The 2002 Botulism Poisoning of Black-faced Spoonbills⚖︎

Official recordSecondhand accountUnverified
440

Verification status of the entries on this page

  • Verified
  • Partially verified
  • Not covered by sources
  • Verified: the source was found and checked
  • Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records
Category
Events
Area
Qigu
Also known as
黑面琵鷺肉毒桿菌中毒、2002 黑面琵鷺集體死亡、2002 spoonbill botulism outbreak、2002 black-faced spoonbill mass death

Guided reading

The 2002 black-faced spoonbill botulism incident was the outbreak of type C botulinum toxin poisoning among black-faced spoonbills in the Qigu area of Tainan from December 2002 to early 2003, in which 73 birds died.R001SourceChuang Wei-chao (莊惟超), Hsieh Yao-ching (謝耀清), Chen Shih-hui (陳世輝), Li Yen-feng (李儼峰), Tsai Keng-yu (蔡耿宇) and Tsai Hsin-hsiung (蔡信雄), 〈黑面琵鷺C1型肉毒梭狀桿菌毒素中毒症〉 ["Type C1 Clostridium botulinum Toxin Poisoning in Black-faced Spoonbills"], 《臺灣獸醫學雜誌》 [Taiwan Veterinary Journal] vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12), pp. 267–273; official web pages of PTS (公視) 《我們的島》 [Our Island] episodes 188, 203 and 232Original URL(None, or not applicable)Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp(None, or not applicable)Abstract of an academic journal article; web pages of the PTS program.

Evidence mix
Verification
  • ✓ Verified 4
  • ◑ Partially verified 4
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources 0
Source type
  • Official record 5
  • Secondhand account 8
  • Unverified 1
✓ ◑ ⊗
  • ✓ Verified: the source was found and checked
  • ◑ Partially verified: only part could be checked, or the check found the opposite
  • ⊗ Not covered by sources: nothing found in currently available public records

Where to start reading

Differing accounts ↓

Full recordBelow is the item-by-item record; every item cites its source.

The 2002 black-faced spoonbill botulism incident was an outbreak of type C botulinum toxin poisoning among black-faced spoonbills in the fish-pond area of Qigu Township, Tainan County, from December 2002 to early 2003; it came in three or four waves, and 73 birds died in all (a count taken while the event was under way gave 53) [R001][R002][R003].

Course of events

Taiwan Veterinary Journal, vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12): mass deaths of black-faced spoonbills broke out on 2002-12-09 in the East Fish Pond (東漁塭) and North Fish Pond (北漁塭) in Qigu Township, Tainan County, and recurred on 2002-12-21 and 2003-01-03; the three waves together killed 73 birds R001SourceChuang Wei-chao (莊惟超), Hsieh Yao-ching (謝耀清), Chen Shih-hui (陳世輝), Li Yen-feng (李儼峰), Tsai Keng-yu (蔡耿宇) and Tsai Hsin-hsiung (蔡信雄), 〈黑面琵鷺C1型肉毒梭狀桿菌毒素中毒症〉 ["Type C1 Clostridium botulinum Toxin Poisoning in Black-faced Spoonbills"], 《臺灣獸醫學雜誌》 [Taiwan Veterinary Journal] vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12), pp. 267–273; official web pages of PTS (公視) 《我們的島》 [Our Island] episodes 188, 203 and 232Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Abstract of an academic journal article; web pages of the PTS program.. Official record

Key events

  1. 2002-12-09 Mass deaths break out in the East and North Fish Ponds in Qigu R001SourceChuang Wei-chao (莊惟超), Hsieh Yao-ching (謝耀清), Chen Shih-hui (陳世輝), Li Yen-feng (李儼峰), Tsai Keng-yu (蔡耿宇) and Tsai Hsin-hsiung (蔡信雄), 〈黑面琵鷺C1型肉毒梭狀桿菌毒素中毒症〉 ["Type C1 Clostridium botulinum Toxin Poisoning in Black-faced Spoonbills"], 《臺灣獸醫學雜誌》 [Taiwan Veterinary Journal] vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12), pp. 267–273; official web pages of PTS (公視) 《我們的島》 [Our Island] episodes 188, 203 and 232Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Abstract of an academic journal article; web pages of the PTS program.. Official record
  2. 2002-12-21 Second wave R001SourceChuang Wei-chao (莊惟超), Hsieh Yao-ching (謝耀清), Chen Shih-hui (陳世輝), Li Yen-feng (李儼峰), Tsai Keng-yu (蔡耿宇) and Tsai Hsin-hsiung (蔡信雄), 〈黑面琵鷺C1型肉毒梭狀桿菌毒素中毒症〉 ["Type C1 Clostridium botulinum Toxin Poisoning in Black-faced Spoonbills"], 《臺灣獸醫學雜誌》 [Taiwan Veterinary Journal] vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12), pp. 267–273; official web pages of PTS (公視) 《我們的島》 [Our Island] episodes 188, 203 and 232Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Abstract of an academic journal article; web pages of the PTS program.. Official record
  3. 2002-12-23 Our Island episode 188 counts 53 deaths R002SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 188 (2002-12-23)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/1394Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.. Secondhand account
  4. 2003-01-03 Third wave; the three waves together killed 73 R001SourceChuang Wei-chao (莊惟超), Hsieh Yao-ching (謝耀清), Chen Shih-hui (陳世輝), Li Yen-feng (李儼峰), Tsai Keng-yu (蔡耿宇) and Tsai Hsin-hsiung (蔡信雄), 〈黑面琵鷺C1型肉毒梭狀桿菌毒素中毒症〉 ["Type C1 Clostridium botulinum Toxin Poisoning in Black-faced Spoonbills"], 《臺灣獸醫學雜誌》 [Taiwan Veterinary Journal] vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12), pp. 267–273; official web pages of PTS (公視) 《我們的島》 [Our Island] episodes 188, 203 and 232Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Abstract of an academic journal article; web pages of the PTS program.. Official record
  5. 2003-11-24 Our Island episode 232: 73 deaths, 17 released into the wild after rescue R004SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 232 (2003-11-24)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.. Secondhand account

Rescue and the inferred source of the toxin

3 itemsFirst items: Episode 188 (2002-12-23) gave the count …Episode 203 (2003-04-14) said there were…Episode 232 (2003-11-24) writes that 73 …MoreLess
  1. Episode 188 (2002-12-23) gave the count while the event was under way: 53 dead and 10 slowly recovering; of these, 8 were cared for by veterinarians of the Tainan County Livestock Disease Control Center, and the medical staff named them 「黑面琵鷺永保安康」 ("Black-faced Spoonbills Forever Safe and Well") and called them Xiao Hei ("Little Black"), Xiao Mian ("Little Face"), Xiao Pi ("Little Spoon") and Xiao Lu ("Little Egret") R002SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 188 (2002-12-23)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/1394Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.. Secondhand account
  2. Episode 203 (2003-04-14) said there were four waves of poisoning from December 2002 to February 2003, with 73 deaths; after the third wave the veterinarian Chi Wei-lien (祈偉廉) inferred that the source of the toxin may have been dead hard clams: fish have a high tolerance to the toxin and do not die from eating toxic clams, and the spoonbills were poisoned by eating those fish; in the four days before 8 December there had been high temperatures and low pressure, which lowered the dissolved oxygen in the water and made the clams prone to die R003SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 203 (2003-04-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.. Secondhand account
  3. Episode 232 (2003-11-24) writes that 73 died and 17 were released into the wild after being rescued; patrol wardens patrolled between the more than 2,000 hectares of fish ponds and the reserve and removed dead fish from the ponds, and the Tainan County Livestock Disease Control Center took samples for testing every month at 16 fixed points R004SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 232 (2003-11-24)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.. Secondhand account

Impact

The Tainan County Government and the Council of Agriculture held an international black-faced spoonbill symposium, and the Tainan County Government established a patrol-warden system R003SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 203 (2003-04-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.R004SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 232 (2003-11-24)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.. Secondhand account

Differing accounts

  1. Location: the academic report writes "East Fish Pond and North Fish Pond" R001SourceChuang Wei-chao (莊惟超), Hsieh Yao-ching (謝耀清), Chen Shih-hui (陳世輝), Li Yen-feng (李儼峰), Tsai Keng-yu (蔡耿宇) and Tsai Hsin-hsiung (蔡信雄), 〈黑面琵鷺C1型肉毒梭狀桿菌毒素中毒症〉 ["Type C1 Clostridium botulinum Toxin Poisoning in Black-faced Spoonbills"], 《臺灣獸醫學雜誌》 [Taiwan Veterinary Journal] vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12), pp. 267–273; official web pages of PTS (公視) 《我們的島》 [Our Island] episodes 188, 203 and 232Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Abstract of an academic journal article; web pages of the PTS program., while Business Today (今周刊) and others write "the main habitat at the Zengwen River mouth." Both are presented. Unverified
  2. Numbers poisoned and recovered: the chronology in Huang Jui-chin's (黃瑞琴) 2014 thesis gives 「90 隻中毒(73 隻中毒死亡,17 隻復原野放)」 ("90 poisoned (73 died of poisoning, 17 recovered and released into the wild)") and calls it 「近年最嚴重的單一死亡事件」 ("the most serious single mortality event in recent years") R005SourceHuang Jui-chin (黃瑞琴),《從黑面琵鷺的驛站看臺江區域特色》[Characteristics of Taijiang Region: Black-faced Spoonbill's Stage],國立臺灣師範大學臺灣語文學系碩士學位在職進修專班 [In-Service Master's Program, Department of Taiwan Culture, Languages and Literature, National Taiwan Normal University] master's thesis, 2014, pp. 58–59Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Characteristics of Taijiang Region: Black-faced Spoonbill's Stage (從黑面琵鷺的驛站看臺江區域特色)》p. 58–59Table 2-4, 「黑面琵鷺在台大事紀」 ("Chronology of the Black-faced Spoonbill in Taiwan"), compiled from Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智) and Hsieh Chih-cheng's (謝志誠) 《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》 [The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], the website of the Tainan County Black-faced Spoonbill Conservation Association, and exhibition materials.. Secondhand account
  3. Source of the toxin: the same chronology says that the international black-faced spoonbill conservation symposium held in Tainan in 2003 discussed the poisoning, and that the cause was 「曾文溪中畜禽浮屍所產生的肉毒桿菌 C 型毒素,被魚攝入,黑面琵鷺吃了中毒的魚」 ("type C botulinum toxin produced by floating carcasses of livestock and poultry in the Zengwen River was ingested by fish, and the black-faced spoonbills ate the poisoned fish") R005SourceHuang Jui-chin (黃瑞琴),《從黑面琵鷺的驛站看臺江區域特色》[Characteristics of Taijiang Region: Black-faced Spoonbill's Stage],國立臺灣師範大學臺灣語文學系碩士學位在職進修專班 [In-Service Master's Program, Department of Taiwan Culture, Languages and Literature, National Taiwan Normal University] master's thesis, 2014, pp. 58–59Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-20Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Characteristics of Taijiang Region: Black-faced Spoonbill's Stage (從黑面琵鷺的驛站看臺江區域特色)》p. 58–59Table 2-4, 「黑面琵鷺在台大事紀」 ("Chronology of the Black-faced Spoonbill in Taiwan"), compiled from Su Huan-chih (蘇煥智) and Hsieh Chih-cheng's (謝志誠) 《黑面琵鷺的鄉愁》 [The Nostalgia of the Black-faced Spoonbill], the website of the Tainan County Black-faced Spoonbill Conservation Association, and exhibition materials.; this differs from the "dead hard clams" source inferred by the veterinarian Chi Wei-lien in episode 203 R003SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 203 (2003-04-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.. Secondhand account

Where the sources disagree

Death toll, number of waves and location of the 2002 botulism outbreak

  1. Account 1Academic case report: three waves in the East and North fish ponds, 73 deaths in totalR001SourceChuang Wei-chao (莊惟超), Hsieh Yao-ching (謝耀清), Chen Shih-hui (陳世輝), Li Yen-feng (李儼峰), Tsai Keng-yu (蔡耿宇) and Tsai Hsin-hsiung (蔡信雄), 〈黑面琵鷺C1型肉毒梭狀桿菌毒素中毒症〉 ["Type C1 Clostridium botulinum Toxin Poisoning in Black-faced Spoonbills"], 《臺灣獸醫學雜誌》 [Taiwan Veterinary Journal] vol. 31, no. 4 (2005-12), pp. 267–273; official web pages of PTS (公視) 《我們的島》 [Our Island] episodes 188, 203 and 232Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Abstract of an academic journal article; web pages of the PTS program.
  2. Account 2PTS episode 188 (while the event was under way): 53 deathsR002SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 188 (2002-12-23)Original URLhttps://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/1394Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.
  3. Account 3PTS episode 203: four waves, 73 deathsR003SourceOfficial web page of PTS 《我們的島》 episode 203 (2003-04-14)Original URL—Retrieved2026-11-06Snapshot timestamp—Official site of the PTS program; the page was opened and checked.

See also

Continue from here