性研究》.
  2. English title: The bioavailability of mercury in the aquatic organisms and mercury exposure of residents living in contaminated area.
  3. Graduate student: Chuang Tsung-yu (莊宗育; English name in the NCKU theses system: Chuang, Tsung-Yu); supervisor: Ching-Chang Lee.
  4. Institution: Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health, National Cheng Kung University; master's thesis.
  5. Date: the cover reads 「中華民國九十四年十月」 ("October, ROC year 94"); the approval sheet is dated October 8, ROC year 94; the acknowledgments are signed 「宗育 2005 年 10 月 10 日 于成大」 ("Tsung-yu, October 10, 2005, at NCKU") (actual pp. 2–3).
  6. Thesis examination committee (handwritten signatures on the approval sheet, actual p. 2): Shen Yi-fu (沈一夫), Ching-Chang Lee, Guo How-ran (郭浩然) and Su Huey-jen (蘇慧貞); head of the institute: Su Huey-jen.
  7. Length: the scanned PDF has 199 pages and no text layer; the main text runs to printed p. 79, the references begin at printed p. 80, the figures at printed p. 103, the tables at printed p. 119, and the attachments (consent form, questionnaire) at printed p. 188.
  8. Keywords: seawater reservoir, total mercury, bioavailability, total seafood consumption, health examination.

Note on page numbers

  1. Citations give the thesis's printed page numbers (Arabic numerals at the foot of the page). Actual page = printed page + 12 (actual p. 13 = printed p. 1; table on actual p. 170 = printed p. 158).
  2. The cover, approval sheet, acknowledgments, abstract and table of contents use Roman numerals; when cited, the actual page is given.

Chapters

  1. Chapter 1, Introduction (printed pp. 1–3): history of the Anshun Plant, the mercury-cell process, the fate of the mercury sludge, previous surveys.
  2. Chapter 2, Literature Review (printed pp. 4–35): the transformation of mercury in the environment, bioavailability, exposure pathways, toxicity to the various organs, mercury concentrations in sediments and aquatic organisms in various countries, studies of human exposure.
  3. Chapter 3, Research Design and Methods (printed pp. 36–49): sampling strategy, pretreatment, total mercury analysis, quality assurance and quality control, sediment organic matter, calculation of bioavailability, questionnaire, blood and urine biochemistry, statistics.
  4. Chapter 4, Results and Discussion (printed pp. 50–76): analysis of the sediment, aquatic organisms, bioavailability factors, residents' basic data, blood total mercury and the various data.
  5. Chapter 5, Conclusions and Recommendations (printed pp. 77–79); references; figures; tables; attachments.

Scope and methods

  1. Site: the seawater reservoir of the CPDC Anshun Plant (中石化安順廠; formerly the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant), which is connected through a sluice gate to the Luermen River (鹿耳門溪). The location maps mark the chlor-alkali plant, the pentachlorophenol plant soil storage area, the pentachlorophenol sludge dumping site, the pumping station and the 13th Public Cemetery beside the reservoir (printed pp. 36–38, Figs. 3-2-1 to 3-2-3, actual pp. 119–121).
  2. Sediment: all collected in a single day, July 31, 2003, from a bamboo raft positioned by satellite. The reservoir was divided into nine zones, A to I, and one surface sediment sample (0–15 cm) was taken in each, 9 samples in all; the mean water depth was 1.03 m (0.57–1.36), the mean water content 33.9%, and the mean organic matter 1.42% (printed pp. 36–37, 50; Table 4-1-1, printed p. 146).
  3. Aquatic organisms: from July 31 to October 9, 2003, in step with the schedule of the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau's (臺南市環保局) harvesting of the reservoir's aquatic organisms, and with the help of graduate students of the NCKU Institute of Life Sciences and Bureau staff, they were caught with cast nets, set nets and crab pots; the nine zones were combined into three large zones, A, B and C (printed pp. 37–38).
    1. Four fish species: tilapia (吳郭魚, Oreochromis mossambicus), milkfish (虱目魚, Chanos chanos), largescale mullet (大鱗鯔, Liza macrolepis, commonly called 豆仔魚 or 烏魚), and Western Pacific gizzard shad (環球海鰶, Nematalosa come, commonly called 扁屏仔 or 土黃仔).
    2. Two crab species: the red-legged mud crab (紅腳蟳; scientific name in the thesis Scylla serrata, commonly called 紅蟳) and the blue swimming crab (遠海梭子蟹, Portunus pelagicus, commonly called 花蟳 or 花蟹).
    3. Sample numbers follow Table 3-2-1: 58 muscle samples (52 fish, 6 crab) and 20 viscera samples (printed p. 51; Table 3-2-1, printed p. 136). Most samples were homogenized composites of the muscle of 2 to 9 fish from the same zone.
  4. Residents' blood: in cooperation with the Tainan City Public Health Bureau (臺南市衛生局), blood was collected at the adult health examinations for those aged 40 and over held by the Annan District Health Station (安南區衛生所) in the four villages of Luer, Xiangong, Sicao and Yantian (May 23, June 27, August 12, September 19 and November 7, 2004), and in sampling by the NCKU Research Center for Environmental Trace Toxic Substances (成大環境微量毒物研究中心) on May 28 and 29, 2004 (including residents of nine other villages), 494 people in all; all signed consent forms (printed p. 39).
  5. Analysis: thermal decomposition / gold amalgamation / cold-vapor atomic absorption spectrometry (MA-2000 total mercury analyzer, Nippon Instruments Corporation, Japan), measuring total mercury in blood, fish, crabs and sediment; the method detection limit was 0.09 ppb; accuracy was verified with NIST SRM 966 for blood and RTC CRM 016-050 for sediment (printed pp. 42, 45–46, 52).
  6. Questionnaires and health examinations: the Public Health Bureau's visit questionnaire (including whether the respondent had eaten fish from the reservoir and whether he or she had worked at the Anshun Plant for three months or more) and the dietary questionnaire of the NCKU Research Center for Environmental Trace Toxic Substances (137 people with detailed seafood consumption); blood and urine from the health examinations were tested by Tainan Municipal Hospital (臺南市立醫院) and the Department of Pathology of National Cheng Kung University Hospital (成大醫院), and with the Public Health Bureau's consent were made available for analysis in the thesis (printed pp. 47–48).
  7. Biota–sediment accumulation factor (BSAF) = total mercury in the organism (dry weight) ÷ total mercury in the sediment (dry weight) (printed pp. 47, 63).

Main conclusions

  1. Mean total mercury in the sediment was 25.5±23.6 mg/kg dry weight (2.9–73.9); 4 of the 9 points (44.4%) exceeded the soil control standard of 20 mg/kg. The highest was zone C, near the former wastewater outfall of the chlor-alkali plant (printed pp. 53, 77; Table 4-3-1, printed p. 158).
  2. Mean total mercury in fish muscle was 0.235 ppm wet weight, in the order tilapia > milkfish > Western Pacific gizzard shad > largescale mullet; crabs were significantly higher than fish. Of the 58 muscle samples only 1, a red-legged mud crab, exceeded 0.5 ppm, while 6 of the 7 liver samples did (printed pp. 60–61, 77).
  3. Compared with the 1985 survey of the reservoir by Lu Shih-tsung (呂世宗) and others (mean for tilapia 1.398 ppm), mercury in fish had fallen considerably, but the sediment remained high (printed p. 62).
  4. BSAF ranged from 0.018 to 0.084, far below the 1.4–45.7 reported in foreign literature. The thesis infers that the reservoir water is shallow (about 1 m) and therefore relatively oxic, saline and oligotrophic; that the plant's past treatment of mercury-bearing wastewater with sulfides may have turned the mercury into mercury sulfide, which is not easily methylated; and that the fish in the reservoir have short life cycles. However, the thesis did not measure these environmental factors, nor did it measure methylmercury (printed pp. 63–67, 77).
  5. Mean blood total mercury of the 494 residents was 15.4±10.3 µg/L; 107 people (21.7%) were above the 20 µg/L of the general population; there was no significant difference among villages (printed pp. 70–71; Table 4-7-4, printed p. 175).
  6. Blood mercury was significantly associated with total seafood consumption and with being male; whether a person had eaten fish from the reservoir was not significantly associated with blood mercury (printed pp. 73–74, 78).
  7. The high-blood-mercury group had higher mean creatinine and blood urea nitrogen, and also higher red blood cell counts and hemoglobin; urine tests showed no significant differences; the thesis holds that more data are needed to determine whether mercury exposure damages the kidneys (printed pp. 75–76, 78).
  8. Recommendations: although the muscle of the fish and crabs in the reservoir meets the standards, the viscera mostly exceed them, so viscera should be eaten sparingly. Citing a 2003 study commissioned by the Bureau of Health Promotion (國民健康局) which found dioxins in the reservoir's aquatic organisms above EU standards, it recommends that the public avoid eating aquatic organisms from the reservoir (printed p. 79).

Cautions for use

  1. Year: the cover and approval sheet are dated October 2005 (ROC year 94); the NCKU theses system records academic year 94, publication year 2006 and 187 pages. This site refers to it by the cover year, 2005.
  2. Only total mercury was measured, not methylmercury; when comparing with the "methylmercury 0.5 ppm" standard, the thesis conservatively assumes that all mercury in the aquatic organisms is methylmercury (printed p. 60).
  3. The sediment and aquatic organisms come from the same sampling as Lin Wu-ting's 2004 thesis (July to October 2003, the same reservoir, sediment from the nine zones, the same four fish species and crabs); one thesis measured mercury, the other dioxins.
  4. Where the main text and the tables disagree, this site follows the tables:
    1. Numbers of residents by village: the main text on printed p. 67 says 「鹿耳(佔 27.5%)、顯宮(佔 13.2%)」 ("Luer (27.5%), Xiangong (13.2%)"), while Table 4-6-1 (printed p. 168) and Table 4-7-4 (printed p. 175) give Xiangong 136 people (27.5%) and Luer 65 people (13.2%); the main text has them reversed.
    2. Aquatic organism sample numbers: printed p. 38 says 60 fish samples, 66 muscle samples, 91 in total; Table 3-2-1, printed p. 51 and the conclusions give 58 muscle samples and 20 viscera samples.
    3. Largescale mullet muscle: the main text on printed p. 56 says 「53.5 ± 133.6」, while Table 4-4-8 (printed p. 166) gives 133.6±53.5 ng/g wet weight.
    4. Creatinine: the main text on printed p. 75 gives the high-concentration group as 「12.3±0.3 mg/dL」, while Table 4-7-13 (printed p. 184) gives 1.2±0.3; for the rate of abnormal blood urea nitrogen, the main text gives 35.0% versus 18.7%, the table 35.0% versus 28.7%.
  5. Disagreements between the abstract and the main text:
    1. Age: the abstract says blood mercury was significantly positively correlated with age (p = 0.0172); in the main text the simple regression shows no correlation (p = 0.5140, Table 4-7-1), and age is also not significant in the multivariate model (p = 0.5844, Table 4-7-11); only in the group comparison is the high-concentration group older (p = 0.0145, Table 4-7-5).
    2. Seafood consumption: the abstract gives p = 0.0505; Table 4-7-8 gives p = 0.0184 for the simple regression, and Table 4-7-12 gives p = 0.0400 for the multivariate model.
    3. Red blood cells and hemoglobin: the Chinese abstract says the high-concentration group was 「略高」 ("slightly higher"), while the English abstract says lower; Table 4-7-13 shows the high-concentration group significantly higher (p = 0.0126, 0.0077), but the rate of abnormal hemoglobin was actually lower in the high-concentration group (19.0% versus 31.0%).
    4. Grouping threshold: the abstract and printed p. 72 group by the 75th percentile, 19.1 µg/L; point 8 of the conclusions says the grouping was at 20 µg/L.
  6. Bioavailability factor: printed p. 64 says the maximum in this study was 0.039, but the same section lists 0.084 for the red crab and 0.072 for the flower crab; 0.039 is the maximum for fish (tilapia).
  7. The latitude of sediment point G is given as N 23.01.03.4, which is out of sequence with the other 8 points (23.01.5x to 23.02.0x) and is probably a slip of the pen (Table 4-1-1).
  8. The introduction says the Anshun Plant was established in ROC year 30 (1941) and closed in ROC year 71 (1982) (printed p. 1); for the years given in other sources, see Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant.
  9. Point 1 of the conclusions gives the sediment of the Amazon basin as 「0.02-1.85 ng/g」, whereas the main text gives 22.7–1850 ng/g (i.e., 0.02–1.85 mg/kg); the unit in the conclusions is a misprint.
  10. Limitations stated by the thesis itself: aquatic organisms were sampled in only one season; sample numbers for some fish species and the crabs were small; the environmental parameters of the reservoir and methylmercury were not measured; the resident study was cross-sectional and recruited through adult health examinations, so the population was mainly middle-aged and elderly (mean age 57.3); and the number of respondents differed from question to question (printed pp. 38, 57, 67–68, 79).
  11. Residents' data: this site cites only group statistics and does not concern any individual.

About the authors

  1. Chuang Tsung-yu: author of this thesis, with a master's degree from the NCKU Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health; the acknowledgments mention completing his studies in "distant southern Taiwan" (遙遠的南台灣). Other career details: to be added.
  2. Supervisor: Ching-Chang Lee.
  3. Thesis examination committee: Shen Yi-fu (the acknowledgments call him 「環保署土基會沈一夫副執秘」, "Deputy Executive Secretary Shen Yi-fu of the Soil and Groundwater Pollution Remediation Fund Management Board, Environmental Protection Administration"), Guo How-ran and Su Huey-jen (also head of the institute).
  4. The acknowledgments also list two teachers, Guo Yue-liang (郭育良) and Chang Huo-yen (張火炎), among the "thesis advisers and oral examiners" (論文指導與口試委員); laboratory teachers and classmates are named by given name only and are not listed here.

Citations on this site

  1. Anshun Plant Seawater Reservoir, Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant and Methylmercury.
  2. Villages: Mazugong Village (顯宮里), Luer Village, Sicao Village and Yantian Village (塩田里; written 鹽田里 in the thesis).
  3. Species: Mozambique tilapia (called 吳郭魚, tilapia, in the thesis), Milkfish, Largescale mullet (大鱗龜鮻; called 大鱗鯔 in the thesis), Western Pacific gizzard shad, Orange mud crab (欖綠青蟳) and Blue swimming crab.
  4. People: Chuang Tsung-yu, Ching-Chang Lee, Shen Yi-fu, Guo How-ran and Su Huey-jen.

2. Authors

  • Chuang Tsung-yu (莊宗育)authorChuang Tsung-yu holds a master's degree from the Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health, National Cheng Kung University; his 2005 master's thesis measured total mercury in the sediment, fish and crabs of the seawater reservoir of the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant and in the blood of 494 nearby residents.
  • Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋)chief compilerChing-Chang Lee is a professor at the Institute of Environmental Medicine, National Cheng Kung University, and director of the NCKU Research Center for Environmental Trace Toxic Substances; from 2006 to 2010 Lee led the Tainan City Government-commissioned survey of blood dioxin exposure and health effects among residents of the Anshun Plant pollution zone.

3. Copyright status

  1. Category: Protected by copyright
  2. Rights holder: Chuang Tsung-yu (莊宗育) (author of the thesis)
  3. How this site uses it: Summarized with short quotations and page numbers cited.
  4. Basis: A degree thesis is the author's work; the author is living or the work is still within the term of protection.

Citation and copyright

4. Where to find it

  1. 國立成功大學博碩士論文系統(2007-10-12 起電子全文公開)[NCKU Theses and Dissertations System (electronic full text public since 2007-10-12)]
  2. 臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 [National Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations in Taiwan]

5. Pages on this site citing this work

  1. Anshun Plant Seawater ReservoirPlacesp. 1、36–38、50–67、77–79、146、158–166
  2. Blue swimming crab (Portunus pelagicus)Speciesp. 37–38、50–64、159、164–166
  3. Ching-Chang LeePeoplep. 實頁 1–3
  4. Chuang Tsung-yuPeoplep. 實頁 1–3、36–39、77–79
  5. Guo How-ranPeoplep. 實頁 1–3
  6. History of the Taijian Anshun PlantTermsp. 1–2、36–39、53–79、158、166、175、181、184
  7. Largescale mullet (Planiliza macrolepis)Speciesp. 37–38、50–64、159、164–166
  8. Luer VillagePlacesp. 39、67–78、168、175–176
  9. Mazugong VillagePlacesp. 39、67–78、168、175–176
  10. MethylmercuryTermsp. 53、59–67、70–79、158、166、175、181、183
  11. MilkfishSpeciesp. 37–38、50–64、159、164–166
  12. Mozambique tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus)Speciesp. 37–38、50–64、159、164–166
  13. Orange mud crab (Scylla olivacea)Speciesp. 37–38、50–64、159、164–166
  14. Shen Yi-fuPeoplep. 實頁 1–3
  15. Sicao VillagePlacesp. 39、67–78、168、175–176
  16. Su Huey-jen (蘇慧貞)Peoplep. 實頁 2–3
  17. Taiwan Alkali Anshun PlantInstitutions and Schoolsp. 1–2、36–39、53–79、158、166、175、181、184
  18. Tilapia (Oreochromis)Speciesp. 37–38、50–64、159、164–166
  19. Western Pacific gizzard shad (Nematalosa come)Speciesp. 37–38、50–64、159、164–166
  20. Yantian VillagePlacesp. 39、67–78、168、175–176

6. People recorded in this work

  1. Guo How-ranp. 實頁 1–3
  2. Ching-Chang Leep. 實頁 1–3
  3. Shen Yi-fup. 實頁 1–3
  4. Su Huey-jen (蘇慧貞)p. 實頁 2–3
  5. Chuang Tsung-yup. 實頁 1–3、36–39、77–79

← Bibliography