Theses
Benthic Macrofauna in a Dioxin Polluted Reservoir in Tainan (台南市戴奧辛嚴重污染水域之大型底棲無脊椎動物群聚)
A master's thesis of July 2005, supervised by Hou Ping-chun and Ching-Chang Lee; 19 pages of main text, with tables, figures and appendices running to printed p. 51. In July 2003 sediment was sampled at seven plots in the seawater reservoir of the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant, and in October 42 samples were taken to analyze the benthic macroinvertebrates. It records 36 species, at mean densities of 5,554.59 to 18,496.08 individuals per square meter; community composition is most closely correlated with sediment grain size and organic matter content, and in Plot B, where dioxin levels were highest, one amphipod species made up 79%.
1. Bibliographic details
- Title
- 《Benthic Macrofauna in a Dioxin Polluted Reservoir in Tainan (台南市戴奧辛嚴重污染水域之大型底棲無脊椎動物群聚)》
- English title
- Benthic Macrofauna in a Dioxin Polluted Reservoir in Tainan
- Also known as
- 《台南市戴奧辛嚴重污染水域之大型底棲無脊椎動物群聚》、《Benthic Macrofauna in a Dioxin Polluted Reservoir in Tainan》
- Authors
- Chen Hsueh-ju (陳學儒) author;Hou Ping-chun (侯平君) chief compiler;Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋) chief compiler
- Publisher
- 國立成功大學生命科學研究所 [Institute of Life Sciences, National Cheng Kung University](碩士論文 [master's thesis])
- Year
- 2005
Chen Hsueh-ju's (陳學儒) master's thesis of July 2005, Institute of Life Sciences, National Cheng Kung University (國立成功大學生命科學研究所), supervised by Hou Ping-chun (侯平君) and Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋). It studies the benthic macroinvertebrates in the sediment of the seawater reservoir of the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant (台鹼安順廠) and estimates their role in the process by which dioxins enter the food chain.
Bibliographic data
- Title: 《台南市戴奧辛嚴重污染水域之大型底棲無脊椎動物群聚》.
- English title: Benthic Macrofauna in a Dioxin Polluted Reservoir in Tainan.
- Graduate student: Chen Hsueh-ju (陳學儒; Hsueh-Ju Chen); supervisors: Hou Ping-chun (侯平君; Ping-Chun Lucy Hou) and Ching-Chang Lee (李俊璋; given in the thesis as Ching-Chang Lee).
- Institution: Institute of Life Sciences, National Cheng Kung University; master's thesis. The approval sheet bears the seal of Chang Su-chiung (張素瓊), chair of the Department of Life Sciences.
- Date: July, ROC year 94 (2005-07); approval sheet dated 2005-07-22.
- Examination committee: Hou Ping-chun, Ching-Chang Lee and Liang Shih-hsiung (梁世雄) (handwritten signatures on the approval sheet, checked against the acknowledgments: 「梁世雄老師專程從高雄來成大為我口試」, "Professor Liang Shih-hsiung came all the way from Kaohsiung to NCKU for my oral examination").
- Pages: 63 pages in the scanned copy; main text printed pp. 1–19, references printed pp. 20–29, tables printed pp. 30–39, figures printed pp. 40–47, appendices printed pp. 48–51.
- Keywords: benthic macroinvertebrates, dioxins, total organic carbon content, polychaetes, biomagnification, sediment grain size.
Note on page numbers
- This site cites the thesis's printed page numbers. For the main text, actual page = printed page + 11 (actual page 12 = printed page 1); the abstract, acknowledgments and table of contents use Roman numerals.
- Every page of the scanned copy has a software trial-version watermark in the footer, unrelated to the content.
Chapters
- Introduction (printed pp. 1–4): definition of benthic macroinvertebrates (larger than 0.5 mm and living in soft sediments), environmental factors of sediments, history of the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant, and the structure and toxicity of dioxins.
- Materials and methods (printed pp. 5–9): study plots, sampling times and locations, collection of sediments and animals, analysis of environmental factors, statistical methods.
- Results (printed pp. 10–15), Discussion (printed pp. 16–19).
- References, Tables 1–5, Figures 1–8; Appendix 1, coordinates, water temperature and depth of sampling points; Appendix 2, basic data on sediment samples (citing Lin Wu-ting, 2004); Appendix 3, raw concentrations of 17 dioxin congeners in each plot.
Study area and methods
- Study site: the seawater reservoir of the former Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant on the border of Xiangong Village (顯宮里) and Luer Village (鹿耳里) (N 23°02′02.5″, E 120°06′45.6″), adjoining the Luermen River, covering 13.5 ha and connected to the river by a sluice gate. It was formerly used for salt-drying and seawater electrolysis, and also received the plant's wastewater (printed p. 5).
- Sampling: in July 2003, surface sediment (0–15 cm) was collected at seven plots, A, B, C, D, F, G and I, for analysis of environmental factors and dioxins; on October 7–8 of the same year, 6 samples were taken near each plot, 42 in all, for analysis of benthic animals (printed pp. 5, 48).
- Equipment: reaching the points by rubber raft, the researchers collected sediment with a Ponar grab (幫能採泥器; sampling area 152 × 152 mm) following the Environmental Protection Administration's published "Sediment Sampling Method" (NIEA S140.30C), sieved it through a 0.5 mm mesh, anesthetized the animals with 10% alcohol and fixed them with 70% alcohol (printed p. 6).
- Division of labor: dioxins were analyzed by NCKU's Research Center of Environmental Trace Toxic Substances (成大環境微量毒物研究中心) (the data are those of Lin Wu-ting's 2004 thesis); total organic carbon, total nitrogen and grain size were sent to the laboratory of Hsieh Hwey-lian (謝蕙蓮) at Academia Sinica (printed p. 6).
- Statistics: principal component analysis, hierarchical cluster analysis, multidimensional scaling (MDS), analysis of similarities (ANOSIM) and biota–environment correlation analysis (BIOENV), using PRIMER 5 (printed p. 9).
Main results
- Sediment (Table 1, printed p. 30): grain size 0.1093–0.3299 mm, coarsest (medium to coarse sand) in Plot A and finest (very fine sand) in Plot C; silt and clay 0.05–22.28%; total nitrogen 0.04–0.22%; total organic carbon 0.15–1.35%, highest in Plot B. Surface water temperature 30.0–31.9 °C (printed p. 10).
- Dioxins: total concentrations of the 17 congeners in the sediments of the seven plots were, from highest to lowest, B 2,298,348.64, C 444,341.00, I 411,177.28, A 347,769.51, D 252,212.19, G 134,721.39 and F 128,053.24 pg/g (printed pp. 10–11). Dioxin concentration was positively correlated with organic carbon and nitrogen and negatively correlated with grain size; the thesis suggests that dioxins readily adsorb to finer sediment particles (printed p. 16).
- Species: 36 species in all: 13 crustaceans (7 orders, 9 families), 12 polychaetes (4 orders, 4 families), 10 mollusks (6 gastropods, 4 bivalves) and 1 flatworm; from 15 (F) to 22 (B, D) species per plot (printed p. 12; Table 3, printed pp. 32–37).
- Density: mean densities per plot ranged from 5,554.59 individuals per square meter (A) to 18,496.08 (B), with a mean of 10,771.17 across the seven plots (Table 3).
- Dominant species: an amphipod of the family Corophiidae (蜾蠃蜚科; numbered Sp.2 in the thesis) averaged 5,442.27 individuals/m² and made up 79% in Plot B; second was a polychaete of the family Parergodrilidae (Sp.17); third was Stenothyra chilkaensis (車鼓粟螺) at 681.18 individuals/m² (printed pp. 12–13, 16; Table 3).
- Diversity: Shannon-Wiener diversity 0.89 (B) to 1.74 (A); Pielou evenness 0.29 (B) to 0.58 (A) (Table 3, printed p. 37).
- Community and environment: the ordination of benthic animals was most similar to the combination "grain size + total organic carbon + water content" (correlation coefficient 0.692); with only two factors, grain size + total organic carbon scored highest (0.671). The correlation of polychaetes with these two factors (0.712) was far higher than that of mollusks (0.112) or arthropods (0.343) (printed pp. 14–15, 17).
- Dioxins and community: in Plots B, I and D, where dioxins were higher, that amphipod made up 70–79%, while in Plots F and G, where they were lower, it made up only 25% and 12%; the correlation coefficient was 0.636 but not significant (p = 0.124). Dioxin concentration showed no significant correlation with species number, diversity or evenness (printed pp. 16–17).
The thesis's inferences and recommendations
- The thesis infers that, since the pond had been contaminated with dioxins for more than 50 years, the benthic animals able to survive are mostly highly tolerant, so diversity does not vary with dioxin concentration; that amphipod may be especially tolerant, but 「此推論需進一步驗證」 ("this inference needs further verification") (printed p. 17).
- The thesis infers, drawing on a food-web study of the Qigu Lagoon (Lin et al. 1999), that shrimp, crabs and fish in the pond accumulate dioxins by eating sediment detritus and benthic animals and are in turn caught and eaten by nearby residents, producing something like biomagnification (printed pp. 18–19).
- The thesis infers that, because the pond is relatively deep on average and has few shallows at low tide, and few birds had been observed feeding there, 「故本區戴奧辛對鳥類的影響情形可能不如預期嚴重」 ("the effect of dioxins in this area on birds may therefore be less serious than expected") (printed p. 19).
- Recommendations: dredging out the sediment directly would seriously disturb the benthic community, and the dredged sediment would be hard to dispose of; it recommends that the authorities determine the extent and degree of contamination of organisms, control the movement of organisms from the pond, and 「嚴格禁止當地居民捕撈及食用該地區的水生物」 ("strictly prohibit local residents from catching and eating aquatic organisms from the area") (printed p. 19).
Cautions in use
- The text and Table 1 do not agree on which plots are which: the text says the finest grain size and highest silt and clay are in Plot D, and the highest total nitrogen, total organic carbon and largest sorting coefficient in Plot C; Table 1 has Plot C with the finest grain size (0.1093 mm) and highest silt and clay (22.28%), and Plot B with the highest total nitrogen (0.22%), total organic carbon (1.35%) and sorting coefficient (1.596). This site follows Table 1; the abstract's statement that 「B 樣區有機物含量較高」 ("Plot B has a higher organic matter content") is also consistent with Table 1 (printed pp. 10, 30).
- Mean density of polychaete Sp.17: the text gives 3,224.47 and Table 3 gives 3,424.47 individuals/m²; this site follows the table (printed pp. 13, 35).
- Discrepancies in means: the text gives a mean grain size of 0.1768 mm, silt and clay of 9.73% and mean water depth of 67.7 cm, while Table 1 gives 0.1731 mm, 11.50% and 73.0 cm (printed pp. 10, 30).
- The introduction gives 1942 as 「明治 17 年」 ("Meiji 17"); it should be Shōwa 17. It also states that 「近 5000 公噸五氯酚露天堆置」 ("nearly 5,000 metric tons of pentachlorophenol were stored in the open") at the plant (citing Chung 2003), a thousandfold difference from the "nearly 5,000 kg" given by Chang Jung-wei's (張榮偉) 2009 doctoral dissertation and the Tainan City Environmental Protection Bureau; see Pentachlorophenol (printed p. 2).
- Most species are identified only to family or genus (numbered Sp.1–Sp.24); several scientific names are spelled or placed differently from current checklists:
- Grandidierella japonica in Table 3 is placed in Odeicerotidae, while the Catalogue of Life in Taiwan (TaiCOL) lists it under Aoridae (賴鉤蝦科).
- Theodoxus oualanisnsis (the thesis's own spelling, Table 3), judging by its specific epithet, corresponds to TaiCOL's 鹿斑蜑螺 (Clithon oualaniense); reports commissioned by the Taijiang National Park Headquarters mostly call it 小石蜑螺 and sometimes spell the scientific name Clithon oualaniensis.
- Balanus glandula, Neomysis mercedis, Mytilus comptus, Melita nitida, Corophium stimpsoni and Parougia wolfi have no Taiwan records in TaiCOL; they are listed as in the original thesis, and no separate species entries are created for them.
- The abstract writes "Shannon-Weiner"; the correct spelling is Shannon-Wiener.
About the author
- Chen Hsueh-ju: author of this thesis. According to the author's own statement at the end of the thesis, he or she holds a bachelor's degree from the Department of Biology and a master's degree from the Institute of Life Sciences, National Cheng Kung University (actual p. 63). Other career details: to be added.
- Supervisors: Hou Ping-chun (NCKU Department of Life Sciences) and Ching-Chang Lee (NCKU Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health). Oral examination committee member: Liang Shih-hsiung.
- Helpers named in the acknowledgments (actual p. 7; only those with full names listed): "李俊瑋老師" ("Professor Li Chun-wei") of the NCKU Research Center for Environmental Trace Toxic Substances (judging by the supervisor's name, this should be Ching-Chang Lee, 李俊璋) and Lin Wu-ting (林霧霆), who provided sediment dioxin and sampling data; Hsieh Hwey-lian of Academia Sinica, who guided the grain-size, total organic carbon and total nitrogen analyses; and Weng Yi-tsung (翁義聰), who helped identify the mollusks.
Cited on this site
- Anshun Plant Seawater Reservoir, Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant.
- Species: Stenothyra chilkaensis (車鼓粟螺), Stenothyra orissaensis (蒼白粟螺), Grandidierella japonica (日本大螯蜚), Clithon oualaniense (鹿斑蜑螺).
- People: Chen Hsueh-ju, Hou Ping-chun, Ching-Chang Lee, Liang Shih-hsiung, Weng Yi-tsung.
- Sister theses from the same sampling campaign: Lin Wu-ting 2004 (dioxins) and Chuang Tsung-yu 2005 (mercury).
2. Authors
3. Copyright status
- Category: Protected by copyright
- Rights holder: Chen Hsueh-ju (陳學儒) (author of the thesis)
- How this site uses it: Summarized with short quotations and page numbers cited.
- Basis: A degree thesis is the author's work; the author is living or the work is still within the term of protection.
4. Where to find it
5. Pages on this site citing this work
- Anshun Plant Seawater ReservoirPlacesp. I–II、5–19、30、32–37
- Chen Hsueh-ju (陳學儒)Peoplep. 實頁 1–4、印頁 5、實頁 63
- Ching-Chang LeePeoplep. 實頁 1、2、7
- Clithon oualanienseSpeciesp. 36
- Grandidierella japonicaSpeciesp. 32
- Hou Ping-chunPeoplep. 實頁 1、2、7
- Liang Shih-hsiungPeoplep. 實頁 2、7
- Stenothyra chilkaensisSpeciesp. 12–13、35
- Stenothyra orissaensisSpeciesp. 35–36
- Taiwan Alkali Anshun PlantInstitutions and Schoolsp. I–II、2、5、10–19
- Weng Yi-tsungPeoplep. 實頁 7
6. People recorded in this work
- Chen Hsueh-ju (陳學儒)p. 實頁 1–4、印頁 5、實頁 63
- Hou Ping-chunp. 實頁 1、2、7
- Ching-Chang Leep. 實頁 1、2、7
- Liang Shih-hsiungp. 實頁 2、7
- Weng Yi-tsungp. 實頁 7