Guided reading
A single development project merged from two conglomerates, two purposes, and one dedicated industrial port: proposed in 1993, passed its EIA in 1999, finalized by notice in 2006, and ended in 2009 through the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act — not because the EIA was overturned.R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.
- Time span
- 1993–200916 years
- Current status
- Ended in 2009 through the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act, so the zone was never built; in 2026 fishponds bought by Yieh United Steel were left idle and breached, turning 50 hectares into a disaster area R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.R002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.R004SourceFollow-up in 2026: Yieh United Steel (燁聯鋼鐵), part of the E-United Group (義联集團) that succeeded Yieh Loong (燁隆), bought fish farm ponds and then left them idle until the embankments breached, turning 50 ha into a disaster zoneOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19No public data have been found on the land parcel numbers, area, date of acquisition, or use..
- Key figures
- 1,732.05 haArea in the final Phase II versionR001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.
- 27, of which 8 bear directly on Taijiang ecologyRequired follow-up itemsR001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.
- under 48 hoursReview panel to full committeeR002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- 1993–2009From proposal to endR002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- Evidence mix
Why it matters
A common claim is that "the EIA stopped Binnan," but the EIA was approved in 1999 and its final version promulgated in 2006; what actually halted the project was the zoning-change procedure in 2009 R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.R002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.. This seventeen-year thread began with the 1992 shooting of black-faced spoonbills; the opposition grew out of temple squares in Qigu and Jiangjun, and what it left behind was the spoonbill reserve and Taijiang National Park R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials..
Main actors
Developers 3
- Yieh Loong GroupSteel cityR003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
- Tuntex GroupSeventh Naphtha CrackerR003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
- Lien Ting SteelEstablished in 1993 for the Binnan steel mill; a wholly owned subsidiary of Chung Hung Steel by 2008; the company that litigated in 2006–2009R008Source中鴻鋼鐵股份有限公司及子公司合併財務報表暨會計師核閱報告 [Consolidated Financial Statements and Accountants' Review Report of Chung Hung Steel Corporation and Subsidiaries], first three quarters of 2008 (ROC year 97) (company history)Original URLhttps://www.chsteel.com.tw/cg/pdf/fin_report_9703c.pdfRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Control Yuan 1
- Ma Yi-kung, Lee Shen-yi, Ku Teng-mei, Chang Te-mingIssued corrective measures twice in 2000R007Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉 [Corrective Measures Proposed by Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan], 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Central government 4
- Industrial Development Bureau, Ministry of Economic AffairsSite inspection 1997-12-08, hearing 12-09R005Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center] (excerpting a Tainan County report by the 中國時報 [China Times]), 〈反七輕人士抗爭鎮暴警察強制驅離 濱南工業區會勘流血衝突〉[Riot Police Forcibly Remove Anti-Naphtha-Cracker Protesters; Bloody Clash at Binnan Industrial Park Site Inspection], 1997-12-09Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/node/79681Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- EPA EIA CommitteeApproved by ad hoc motion on 1999-12-17R002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- Council of Agriculture representativeSaid the reserve was unrelated to the EIAR003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
- Ministry of the InteriorTerminated the zoning-change procedure in 2009R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
Scholars 1
- Scholars on the 1999-12-15 review panelUrged prompt designation of a spoonbill reserveR003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
Opponents 1
- Anti-Binnan briefingsEleven held at temple squares in October 1994R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
Local government 1
- Tainan County GovernmentProclaimed the Zengwen River mouth spoonbill reserve in 2002R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
Aftermath 1
- Yieh United Steel (E-United Group)Idle, breached fishponds in 2026R004SourceFollow-up in 2026: Yieh United Steel (燁聯鋼鐵), part of the E-United Group (義联集團) that succeeded Yieh Loong (燁隆), bought fish farm ponds and then left them idle until the embankments breached, turning 50 ha into a disaster zoneOriginal URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19No public data have been found on the land parcel numbers, area, date of acquisition, or use.
Points of contention
These are the questions people have argued over. Each side's account is set out as stated; this site does not rule on them.
1What actually stopped the Binnan project?4
- Popular account
"The EIA stopped Binnan"; this page points out that this does not match the procedure.R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.
- EIA procedure
Approved by ad hoc motion on 1999-12-17, final version accepted 2004-12-16, promulgated 2006-01-19.R002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- Control Yuan (2000-04-17)
Issued corrective measures against the EPA for not counting holidays toward the review deadline and for using meeting conclusions to exceed the authority delegated by the parent law; the corrective measures did not change the EIA approval.R007Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉 [Corrective Measures Proposed by Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan], 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- Zoning-change procedure
In September 2009 the Ministry of the Interior declared Binnan's zoning-change procedure terminated.R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
- Popular account
2Should a spoonbill reserve be a condition of the EIA?2
- Review panel scholar (1999-12-15)
Urged that a black-faced spoonbill reserve be designated promptly under statutory procedure.R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
- Council of Agriculture representative
Whether a reserve is designated "has nothing to do with the spirit of what the EIA requires of the developer."R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.
- Review panel scholar (1999-12-15)
Turning points
Click a year to jump to it in the full timeline below.
- 1993Yieh Loong and Tuntex propose the projectR002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- 1999-12-17Committee approves the EIA by ad hoc motionR002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- 2000-04-17Control Yuan issues corrective measures against the EPAR007Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉 [Corrective Measures Proposed by Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan], 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 2006-01-19EPA promulgates the final versionR002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- 2009Ended through the zoning-change procedureR002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.
- 2026Yieh United Steel's fishponds left idle and breachedR004SourceFollow-up in 2026: Yieh United Steel (燁聯鋼鐵), part of the E-United Group (義联集團) that succeeded Yieh Loong (燁隆), bought fish farm ponds and then left them idle until the embankments breached, turning 50 ha into a disaster zoneOriginal URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19No public data have been found on the land parcel numbers, area, date of acquisition, or use.
Where to start reading
- EntryBinnan Industrial ParkThe Binnan Industrial Park was an industrial park development project proposed in 1993 for the area of Qigu Lagoon and its sandbars in Tainan County, comprising the seventh naphtha cracker petrochemical complex, a large integrated steel mill and a dedicated industrial port; it passed its environmental impact assessment in 1999, its review conclusions were announced in 2006, and it was terminated in 2009 through the zoning-approval procedure under the Regional Planning Act, never to be built.
- EntryQigu Industrial ParkThe Qigu Industrial Park was a sub-project of the Tainan County Government's Qigu Regional Comprehensive Development Plan of about 1987, planned for the accreted land on the north bank of the Zengwen River estuary and never developed; its 1993 EIA conclusions first recorded the consensus that a black-faced spoonbill reserve must be established, and those conclusions were officially revoked in 2020.
- EntryFounding of Taijiang National ParkThe founding of Taijiang National Park is the process by which Taiwan's eighth national park came into being: after black-faced spoonbills were shot in Qigu in 1992, reserves were designated one after another; Tainan City began advocating a national park in 2001, the Ministry of the Interior proclaimed it on October 15, 2009, and its headquarters was inaugurated on December 28.
- Reports 6.6How the National Park Sees TuchengThis page is not about scenery. It is about how a 394-page statutory plan (the approved edition) describes, classifies, and passes over Tucheng — together with one observation on naming: the authorities recognize "Chengxi" and "Qingcaolun" but not "Tucheng."
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
What it is
The environmental impact assessment (EIA, 環評) was passed in 1999 and finalized by notice in 2006; what actually brought this project to a halt was the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act (區域計畫法) in 2009 R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.R002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.. Official record "The EIA stopped the Binnan case" (「環評擋下濱南案」) is a widely circulated claim, but it does not match the procedure.

Chronology
First items: The original case was revoked at the 22n…The first-stage conclusion required that…On-site inspection by the Industrial Dev…MoreLess
The procedural chain R002SourceChain of EIA review procedures, 1993–2009 (1995-11-28, original case revoked at the 22nd meeting/1996-06-05, first-stage conclusion requiring that 「使用潟湖、沙洲比例降至 30% 以下」 ["the proportion of lagoon and sandbar used be reduced to below 30%"]/1997-12-08, Industrial Development Bureau site inspection, riot police clear protesters; 12-09, hearing/1998-03-19, ten issues won for debate/1999-08-26, scientific conclusion on the lagoon/1999-09-02, procedural turning point/1999-12-15, project panel 28/7/10/1999-12-17, committee passes it by ad hoc motion 27/8/9/2004-12-16, finalized document approved/2006-01-19, notice)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-191999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; they must not be conflated.: Official record
- 1993
- Proposed.
- 1995
11-28The original case was revoked at the 22n…MoreLess
The original case was revoked at the 22nd meeting.
- 1996
- 1997
12-08On-site inspection by the Industrial Dev…MoreLess
On-site inspection by the Industrial Development Bureau (工業局); riot police cleared protesters. 12-09: hearing R005Source環境資訊中心 [Taiwan Environmental Information Center] (excerpting a Tainan County report by the 中國時報 [China Times]), 〈反七輕人士抗爭鎮暴警察強制驅離 濱南工業區會勘流血衝突〉[Riot Police Forcibly Remove Anti-Naphtha-Cracker Protesters; Bloody Clash at Binnan Industrial Park Site Inspection], 1997-12-09Original URLhttps://e-info.org.tw/node/79681Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- 1998
- 03-19Ten issues won for debate.
- 1999
- 08-26Scientific conclusion on the lagoon.
- 09-02Procedural turning point.
- 12-15Project panel, 28/7/10.
12-17The committee passed it by ad hoc motion…MoreLess
The committee passed it by ad hoc motion, 27/8/9.
- 2000
01-07The Control Yuan issued corrective measu…MoreLess
The Control Yuan issued corrective measures against the Industrial Development Bureau of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and the Tainan County Government: the county government had added Point 8 to its operating guidelines for delimiting privately owned coastal land, 「為濱南工業區之開發案解套」 ("to get the Binnan Industrial Park development project off the hook") R006Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈馬以工、李伸一委員提案糾正經濟部工業局及台南縣政府〉 [Corrective Measures Proposed by Members Ma Yi-kung and Lee Shen-yi against the Industrial Development Bureau, Ministry of Economic Affairs, and the Tainan County Government], 2000-01-07Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3584Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record04-17The Control Yuan issued corrective measu…MoreLess
The Control Yuan issued corrective measures against the Environmental Protection Administration: it had not counted holidays toward the review deadline, and had used meeting conclusions to exceed the authority delegated by the parent law R007Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉 [Corrective Measures Proposed by Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan], 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record04-26The EPA convened the review meeting to c…MoreLess
The EPA convened the review meeting to confirm the final version; from then on, the back-and-forth over the final version dragged on for nearly five years R009SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智), 《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》 [The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], 〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉 [The Final EIA Version: Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (transcribing the text of the Control Yuan corrective measures; the review meeting to confirm the final version, 2000-04-26)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side.. Secondhand account
- 2004
- 12-16The finalized document was approved.
- 2006
- 01-19Notice.
- 2009
Ended through the zoning-change procedur…MoreLess
Ended through the zoning-change procedure under the Regional Planning Act.
1999-12-15 and 12-17 are two different meetings with different vote counts; and 12-17 came less than 48 hours after the project panel, during which time the lagoon condition was reversed. The party litigating from 2006 to 2009 was Lien Ting Steel (聯鼎鋼鐵), not Yieh Loong (燁隆). Lien Ting Steel was established in September 1993 to build an integrated steel mill in the Binnan Industrial Park; in the 2008 financial statements it was a wholly owned subsidiary of Chung Hung Steel (中鴻鋼鐵), and operating control of Chung Hung had rested with China Steel (中國鋼鐵) since March 2000 R008Source中鴻鋼鐵股份有限公司及子公司合併財務報表暨會計師核閱報告 [Consolidated Financial Statements and Accountants' Review Report of Chung Hung Steel Corporation and Subsidiaries], first three quarters of 2008 (ROC year 97) (company history)Original URLhttps://www.chsteel.com.tw/cg/pdf/fin_report_9703c.pdfRetrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Neither of the two Control Yuan corrective measures was published until after the EIA had been approved, and neither changed the approval; the review-deadline problem the corrective measures pointed out was later dealt with by the EPA through amendments to the rules R006Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈馬以工、李伸一委員提案糾正經濟部工業局及台南縣政府〉 [Corrective Measures Proposed by Members Ma Yi-kung and Lee Shen-yi against the Industrial Development Bureau, Ministry of Economic Affairs, and the Tainan County Government], 2000-01-07Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3584Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R007Source監察院 [Control Yuan], 〈馬以工、古登美、張德銘委員提案糾正行政院環境保護署〉 [Corrective Measures Proposed by Members Ma Yi-kung, Ku Teng-mei, and Chang Te-ming against the Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan], 2000-04-17Original URLhttps://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=795&s=3623Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—R009SourceHsieh Chih-cheng (謝志誠) and Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智), 《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》 [The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], 〈環評定稿 一波多折2000~2006〉 [The Final EIA Version: Twists and Turns, 2000–2006] (transcribing the text of the Control Yuan corrective measures; the review meeting to confirm the final version, 2000-04-26)Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/?p=441Retrieved2026-10-30Snapshot timestamp—The authors were parties on the opposing side.. Secondhand account

Four sets of area figures
- The 1993 concept stage: Yieh Loong 1,000 hectares, Tuntex (東帝士) 1,500 hectares.
- The 1996 alternatives: 0850201A, 1,873 hectares, and 0850641A, 1,036 hectares — these are two separate documents.
- The finalized second-stage document 0940502A: 1,732.05 hectares R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.. Official record
The 27 required items of the finalized second-stage document
The finalized document lists 27 items the developer must carry out, 8 of which relate directly to the ecology of Taijiang (台江) R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.. Official record They never reached the construction stage and so were never tested.
A seventeen-year thread
MoreLess
At the end of 1992, a group of black-faced spoonbills in Qigu (七股) was shot dead R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.. Secondhand account Half a year later, Yieh Loong proposed a Steel City (鋼鐵城) and Tuntex the seventh naphtha cracker (七輕); in December of the same year, the EIA conclusion for the Qigu Industrial Park (七股工業區) recorded that all parties 「有共識,必須設置保護黑面琵鷺保護區」 ("have reached a consensus that a reserve to protect the black-faced spoonbill must be established") — the first time a black-faced spoonbill reserve appeared in an official document R001Source環境部環境影響評估書件查詢系統 [Ministry of Environment EIA Document Search System], the Binnan Industrial Park case group (the 1996 alternatives 0850201A, 1,873 ha, and 0850641A, 1,036 ha, are two separate documents; the finalized second-stage document 0940502A, 1,732.05 ha)Original URLhttps://eiadoc.moenv.gov.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19The four sets of area figures must not be mixed up; where a single figure is used, the 1,732.05 ha of the finalized second-stage document prevails.R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.. Official record
The opposition grew up in front of temples. In October 1994, eleven anti-Binnan briefings were held, starting at the Daitian Temple (代天府) in Dingshan (頂山), Qigu, and running all the way to the front of the main temple at Mashagou (馬沙溝), Jiangjun (將軍) R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.. Secondhand account Over the following years, masked assailants broke into people's homes, one person was slashed more than twenty times, and beatings and forcible removals occurred again and again at site inspections and hearings R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.. Secondhand account
At the project panel meeting of December 15, 1999, a scholar demanded 「儘速依法定程序劃設黑面琵鷺保護區」 ("that a black-faced spoonbill reserve be designated as soon as possible through the statutory procedure"), while the representative of the Council of Agriculture (農委會) said that whether to designate a reserve 「是否劃設與環評要求開發單位之精神無關」 ("has nothing to do with the spirit of what the EIA requires of the developer") R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.. Secondhand account Two days later the Binnan case passed its EIA; three years later, the Black-faced Spoonbill Reserve (黑面琵鷺保護區) on the north bank of the Zengwen River estuary (曾文溪口) was announced by the Tainan County Government (臺南縣政府) R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.. Secondhand account
In September 2009 the Ministry of the Interior (內政部) announced the end of Binnan's zoning-change procedure; on October 15, Taijiang National Park (台江國家公園) was officially established, and on December 28 the park headquarters' signboard was unveiled. That reserve became an ecological protection area of the national park R003Source《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》[The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], full text (permanent link at jcshieh.tw); Yu Pei-hsuan (余珮瑄), master's thesis, 2009; documentary 《西濱之美》[The Beauty of the West Coast], 1995Original URLhttps://jcshieh.tw/Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19In the original book, the members of the 1999-12-15 project panel are referred to by English initials.. Secondhand account
The year-by-year historical record, the people involved, and the positions of all parties are collected in three entries: the Binnan Industrial Park (濱南工業區), the Qigu Industrial Park, and the Founding of Taijiang National Park (台江國家公園設立).
Follow-up in 2026
Yieh United Steel (燁聯鋼鐵), part of the E-United Group (義联集團) that succeeded Yieh Loong, bought fish farm ponds but left them idle until the embankments breached, and 50 hectares became a disaster zone R004SourceFollow-up in 2026: Yieh United Steel (燁聯鋼鐵), part of the E-United Group (義联集團) that succeeded Yieh Loong (燁隆), bought fish farm ponds and then left them idle until the embankments breached, turning 50 ha into a disaster zoneOriginal URL—Retrieved2026-10-24Snapshot timestamp2026-10-19No public data have been found on the land parcel numbers, area, date of acquisition, or use.. Official record "Buying land without developing it" requires no development permit, and there is no statutory review procedure that can stop it. Unverified Sixteen years of procedure held back an industrial park, but could not stop a piece of land from simply being left as it is.
Video
Videos were uploaded by their respective channels; titles and channel names follow the video pages. This site quotes only short excerpts with timecodes; the videos themselves are authoritative.
Behind this door is the internal site, with profiles of people and local comments. The internal site is deployed separately.