Pyruvic acid and pungency measurement refers to representing the pungency of onions and shallots by pyruvate, a stable by-product of the Allium flavor reaction formed in equal amounts to the flavor volatiles; internationally "enzymatically produced pyruvate" (EPY) is used to represent onion pungency, and since 2003 the UK has graded onions on this basis and marketed sweet onions [R001]. A Croatian study of shallots compared 34 accessions by pyruvate and found significant effects of harvest year, species and their interaction [R002]. The difference in pungency between Taiwan's Annan and Xiluo varieties has so far been described only in sensory terms [R004].
Definition and origin
- Pyruvate is a by-product of the alliinase reaction, formed "in equal amounts" to the flavor volatiles R001SourceMeriel G. Jones, "Knowing your Alliums", Chemistry & Industry, 24 May 2010, pp. 18–20: 「an internationally recognised system developed around the stable compound pyruvate that is formed in equal amounts to the flavour volatiles during the alliinase reaction」; trials by Warwick HRI and the University of Liverpool in the UK, supported by DEFRA, 「has led to much better market categorisation and opportunities for new market sectors including sweet – Supasweet – onions since 2003」; Cranfield University and others have also developed a pyruvate biosensorOriginal URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- The volatiles are short-lived, and human tasters cannot tell samples apart after tasting a few, so the stable pyruvate is measured instead R001SourceMeriel G. Jones, "Knowing your Alliums", Chemistry & Industry, 24 May 2010, pp. 18–20: 「an internationally recognised system developed around the stable compound pyruvate that is formed in equal amounts to the flavour volatiles during the alliinase reaction」; trials by Warwick HRI and the University of Liverpool in the UK, supported by DEFRA, 「has led to much better market categorisation and opportunities for new market sectors including sweet – Supasweet – onions since 2003」; Cranfield University and others have also developed a pyruvate biosensorOriginal URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- Method: the bulb tissue is macerated, the enzyme is allowed to react for a set time, and the amount of pyruvate formed is then measured; the literature calls this EPY (enzymatically produced pyruvate) R003SourceD. A. Kopsell, W. M. Randle, D. E. Kopsell, HortScience 37:118–121 (2002), abstract: reducing the sulfate supply 49 days before harvest 「coincided with a reduction in EPY」Original URLhttps://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_planpubs/14Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—Abstract only. EPY = enzymatically produced pyruvate.. Official record
Content
Uses
- Market grading: the UK established grading based on pyruvate and began marketing low-pungency sweet onions in 2003 R001SourceMeriel G. Jones, "Knowing your Alliums", Chemistry & Industry, 24 May 2010, pp. 18–20: 「an internationally recognised system developed around the stable compound pyruvate that is formed in equal amounts to the flavour volatiles during the alliinase reaction」; trials by Warwick HRI and the University of Liverpool in the UK, supported by DEFRA, 「has led to much better market categorisation and opportunities for new market sectors including sweet – Supasweet – onions since 2003」; Cranfield University and others have also developed a pyruvate biosensorOriginal URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- Research:
- Sulfur fertilizer trials track changes in pungency by EPY R003SourceD. A. Kopsell, W. M. Randle, D. E. Kopsell, HortScience 37:118–121 (2002), abstract: reducing the sulfate supply 49 days before harvest 「coincided with a reduction in EPY」Original URLhttps://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_planpubs/14Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—Abstract only. EPY = enzymatically produced pyruvate.. Official record
- Comparison of shallot accessions: a Croatian study compared 34 accessions by pyruvate and found that the A. cepa Aggregatum group has lower dry matter content and also lower pyruvate (pungency); two other shallots of hybrid origin (A. × cornutum and A. × proliferum) have about 25% dry matter R002SourceMajor N. et al., The Phytochemical and Nutritional Composition of Shallot Species (Allium × cornutum, Allium × proliferum and A. cepa Aggregatum) Is Genetically and Environmentally Dependent. Antioxidants 11(8):1547 (2022): the abstract says the A. cepa Aggregatum group has 「lower dry matter content and, as a result, lower pungency (measured as pyruvic acid content)」; A. × cornutum and others are 「characterized by high dry matter content (around 25%)」; 「Significant effects of the harvest year, the species and their interactions were observed」Original URLhttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9405304/Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- In the same study, harvest year, species and the interaction of the two all had significant effects on composition R002SourceMajor N. et al., The Phytochemical and Nutritional Composition of Shallot Species (Allium × cornutum, Allium × proliferum and A. cepa Aggregatum) Is Genetically and Environmentally Dependent. Antioxidants 11(8):1547 (2022): the abstract says the A. cepa Aggregatum group has 「lower dry matter content and, as a result, lower pungency (measured as pyruvic acid content)」; A. × cornutum and others are 「characterized by high dry matter content (around 25%)」; 「Significant effects of the harvest year, the species and their interactions were observed」Original URLhttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9405304/Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
The Annan and Xiluo varieties
- Official teaching materials describe the pungency of the two varieties only in sensory terms: the Annan (安南) variety is 「辛香味濃郁,較辛辣」 ("strongly aromatic and more pungent"), and the Xiluo (西螺) variety is 「辛香味較不濃郁,口感像洋蔥」 ("less strongly aromatic, tasting like onion") R004Source農業部生物多樣性研究所 [Taiwan Biodiversity Research Institute, Ministry of Agriculture],《國產農漁畜產品教材:紅蔥頭》[Teaching Materials on Domestic Agricultural, Fishery and Livestock Products: Shallots] (2024-09): Annan (Tainan local variety) 「辛香味濃郁,較辛辣」 ("strongly aromatic and more pungent"); Xiluo (Indonesian early variety) 「辛香味較不濃郁,口感像洋蔥」 ("less strongly aromatic, tasting like onion")Original URLhttps://fae.moa.gov.tw/files/topics/3008/A02_2.pdfRetrieved2026-11-02Snapshot timestamp—SourceFrom 《Teaching Materials on Domestic Agricultural, Fishery and Livestock Products: Shallots (國產農漁畜產品教材:紅蔥頭)》. Official record
- No published pyruvate measurements for the two varieties have yet been found. Unverified
See also
- AlliinaseThe first enzyme of the allium flavor system
- IsoalliinThe main flavor precursor of onions
- Lachrymatory Factor (Propanethial S-oxide)Sulfur compound that brings tears when onions are cut
- AmaryllidaceaeShallot (Allium ascalonicum)Cultivated Allium, a winter crop of the Tainan coast
Reports that mention it
Hall of the Present6.11Present conditions and institutions / Fishing and farming
Fishing and Farming on the Coast: From Sicao to Beimen
Along the coast from Tucheng to Beimen, the land by the sea has been enclosed into fish ponds and oyster racks, and the saline land is planted with shallots, garlic, carrots and melons. Township statistics of the Agriculture and Food Agency show that Annan District has ranked first in the city for shallots in most years, while cantaloupe and garlic have shrunk to a few dozen hectares over thirty years; fish ponds have shifted from shallow-pond milkfish to hard clams, polyculture and deep-water culture. There are seven fishing harbors from north to south, and in 2009 trawlers blockaded Jiangjun Fishing Harbor.