Theses

Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)

Protected by copyrightCited 47 times

A master's thesis completed by Chang Yu-hsin (張玉欣) in August 2009 at the Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University, supervised by Yang Yung-nien (楊永年). Taking as its case the "NT$1.3 billion over 5 years" compensation scheme for the CPDC Anshun Plant approved by the Executive Yuan in 2005, it measures the results in terms of "policy identification" and "social justice" across the three stages of policy formation, planning and implementation; it interviews officials, scholars, environmentalists, village chiefs, cadres of the self-help association and residents of the three villages of Xiangong, Luer and Sicao, and compiles a history of the Anshun Plant and a chronology of the discovery of the pollution.

1. Bibliographic details

Title
《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》
English title
Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case
Also known as
《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》、《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case》、《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case》、《A Study of the Compensation Policy for the CPDC Anshun Plant》
Authors
Chang Yu-hsin (張玉欣) author;Yang Yung-nien (楊永年) chief compiler
Publisher
國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所 [Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University](碩士論文 [master's thesis])
Year
2009

Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》) is a master's thesis completed by Chang Yu-hsin (張玉欣) in August 2009 at the Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University (國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所), supervised by Yang Yung-nien (楊永年), with Liao Chao-ning (廖肇寧), Wang Ching-hui (王慶輝) and Tsai Yun-tung (蔡允棟) on the oral examination committee. Taking the CPDC Anshun Plant Compensation and Care Program as its case, the thesis measures the results of the compensation policy in terms of 「政策認同」 ("policy identification") and 「社會正義」 ("social justice") across the three stages of policy formation, planning and implementation R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62. Scholarly view Page numbers always refer to the printed page numbers of the thesis.

Research methods and materials

  1. In-depth interviews: interviewees are identified by code and include officials of the central government and the Tainan City Government, scholars, environmentalists, filmmakers, village chiefs, cadres of the self-help association and high-concentration cases (Table 3-1) R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62.
  2. Documents: newspapers, Control Yuan corrective measures, materials of the Tainan City Government and its Social Affairs Bureau (社會處), and earlier studies by Yang Yung-nien and others R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62.

Chapter summary

  1. Chapter 1, Introduction (pp. 1–17): research background and motivation, definitions of terms, a brief history of the pollution of the CPDC Anshun Plant (Table 1-1).
  2. Chapter 2, Literature review (pp. 18–36): theories and analytical framework of policy formation, planning and implementation.
  3. Chapter 3, Research design (pp. 37–45): research methods, interviewees, design of the questions and limitations of the research.
  4. Chapter 4, Research findings and analysis (pp. 46–91): policy formation (frequency of media reports; Table 4-1 of the factors of the various parties), policy planning (Table 4-2, the living-care scheme; Table 4-4, sources of funding), and policy implementation.
  5. Chapter 5, Conclusions and recommendations (pp. 92–98); references (from p. 99).

Key points concerning the Anshun Plant and Annan District

  1. Definition of the scheme: on July 11, 2005, the Environmental Protection Administration convened an inter-ministerial task force meeting that approved the scheme proposed by the Tainan City Government, 「基於『人道關懷』所提供為期 5 年共計 13 億元之補償金」 ("compensation totaling NT$1.3 billion over 5 years, provided on the basis of 'humanitarian concern'") to the residents of the three villages of Xiangong, Luer and Sicao (p. 9) R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62. Scholarly view
  2. Division of funding: the Ministry of Economic Affairs over NT$1.25 billion (living care), the Environmental Protection Administration over NT$13 million (pollution control and dredging), and the Council of Agriculture over NT$32 million (purchase of aquatic products from the farming-ban area and compensation) (p. 14) R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62. Scholarly view
  3. Consolation payments and threshold: residents of the three villages received a consolation payment of NT$1,814 a month for 5 years; the advisory meeting of the medical expert group resolved to use 「人體血液戴奧辛濃度達 64 皮克(pg-TEQ/g)」 ("a dioxin concentration in human blood of 64 picograms (pg-TEQ/g)") as the high-concentration standard (pp. 61–62) R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62. Scholarly view
  4. History of the plant: the thesis divides it into four periods; the same thesis gives two dates for the founding of the plant: section 4 of Chapter 1 writes 「日治時期 1942 年所興建之鹼氯工廠」 ("an alkali-chlorine plant built in 1942 under Japanese rule") (p. 7), while section 5 writes 「1938 年日本鐘淵曹達株式會社於台南安順設立『鐘淵曹達廠』」 ("in 1938 Japan's Kanegafuchi Soda Co. (鐘淵曹達株式會社) set up the 'Kanegafuchi Soda Plant' at Anshun, Tainan") (p. 10); in 1977 the sodium pentachlorophenate plant stopped production, and in 1978 the Ministry of Economic Affairs ordered that it no longer be manufactured or imported (p. 11) R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62. Scholarly view
  5. Early knowledge of the pollution: in December 1981 the Water Pollution Control Institute (水污所) found that tilapia in the reservoir contained mercury above the edible standard and sent a letter requesting 「查察禁止捕魚」 ("inspection and a ban on fishing") (p. 11) R001SourceChang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case (中石化安順廠補償政策之研究)》p. I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62. Scholarly view

Author

Chang Yu-hsin (張玉欣) holds a master's degree from the Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University (2009); English name Chang Yu-Hsin; other career details: to be added. Supervisor: Yang Yung-nien.

Cited on this site

  1. Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant, History of the Taijian Anshun Plant
  2. CPDC Anshun Plant Compensation and Care Program, 64-picogram high-concentration standard, Annan District Affiliated Health Room
  3. CPDC Dioxin Pollution Self-Help Association, Tainan City Committee on Health Care and Pollution Prevention for Residents near the CPDC Anshun Plant

2. Authors

  • Chang Yu-hsin (張玉欣)authorChang Yu-hsin holds a master's degree from the Graduate Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University, and is the author of the 2009 master's thesis 《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》 [Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case].
  • Yang Yung-nien (楊永年)chief compilerYang Yung-nien is a professor in the Department of Political Science at National Cheng Kung University who has studied the compensation, community development and dredging policies of the CPDC Anshun Plant, and supervised Chang Yu-hsin's 2009 master's thesis on the Anshun compensation policy.

3. Copyright status

  1. Category: Protected by copyright
  2. Rights holder: Chang Yu-hsin (張玉欣) (author of the thesis)
  3. How this site uses it: Summarized with short quotations and page numbers cited.
  4. Basis: A degree thesis is the author's work; the author is living or the work is still within the term of protection.

Citation and copyright

4. Where to find it

  1. 臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 [National Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations in Taiwan](電子全文 [electronic full text])

5. Pages on this site citing this work

  1. 64-picogram high-concentration standardTermsp. 62、65、71–77、13、47–48
  2. Annan District Affiliated Health RoomInstitutions and Schoolsp. 63、70、79、I、89–90
  3. Chan Po-wangPeoplep. 56、102
  4. Chang Yu-hsinPeoplep. 封面、I、43、III
  5. Chen Ying-tzuPeoplep. 13、102
  6. Cheng Yu-jungPeoplep. 55、102
  7. Chu Shu-chuan (朱淑娟)Peoplep. 8、55、102
  8. CPDC Anshun Plant Compensation and Care ProgramEventsp. 9、14、59–62、65、63–64、67、4、52–58、69–70、79、82–83、97
  9. CPDC Dioxin Pollution Self-Help Association (中石化戴奧辛污染自救會)Institutions and Schoolsp. I、42、88–90、48–49、53、72–73、83–84、86
  10. Hau Lung-pinPeoplep. 47
  11. History of the Taijian Anshun PlantTermsp. 7、9–14、61–62
  12. Lin Wei-minPeoplep. 102
  13. Ling Pei-chunPeoplep. 102
  14. Lu Li-tePeoplep. 102
  15. Shih Yi-chinPeoplep. 56、102
  16. Steve Chen (Chen Ruey-long)Peoplep. 55、56
  17. Sung Te-kaoPeoplep. 13、16
  18. Tainan City Committee on Health Care and Pollution Prevention for Residents near the CPDC Anshun PlantInstitutions and Schoolsp. 63–64
  19. Tainan Community CollegeInstitutions and Schoolsp. 51、41、46–47、14、75、89
  20. Ting Wan-ming (丁萬鳴)Peoplep. 55、102
  21. Tsuey-Ping Lee (李翠萍)Peoplep. 19–20、70、100、104
  22. Wu Yu-hsiangPeoplep. 85、88
  23. Yang Yung-nienPeoplep. 封面、56–57、101、105

6. People recorded in this work

  1. Steve Chen (Chen Ruey-long)p. 55、56
  2. Chen Ying-tzup. 13、102
  3. Ting Wan-ming (丁萬鳴)p. 55、102
  4. Hau Lung-pinp. 47
  5. Tsuey-Ping Lee (李翠萍)p. 19–20、70、100、104
  6. Lin Wei-minp. 102
  7. Ling Pei-chunp. 102
  8. Lu Li-tep. 102
  9. Shih Yi-chinp. 56、102
  10. Sung Te-kaop. 13、16
  11. Wu Yu-hsiangp. 85、88
  12. Yang Yung-nienp. 封面、56–57、101、105
  13. Chan Po-wangp. 56、102
  14. Chang Yu-hsinp. 封面、I、43、III
  15. Cheng Yu-jungp. 55、102
  16. Chu Shu-chuan (朱淑娟)p. 8、55、102

7. Sources for the bibliographic details

  1. R001Chang Yu-hsin (張玉欣),《中石化安順廠補償政策之研究》[Compensation Policy Research of An-Shun Case],國立成功大學政治經濟學研究所碩士論文 [master's thesis, Institute of Political Economy, National Cheng Kung University],2009,頁 I、IV–VI、7、9–11、14、61–62 [pp. I, IV–VI, 7, 9–11, 14, 61–62]Retrieved 2026-11-20

← Bibliography