Guided reading
The Guanziling Meeting was a secret gathering held on June 19, 1960, at the Jingle Inn in Guanziling, Tainan, by a group of National Taiwan University graduates and their friends and relatives; held under the pretext of a send-off for those going abroad to study, it ended with all present swearing brotherhood. The Investigation Bureau later pursued the matter, and Liu Chia-shun was sent to a military court and ordered to three years of reformatory education.R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
- Time span
- 1958–201961 years
- Current status
- On 2019-05-30 the Transitional Justice Commission annulled by public notice the pronouncement of Liu Chia-shun's security measure; in 2007-11 the participants reunited in Taipei R005Source促進轉型正義委員會 [Transitional Justice Commission] public notice, list of annulments in notice 促轉三字第1085300156A號 of 2019-05-30 (serial no. 0619, Liu Chia-shun)Original URLhttps://tjb.ey.gov.tw/File/5FC5B61F1E583CD2/32ed6d0c-d680-4b3f-b4c0-aa6dc55c850b?A=CRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—R007SourceBlog of Chien Yu-yen (簡余晏), 〈《被出賣的台灣》譯者陳榮成:關仔嶺會議成員,47年後重聚首〉 [Chen Jung-cheng, Translator of Formosa Betrayed: Members of the Guanziling Meeting Reunite after 47 Years], 2007-11-02Original URLhttp://www.yuyen.tw/2007/11/47.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—
- Key figures
- 1960-06-19Date of the gatheringR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
- 43 (27 on the official list)ParticipantsR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
- 1 (Liu Chia-shun)Referred to military justiceR002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.
- Three years of reformatory educationMeasureR003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- Evidence mix
Why it matters
This gathering was held at Guanziling in Tainan and is one of the Tainan-area events recorded in the Memory Bank R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. No organization was founded, and the official files do not show any active pursuit of the gathering itself, yet one participant was sent to reformatory education for his speech, and several participants were summoned for questioning or detained R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references..
Main actors
Participant 6
- Tsai Tung-jung (蔡同榮)One of those being sent off abroad; one of the main initiatorsR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
- Liu Chia-shun (劉家順)The only one referred to military justiceR002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.
- Hou Jung-pang (侯榮邦)One of the liaisons; summoned for questioning three timesR002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.
- Chen An-lan (陳安瀾)One of the liaisons; detained for 5 monthsR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
and 2 more
- Tsai Shun-li (蔡順利)One of the liaisons; detained for 5 monthsR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
- Huang Kun-hu (黃崑虎)Afterward fled to the mountains of Hsinchu and took up livestock farmingR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
Investigating agency 1
- Investigation Bureau of the Ministry of Judicial Administration (司法行政部調查局)Detained Liu Chia-shun and held Chen An-lanR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
Adjudicating body 1
- Taiwan Garrison Command (臺灣警備總司令部)Ruling (51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30]R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Turning points
Click a year to jump to it in the full timeline below.
- 1960-06-19Gathering and sworn brotherhood at the Jingle Inn, GuanzilingR001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
- 1960-11-25Liu Chia-shun detained by the Investigation BureauR004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 1962-05Liu Chia-shun ordered by ruling to undergo three years of reformatory educationR003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 2007-11Participants reunite in TaipeiR007SourceBlog of Chien Yu-yen (簡余晏), 〈《被出賣的台灣》譯者陳榮成:關仔嶺會議成員,47年後重聚首〉 [Chen Jung-cheng, Translator of Formosa Betrayed: Members of the Guanziling Meeting Reunite after 47 Years], 2007-11-02Original URLhttp://www.yuyen.tw/2007/11/47.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
- 2019-05-30Transitional Justice Commission annuls Liu Chia-shun's security measureR005Source促進轉型正義委員會 [Transitional Justice Commission] public notice, list of annulments in notice 促轉三字第1085300156A號 of 2019-05-30 (serial no. 0619, Liu Chia-shun)Original URLhttps://tjb.ey.gov.tw/File/5FC5B61F1E583CD2/32ed6d0c-d680-4b3f-b4c0-aa6dc55c850b?A=CRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)
Where to start reading
Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.
The Guanziling Meeting (關仔嶺會議) was a secret gathering held on June 19, 1960, at the Jingle Inn (靜樂旅社) in the Guanziling (關仔嶺) hot-spring area of Tainan by a group of National Taiwan University graduates and their friends and relatives; held under the pretext of a send-off for Tsai Tung-jung (蔡同榮) and Liu Chia-shun (劉家順), who were going abroad to study, it discussed the party-founding movement of Lei Chen (雷震), Li Wan-chu (李萬居), and others, and ended with all present swearing brotherhood R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record The National Human Rights Memory Bank calls it 「臺獨運動史上一場特殊的秘密會議,以『結拜兄弟』方式凝聚情誼,為未來可能的組織工作鋪路,因事洩造成政治獄」 ("a distinctive secret meeting in the history of the Taiwan independence movement; it built bonds of friendship by 'swearing brotherhood,' paving the way for possible future organizational work, and when it was exposed it led to political imprisonment") R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. About 43 people took part (the authorities obtained a list of only 27); the Investigation Bureau later pursued the matter, and Liu Chia-shun was the only one sent to a military court, ordered in 1962 to three years of reformatory education; in 2019 the Transitional Justice Commission announced the revocation of his security-measure sentence R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—R005Source促進轉型正義委員會 [Transitional Justice Commission] public notice, list of annulments in notice 促轉三字第1085300156A號 of 2019-05-30 (serial no. 0619, Liu Chia-shun)Original URLhttps://tjb.ey.gov.tw/File/5FC5B61F1E583CD2/32ed6d0c-d680-4b3f-b4c0-aa6dc55c850b?A=CRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Names
- The National Human Rights Memory Bank calls it the 「關仔嶺會議」 (Guanziling Meeting) R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- Wikipedia calls it the 「關子嶺會議」 R010Source維基百科中文版 [Chinese Wikipedia]: 關子嶺會議 [Guanziling Meeting]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/zh-tw/%E9%97%9C%E5%AD%90%E5%B6%BA%E6%9C%83%E8%AD%B0Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—An online encyclopedia, used only for comparison.; Thinking Taiwan (想想論壇) calls it the 「關仔嶺事件」 (Guanziling Incident), explaining that the matter 「並沒有正式成案」 ("never formally became a case") and that this is a name used in later accounts R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.. Secondhand account
Course of events
First items: Origins: the Memory Bank says that a gro…1960-06-19 Under the pretext of a send-o…At the meeting: the talk centered on the…MoreLess
- Origins: the Memory Bank says that a group of NTU graduates 「具有強烈臺灣意識」 ("with a strong Taiwanese consciousness," in Tsai Tung-jung's words) who were dissatisfied with Kuomintang rule were one after another finishing military service or about to go abroad, and 10 alumni planned the gathering together R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 recollection says the planners were ten people, including George Chang (Chang Tsan-hung, 張燦鍙), Tsai Tung-jung (蔡同榮), Lo Fu-chen (羅福全) and Hou Jung-pang R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.. Secondhand account
- 1960-06-19 Under the pretext of a send-off for Tsai Tung-jung and Liu Chia-shun (劉家順), who were going abroad, they rented the whole Jingle Inn (靜樂旅社) in the Guanziling hot-spring area of Tainan for two days and one night R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- Tsai Tung-jung, 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back]: 「投宿者只有參加會議的人,沒有其他旅客。為迴避警察的耳目,只有一部分的人向旅館登記」 ("The only guests were those attending the meeting; there were no other travelers. To avoid the eyes and ears of the police, only some of us registered with the inn") (as quoted by Thinking Taiwan) R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.. Secondhand account
- At the meeting: the talk centered on the party-founding movement of Lei Chen (雷震), Li Wan-chu (李萬居) and others; to reduce the risk, there was no proposal for an organization or plan of activities, and all agreed to raise their glasses and swear brotherhood R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- Agreements: when any of the brothers married, everyone would do their best to attend; every year on the second day of the Lunar New Year they would gather for two days and one night; Hou Jung-pang, Tsai Shun-li (蔡順利) and Chen An-lan (陳安瀾) were chosen as liaisons for the next gathering R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- Participants: 43 (the authorities obtained a list of only 27), mostly NTU alumni, with a few relatives and friends R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Those named by the Memory Bank R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.: Official record
- NTU Department of Law: Tsai Tung-jung, Hou Jung-pang, Chen Jung-cheng (陳榮成), Chung Liao-chuan (鍾廖權), Huang Kun-hu (黃崑虎).
- NTU Department of Political Science: Chen An-lan, Liu Chia-shun, Chen Yen-chang (陳燕昌).
- NTU Department of Economics: Lo Fu-chen, Li Hsi-lu (李錫祿).
- NTU Department of Chemical Engineering: George Chang; Department of Agricultural Economics: Hou Jung-mei (侯榮楣).
- Tamkang College of Arts and Sciences (淡江文理學院): Sun Ching-yuan (孫靜源); Tamkang English College (淡江英專): Tsai Shun-li, Wu Kao-shan (吳高山).
- 《共和國雜誌》 [The Republic] writes: 「四十多人的聚會當中沒有一人是國民黨員,在『三人以上不得秘密集會』的戒嚴體制下,當然是蠻大條的代誌。」 ("Not one of the forty-odd people at the gathering was a Kuomintang member; under the martial-law system of 'no secret gatherings of three or more people,' it was of course a pretty big deal.") R008Source〈人生的選擇──羅福全和毛清芬的青春寫照〉 [Life's Choices: A Portrait of the Youth of Lo Fu-chen and Mao Ching-fen], 台灣獨立建國聯盟 [World United Formosans for Independence], 《共和國雜誌》 [The Republic] no. 49, 2006-07Original URLhttps://wufi.org.tw/therepublic/vol-49/%E4%BA%BA%E7%94%9F%E7%9A%84%E9%81%B8%E6%93%87-%E2%94%80%E2%94%80%E7%BE%85%E7%A6%8F%E5%85%A8%E5%92%8C%E6%AF%9B%E6%B8%85%E8%8A%AC%E7%9A%84%E9%9D%92%E6%98%A5%E5%AF%AB%E7%85%A7Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Secondhand account
Investigation and punishment
First items: Table of persons involvedMoreLess
- The Memory Bank's assessment: Liu Chia-shun was probably arrested and named names, after which Chen An-lan and Tsai Shun-li were arrested on the strength of his statement (both were detained for 5 months), and the brothers Hou Jung-mei and Hou Jung-pang and Wu Kao-shan were summoned for questioning R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- The Memory Bank points out that, judging from the official files, the Investigation Bureau 「對關仔嶺會議因掌握線索有限,似未積極追查,反較關注劉的臺獨言論」 ("having limited leads on the Guanziling Meeting, seems not to have pursued it actively, and was instead more concerned with Liu's pro-independence remarks"), including those at a 1958 gathering at the home of Chiu Hung-ta (丘宏達) R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- Liu Chia-shun: on the eve of going abroad his passport was revoked by the Garrison Command; after returning to Chiayi he was summoned for questioning by the Chiayi station of the Investigation Bureau; he was first held in the Investigation Bureau's holding room (the Sanzhangli guesthouse, 三張犂招待所) R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.. Secondhand account
- On 1960-11-25 he was detained by the Investigation Bureau on 「涉嫌叛亂」 ("suspicion of rebellion") and locked up in the Dalongdong No. 1 Holding Room (大龍峒第一留置室) R004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- In 1962, by ruling (51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30 of the Taiwan Garrison Command, under Article 8, Paragraph 1, Subparagraph 2 of the 《戡亂時期檢肅匪諜條例》 [Statute for the Detection and Elimination of Communist Spies during the Period of Communist Rebellion] and Article 2, Paragraph 2 of the 《戡亂時期匪諜交付感化辦法》 [Regulations on Reformatory Education for Communist Spies during the Period of Communist Rebellion], he was ordered to undergo 「交付感化三年」 ("three years of reformatory education"); the prosecutor was Hu Shen-yi (胡慎義) and the judge Chao Hua-tung (趙華通) R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- Thinking Taiwan: 「劉家順是這些人中唯一被送軍法的。」 ("Liu Chia-shun was the only one of these people sent to military justice.") R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.Secondhand account
- Chen An-lan: the National Archives file 〈陳安瀾案〉 [The Chen An-lan Case] is a 「50年間司法行政部調查局留質室被留質人資料袋」 ("data folder on persons held in the holding room of the Investigation Bureau of the Ministry of Judicial Administration, ROC year 50"), containing fingerprint cards and front and profile photographs, file date 1961-01-02 R006Source國家檔案資訊網 [National Archives Information Network], 〈陳安瀾案〉 [The Chen An-lan Case], 法務部調查局 [Ministry of Justice Investigation Bureau], file no. A311010000F/0059/156/00704Original URLhttps://aa.archives.gov.tw/ELK/SearchDetailed?SystemID=MDAwMDE4NDExMg==Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- The Memory Bank has another person page for a Chen An-lan: born 1932, a native of Tainan County, who in 1950, as a student at Chiayi Middle School (嘉義中學), was implicated in case (39) An-Cheng No. 1560 ((39)安澄字第1560號), was judged 「無罪」 ("not guilty"), and was detained for 243 days R011Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈陳安瀾〉 [Chen An-lan] person pageOriginal URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/15056Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Thinking Taiwan considers the two to be the same person R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.; the Memory Bank person page itself does not mention the Guanziling Meeting. Unverified
- Hou Jung-pang: according to his 1993 recollection, he was summoned for questioning three times in all; the agents showed him a secret denunciation signed by his classmate Shih Chi-yang (施啟揚; the text also writes 「施啟陽」), and he firmly denied that Taiwan independence had been discussed at the meeting; in April 1963 he went to Japan to study R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.. Secondhand account
- Informant: the Memory Bank's Liu Chia-shun page records 「本案線民龔伯文」 ("the informant in this case, Kung Po-wen (龔伯文)"), whom the Investigation Bureau called the 「本案原報內線」 ("the inside source who originally reported this case") R004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Table of persons involved
| Name | Native place | Status at the time | Measures taken | Redress |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liu Chia-shun | Erlun (二崙), Yunlin | Graduate of the NTU Department of Political Science; discharged reserve officer | Three years of reformatory education under (51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30; a total of 4 years, 6 months and 2 days including detention | Compensated in 2002; annulled 2019-05-30 |
| Chen An-lan | Tainan County (Memory Bank person page for the 1950 case) | NTU Department of Political Science | Detained by the Investigation Bureau for 5 months | No record found for this case |
| Tsai Shun-li | Unknown | Tamkang English College | Detained by the Investigation Bureau for 5 months | No record found for this case |
| Hou Jung-pang, Hou Jung-mei, Wu Kao-shan | Unknown | NTU Department of Law, Department of Agricultural Economics, Tamkang English College | Summoned for questioning | None |
Sources: R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—R004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—R005Source促進轉型正義委員會 [Transitional Justice Commission] public notice, list of annulments in notice 促轉三字第1085300156A號 of 2019-05-30 (serial no. 0619, Liu Chia-shun)Original URLhttps://tjb.ey.gov.tw/File/5FC5B61F1E583CD2/32ed6d0c-d680-4b3f-b4c0-aa6dc55c850b?A=CRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Aftermath
- Chien Yu-yen's (簡余晏) blog, 2007-11-02: 「距離1960年6月19日關仔嶺會議已47年整……養雞大王黃崑虎、國安會秘書長陳唐山、旅美教授陳榮成、立委蔡同榮、前駐日代表羅福全、台獨聯盟財務長侯榮邦等人,難得將再次聚會」 ("It has been exactly 47 years since the Guanziling Meeting of June 19, 1960... 'chicken king' Huang Kun-hu, National Security Council Secretary-General Mark Chen (Chen Tang-shan, 陳唐山), U.S.-based professor Chen Jung-cheng, legislator Tsai Tung-jung, former representative to Japan Lo Fu-chen, WUFI treasurer Hou Jung-pang and others will have a rare chance to meet again"); the host of the forum was Huang Kun-hu R007SourceBlog of Chien Yu-yen (簡余晏), 〈《被出賣的台灣》譯者陳榮成:關仔嶺會議成員,47年後重聚首〉 [Chen Jung-cheng, Translator of Formosa Betrayed: Members of the Guanziling Meeting Reunite after 47 Years], 2007-11-02Original URLhttp://www.yuyen.tw/2007/11/47.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- A 2012-08-07 article by the Taiwan Earth Cultural and Educational Foundation (台灣大地文教基金會): 「1960年6月19日,羅福全參加蔡同榮所策劃的關仔嶺事件,因未被國民黨察覺,而得以順利出國。」 ("On June 19, 1960, Lo Fu-chen took part in the Guanziling Incident planned by Tsai Tung-jung; because he was not detected by the Kuomintang, he was able to go abroad without trouble.") R009Source財團法人台灣大地文教基金會 [Taiwan Earth Cultural and Educational Foundation], 〈建立台日新關係〉 [Building a New Taiwan–Japan Relationship], 2012-08-07Original URLhttps://www.taiwantt.org.tw/tw/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=5737&Itemid=57Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Secondhand account
- The closing line of the Memory Bank event page: 「黃崑虎從臺南逃往新竹山區,從事畜牧,後成為『養雞大王』。」 ("Huang Kun-hu fled from Tainan to the mountains of Hsinchu and took up livestock farming, later becoming the 'chicken king.'") R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.Official record
Differing accounts
Number of participants
- Account 1Memory Bank event page: 「這次參加者有43人(官方僅取得27人名單)」 ("there were 43 participants this time (the authorities obtained a list of only 27)")R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.
- Account 2The Republic no. 49: 「四十多人的聚會」 ("a gathering of more than forty people"); Chien Yu-yen's blog: 「找來43人」 ("brought together 43 people")R008Source〈人生的選擇──羅福全和毛清芬的青春寫照〉 [Life's Choices: A Portrait of the Youth of Lo Fu-chen and Mao Ching-fen], 台灣獨立建國聯盟 [World United Formosans for Independence], 《共和國雜誌》 [The Republic] no. 49, 2006-07Original URLhttps://wufi.org.tw/therepublic/vol-49/%E4%BA%BA%E7%94%9F%E7%9A%84%E9%81%B8%E6%93%87-%E2%94%80%E2%94%80%E7%BE%85%E7%A6%8F%E5%85%A8%E5%92%8C%E6%AF%9B%E6%B8%85%E8%8A%AC%E7%9A%84%E9%9D%92%E6%98%A5%E5%AF%AB%E7%85%A7Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—
- Account 3Wikipedia: 「參與者有六十餘人」 ("there were more than sixty participants")R010Source維基百科中文版 [Chinese Wikipedia]: 關子嶺會議 [Guanziling Meeting]Original URLhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/zh-tw/%E9%97%9C%E5%AD%90%E5%B6%BA%E6%9C%83%E8%AD%B0Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—An online encyclopedia, used only for comparison.
The measure imposed on Liu Chia-shun
- Account 1Transitional Justice Database, Memory Bank and Transitional Justice Commission list: ruling (51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30, 「交付感化三年」 ("three years of reformatory education"), a total of 4 years, 6 months and 2 days including detentionR003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—
- Account 2The Republic no. 49: 「不幸的劉家順後來被捕判刑10年」 ("the unfortunate Liu Chia-shun was later arrested and sentenced to 10 years"); Wikipedia says the sameR008Source〈人生的選擇──羅福全和毛清芬的青春寫照〉 [Life's Choices: A Portrait of the Youth of Lo Fu-chen and Mao Ching-fen], 台灣獨立建國聯盟 [World United Formosans for Independence], 《共和國雜誌》 [The Republic] no. 49, 2006-07Original URLhttps://wufi.org.tw/therepublic/vol-49/%E4%BA%BA%E7%94%9F%E7%9A%84%E9%81%B8%E6%93%87-%E2%94%80%E2%94%80%E7%BE%85%E7%A6%8F%E5%85%A8%E5%92%8C%E6%AF%9B%E6%B8%85%E8%8A%AC%E7%9A%84%E9%9D%92%E6%98%A5%E5%AF%AB%E7%85%A7Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—
The official files show a reformatory measure; "sentenced to 10 years" appears only in later articles.
Date of the ruling on Liu Chia-shun
- Account 1Historical materials field of the Memory Bank person page: date of the ruling 510512 (1962-05-12)R004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—
- Account 2Transitional Justice Database: hearing date May 18, ROC year 51, and the decision date in the judgment header 510518; Thinking Taiwan likewise gives 1962-05-18R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—
Key events
First items: At a graduates' social dinner at the hom…Lo Fu-chen leaves for Waseda University …Liu Chia-shun detained by the Investigat…MoreLess
- 1958
06At a graduates' social dinner at the hom…MoreLess
At a graduates' social dinner at the home of Chiu Hung-ta, Liu Chia-shun advocated Taiwan independence (as found in the ruling) R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 1960
- 06-19Gathering at the Jingle Inn, Guanziling R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
08-04Lo Fu-chen leaves for Waseda University …MoreLess
Lo Fu-chen leaves for Waseda University (早稻田大學) in Japan R008Source〈人生的選擇──羅福全和毛清芬的青春寫照〉 [Life's Choices: A Portrait of the Youth of Lo Fu-chen and Mao Ching-fen], 台灣獨立建國聯盟 [World United Formosans for Independence], 《共和國雜誌》 [The Republic] no. 49, 2006-07Original URLhttps://wufi.org.tw/therepublic/vol-49/%E4%BA%BA%E7%94%9F%E7%9A%84%E9%81%B8%E6%93%87-%E2%94%80%E2%94%80%E7%BE%85%E7%A6%8F%E5%85%A8%E5%92%8C%E6%AF%9B%E6%B8%85%E8%8A%AC%E7%9A%84%E9%9D%92%E6%98%A5%E5%AF%AB%E7%85%A7Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account11-25Liu Chia-shun detained by the Investigat…MoreLess
Liu Chia-shun detained by the Investigation Bureau R004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 1961
01-02Chen An-lan entered in the Investigation…MoreLess
Chen An-lan entered in the Investigation Bureau's records of persons held in its holding room R006Source國家檔案資訊網 [National Archives Information Network], 〈陳安瀾案〉 [The Chen An-lan Case], 法務部調查局 [Ministry of Justice Investigation Bureau], file no. A311010000F/0059/156/00704Original URLhttps://aa.archives.gov.tw/ELK/SearchDetailed?SystemID=MDAwMDE4NDExMg==Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 1962
05Liu Chia-shun ordered by ruling to under…MoreLess
Liu Chia-shun ordered by ruling to undergo three years of reformatory education (other accounts give 05-12 and 05-18) R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—R004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 1965
- 05Liu Chia-shun released R004Source國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈劉家順〉 [Liu Chia-shun] person page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Person/Detail/4894Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- 1970
The Taiwan independence alliance (臺獨聯盟, …MoreLess
The Taiwan independence alliance (臺獨聯盟, World United Formosans for Independence) is founded, with George Chang, Chen Jung-cheng, Hou Jung-pang, Lo Fu-chen and Tsai Tung-jung all core members R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.. Official record
- 2007
11Chen Jung-cheng returns to Taiwan and th…MoreLess
Chen Jung-cheng returns to Taiwan and the participants reunite R007SourceBlog of Chien Yu-yen (簡余晏), 〈《被出賣的台灣》譯者陳榮成:關仔嶺會議成員,47年後重聚首〉 [Chen Jung-cheng, Translator of Formosa Betrayed: Members of the Guanziling Meeting Reunite after 47 Years], 2007-11-02Original URLhttp://www.yuyen.tw/2007/11/47.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Secondhand account
- 2019
05-30The Transitional Justice Commission annu…MoreLess
The Transitional Justice Commission annuls the pronouncement of Liu Chia-shun's security measure R005Source促進轉型正義委員會 [Transitional Justice Commission] public notice, list of annulments in notice 促轉三字第1085300156A號 of 2019-05-30 (serial no. 0619, Liu Chia-shun)Original URLhttps://tjb.ey.gov.tw/File/5FC5B61F1E583CD2/32ed6d0c-d680-4b3f-b4c0-aa6dc55c850b?A=CRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Historical materials
- National Archives: Ministry of Justice Investigation Bureau (法務部調查局), 〈陳安瀾案〉 [The Chen An-lan Case] AA11010000F/0049/3-9/01999 and A311010000F/0059/156/00704; 〈蔡順利案〉 [The Tsai Shun-li Case] A311010000F/0049/156/01100; 〈龔伯文案〉 [The Kung Po-wen Case] AA11010000F/0052/301/01770 R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.R002SourceMa Fei-pai (馬非白), 〈【被遺忘的歷史】蔣家王朝羅織失敗的〈關仔嶺事件〉〉 [(Forgotten History) The "Guanziling Incident": A Failed Frame-up by the Chiang Dynasty], 想想論壇 [Thinking Taiwan], 2022-01-05Original URLhttps://www.thinkingtaiwan.net/content/8505Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—A commentary article quoting extensively from Tsai Tung-jung's (蔡同榮) 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back] and Hou Jung-pang's (侯榮邦) 1993 〈回首關仔嶺事件〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Incident]; the wording of the title reflects the author's position.R006Source國家檔案資訊網 [National Archives Information Network], 〈陳安瀾案〉 [The Chen An-lan Case], 法務部調查局 [Ministry of Justice Investigation Bureau], file no. A311010000F/0059/156/00704Original URLhttps://aa.archives.gov.tw/ELK/SearchDetailed?SystemID=MDAwMDE4NDExMg==Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- Taiwan Transitional Justice Database: Liu Chia-shun, (51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30 R003Source國家人權博物館臺灣轉型正義資料庫 [Taiwan Transitional Justice Database, National Human Rights Museum], the case of Liu Chia-shun (劉家順) ((51)警審聲字第30號 [(51) Ching-Shen-Sheng No. 30])Original URLhttps://twtjdb.nhrm.gov.tw/content-12269-12269.htmlRetrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- Bibliography (as listed by the Memory Bank) R001Source國家人權博物館國家人權記憶庫 [National Human Rights Museum, National Human Rights Memory Bank], 〈關仔嶺會議〉 [Guanziling Meeting] event page (written by Li Chen-hsiang (李禎祥))Original URLhttps://memory.nhrm.gov.tw/TopicExploration/Event/Detail/63Retrieved2026-11-01Snapshot timestamp—Original Memory Bank text captured on 2026-10-29, including 6 references.: Official record
- Chen Yi-shen (陳儀深), 2012, 〈陳榮成先生訪問紀錄〉 [Record of an Interview with Mr. Chen Jung-cheng], in 《海外臺獨運動相關人物口述史(續篇)》 [Oral Histories of Figures in the Overseas Taiwan Independence Movement (Sequel)], pp. 299-314, 中央研究院近代史研究所 [Institute of Modern History, Academia Sinica].
- Tsai Tung-jung (蔡同榮), 1991, 《我要回去》 [I Want to Go Back], pp. 24-25, 敦理出版社 [Tunli Publishing].
- Tsai Tung-jung, 2010, 《顧臺灣》 [Looking After Taiwan], pp. 29-32, 民視文教基金會 [Formosa TV Cultural and Educational Foundation].
- Hou Jung-pang (侯榮邦), 〈回首關仔嶺會議〉 [Looking Back on the Guanziling Meeting], 《自立晚報》 [Independence Evening Post], supplement, 1993-04-07.
See also
- Postwar to 1987・Victims of political casesLiu Chia-shun⚖︎Participant in the Guanziling Meeting
- Postwar to 1987・Victims of political casesChung Liao-chuanVictim in the Youth Comrades Association case, Jiali junior high school dean
- 1987 to present・Postwar officialsMark ChenFormer magistrate of Tainan County and minister of foreign affairs
Reports that mention it
Hall of Local Memory9.10Everyday memories / Remembered events
The White Terror in Nanying
Around 1950 the branches of the Tainan City Work Committee of the Chinese Communist Party's Taiwan Provincial Work Committee were uncovered one after another in the former Tainan County: the cases in Madou, Danei, Yujing, Xiaying and central Tainan, together with the story of the principal of the Tucheng National School who resigned because he had stood as guarantor for an accused man, and of the two managers of the Taiwan Alkali Anshun Plant who were tried.
Continue from here
- Other EventsCase of Yang Ching-chi et al., Danei Branch⚖︎A 1950 White Terror case in Danei Township, Tainan County
- Related entriesLiu Chia-shun⚖︎Participant in the Guanziling Meeting
- Entries in the same hallThe Madou Branch Case of Hsieh Jui-jen et al.⚖︎A 1950 political case in Madou's sugar factory and township officeContains 11 items