Dispute over the Fish Ponds on the Zengwen River Estuary Riverland

Secondhand account
300

Verification status of the entries on this page

  • Verified
  • Partially verified
  • Not covered by sources
  • Verified: the source was found and checked
  • Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records
Category
Events
Area
Qigu
Also known as
七股河川新生地魚塭拆除、曾文溪口河川地開發糾紛、曾文溪口河川地魚塭糾紛、Demolition of the fish ponds on the Qigu river accretion land、Zengwen estuary riverland development dispute

Guided reading

The dispute over the fish ponds on the Zengwen River estuary riverland was a conflict in the 1980s between the Tainan County Government, which demolished fish ponds on the riverland at the mouth of the Zengwen River in Qigu with a view to turning it into an industrial zone, and the local fish farmers. The Qigu Comprehensive Development Plan was shelved for a time because of the backlash, and the conflict later carried over into the anti-Seventh Naphtha Cracker movement of the 1990s.R001SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 77–79Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)

Evidence mix
Verification
  • ✓ Verified 3
  • ◑ Partially verified 0
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources 0
✓ ◑ ⊗
  • ✓ Verified: the source was found and checked
  • ◑ Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.

In 1974 the riverland at the mouth of the Zengwen River was reserved for development by CPC Corporation and Taiwan Sugar Corporation, but they abandoned it because of cost and geology; in 1978 Provincial Assemblyman Hsieh Kun-shan proposed relaxing the rules so that fishermen could reclaim it [R001]. Residents had already dug fish ponds on the riverland before the September 3 flood of 1981; in 1986 County Councilor Fang Lung-sheng proposed clearing the "illegally reclaimed fish ponds," and the county government demolished the ponds, intending to develop an industrial zone in cooperation with Formosa Plastics and the Tuntex Group [R002]. In 1987 fishermen of Shifen Village led by Tsai Fu petitioned for a specialized aquaculture zone, and Yang Fu-ming and others of Yihe Village opposed the industrial port, amusement area, and industrial zone of the Qigu Comprehensive Development Plan. The fish ponds were demolished in the end; the plan was shelved for a time and later developed into the anti-Seventh Naphtha Cracker movement [R002].

Relationship map

  • Places
  • Events
Dispute over the Fish Ponds on the Zengwen River Estuary Riverland

Background

4 items1974–1984First items: In 1974 the riverland at the mouth of th…In 1978 Provincial Assemblyman Hsieh Kun…In 1984 County Councilor Hsieh Yin-hang …MoreLess

According to Wang Hsiang-min's (王詳閔) 2023 master's thesis R001SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 77–79Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 77–79:

  1. In 1974 the riverland at the mouth of the Zengwen River was reserved for CPC Corporation (中油公司) and Taiwan Sugar Corporation (台糖公司) to develop resources and energy, but after assessment they gave it up because 「開發經費龐大,且位於地震帶,土質鬆軟,不適設廠與處理油氣而放棄」 ("development costs were enormous, and it lies in an earthquake zone with soft soil, unsuitable for building plants or handling oil and gas").
  2. In 1978 Provincial Assemblyman Hsieh Kun-shan (謝崑山) pointed out that of the 400 hectares of riverland, only 150 hectares were being used by the thousand or so local fishermen, and proposed relaxing the rules on applications for reclamation; the Provincial Assembly considered that the land should not be reclaimed at will and referred the matter to the Water Conservancy Bureau for planning.
  3. In 1984 County Councilor Hsieh Yin-hang (謝銀行) and others hoped to sell the shallow sea outside the south embankment, on installment terms and with priority, to the fishermen of Sangu (三股), Yongji (永吉), and Shifen (十份), because the shallow sea outside the south embankment had been entirely enclosed as fish ponds and the fishermen had lost their areas for hanging oyster culture and fishing; the County Council had many doubts, and the proposal was shelved.
  4. In the early 1980s, County Councilor Huang Yen-chen (黃炎禎), a native of Shifen Village, proposed building a freshwater supply station at the mouth of the Zengwen River to supply fresh water to the riverland and to 1,100 hectares of Qigu fish ponds; in 1981–1984 a freshwater supply station had already been set up for more than 200 hectares of fish ponds in Longshan Village (龍山村).

Demolition and petitions

5 items1986–1987First items: In 1986 County Councilor Fang Lung-sheng…Citing council minutes, the thesis point…In 1987 fishermen of Shifen Village led …MoreLess
  1. In 1986 County Councilor Fang Lung-sheng (方隆盛) proposed clearing the illegally reclaimed fish ponds 「河堤外面一千六百公尺」 ("1,600 meters outside the river embankment"), arguing that the damage to the county-owned Qigu fish ponds in the September 3 flood (九三水災) was related to these ponds. The county government carried out the demolition without compensation; the operators closed three sluice gates in protest, and shrimp farmers crowded into the county magistrate's office to petition, where Magistrate Li Ya-chiao (李雅樵) promised to allow time for negotiation R002SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 79–81Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 79–81.
  2. Citing council minutes, the thesis points out that by then the county government already intended to cooperate with Formosa Plastics (台塑) and the Tuntex Group (東帝士集團) to develop the riverland as an industrial zone R002SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 79–81Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 79–81.
  3. In 1987 fishermen of Shifen Village led by Tsai Fu (蔡縛), citing a statement by the council speaker Chou Ching-wen (周清文), petitioned the County Council. The Council's position was that the newly formed riverland should be developed as a specialized aquaculture zone and that it opposed rezoning it as an industrial zone; that demolition was a matter of executive authority and had entered administrative appeal proceedings; and that the existing operators all had legitimate interests R002SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 79–81Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 79–81.
  4. The county government's "Qigu Comprehensive Development Plan" (七股綜合開發計畫) included an industrial port, a comprehensive amusement area, and an industrial zone. Yang Fu-ming (楊福明) and others of Yihe Village (義合村) also petitioned against it, arguing that industry would pollute the aquaculture areas, that the amusement area would bring poor returns, and that the geography was unsuitable for an industrial port. The County Council approved the petition of Yang Fu-ming and the others, but the petition of Tsai Fu and the others was not accepted R002SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 79–81Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 79–81.
  5. Tsai Fu and the others petitioned again, explaining that the fish ponds lay within the floodway outside the new embankment, whereas the county government had determined their status by the line of the old embankment. In the end all the fish ponds were demolished R002SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 79–81Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 79–81.

Aftermath

  1. The Qigu Comprehensive Development Plan was shelved for a time because of public opposition, and later developed into the anti-Seventh Naphtha Cracker (反七輕) movement of the 1990s R002SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 79–81Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 79–81. See Action Alliance Against the Seventh Naphtha Cracker and the Large Steel Mill.
  2. In 1990 Huang Yen-chen pointed out in the County Council that milkfish were overproduced: 「五條虱目魚壹佰元,一台斤值不到二十元,成本就必須虧損十五元左右」 ("five milkfish for a hundred dollars, a catty worth less than twenty dollars, a loss of about fifteen dollars against cost"); in 1991 he moved that rents on the county-owned Qigu fish ponds be suspended R003SourceWang Hsiang-min (王詳閔),《戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代)》[The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980)],國立成功大學歷史學系 [Department of History, National Cheng Kung University] 碩士論文 [master's thesis],2023,pp. 81–82Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《The History and Development of the Local Industry of Milkfish in Taiwan after World War II: A Case Study of the Qigu Area in Tainan (1950–1980) (戰後臺灣虱目魚地方產業的歷史發展與變遷-以臺南七股地區為例(1950–1980 年代))》p. 81–82.

See also

Continue from here