The lachrymatory factor is propanethial S-oxide, the volatile that first appears in quantity when onion-type bulbs are cut and the main source of the pungency of onions. It is produced from isoalliin in two steps by alliinase and lachrymatory factor synthase. Onions from the same field differ in strength, which also changes in storage; water, temperature and sulfur supply all affect flavor intensity.
Definition and origin
- It is the volatile that first appears in quantity after an onion is cut; the thiosulfinates and sulfides that garlic produces are produced by onion in practically no amount at all R001SourceMeriel G. Jones, "Knowing your Alliums", Chemistry & Industry, 24 May 2010, pp. 18–20: 「Surprisingly, given the chemical similarities in their flavour precursors, onion does not produce even trace amounts of the thiosulphinates and sulphides predicted from garlic. Instead, the dominant initial volatile is the eye-watering propanthial-S-oxide (lachrymatory factor, LF) that gives onions their distinctive pungency.」; LFS 「directs the decomposition of the products of the alliinase reaction, to give propanthial-S-oxide」Original URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- The lachrymatory factor is also the main source of the pungency of onions R001SourceMeriel G. Jones, "Knowing your Alliums", Chemistry & Industry, 24 May 2010, pp. 18–20: 「Surprisingly, given the chemical similarities in their flavour precursors, onion does not produce even trace amounts of the thiosulphinates and sulphides predicted from garlic. Instead, the dominant initial volatile is the eye-watering propanthial-S-oxide (lachrymatory factor, LF) that gives onions their distinctive pungency.」; LFS 「directs the decomposition of the products of the alliinase reaction, to give propanthial-S-oxide」Original URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—.
Content
Formation pathway
- Isoalliin (the precursor stored in the cells)
- → cleaved by alliinase, yielding pyruvate, ammonia and 1-propenylsulfenic acid R001SourceMeriel G. Jones, "Knowing your Alliums", Chemistry & Industry, 24 May 2010, pp. 18–20: 「Surprisingly, given the chemical similarities in their flavour precursors, onion does not produce even trace amounts of the thiosulphinates and sulphides predicted from garlic. Instead, the dominant initial volatile is the eye-watering propanthial-S-oxide (lachrymatory factor, LF) that gives onions their distinctive pungency.」; LFS 「directs the decomposition of the products of the alliinase reaction, to give propanthial-S-oxide」Original URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- → lachrymatory factor synthase converts 1-propenylsulfenic acid into propanethial S-oxide R001SourceMeriel G. Jones, "Knowing your Alliums", Chemistry & Industry, 24 May 2010, pp. 18–20: 「Surprisingly, given the chemical similarities in their flavour precursors, onion does not produce even trace amounts of the thiosulphinates and sulphides predicted from garlic. Instead, the dominant initial volatile is the eye-watering propanthial-S-oxide (lachrymatory factor, LF) that gives onions their distinctive pungency.」; LFS 「directs the decomposition of the products of the alliinase reaction, to give propanthial-S-oxide」Original URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- The lachrymatory factor itself is very short-lived and hard to analyze routinely, so the industry instead measures pyruvate, which is formed at the same time and is more stable, as an index of pungency (see "Pyruvic acid and pungency measurement") R002SourceSame as R001: 「Onion marketers knew that onions varied in strength even between bulbs from the same field and changed during storage」; the British grading system based on pyruvate has allowed low-pungency sweet onions (Supasweet) to be marketed since 2003Original URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
Variation in strength
- Onions harvested from the same field differ in strength, and their strength also changes during storage R002SourceSame as R001: 「Onion marketers knew that onions varied in strength even between bulbs from the same field and changed during storage」; the British grading system based on pyruvate has allowed low-pungency sweet onions (Supasweet) to be marketed since 2003Original URLhttps://www.liverpool.ac.uk/~sd21/onion/Know_Alliums_C&I_May10.pdfRetrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—. Official record
- Within a single cultivar, low irrigation, high temperatures during growth and development, and high sulfur fertility increase flavor intensity R003SourceW. M. Randle, Genetic and environmental effects influencing flavor in onion. Acta Horticulturae 433:299–312 (1997), abstract: within a single cultivar, low irrigation, high temperatures during growth and high sulfur fertility increase flavor intensityOriginal URLhttps://ishs.org/ishs-article/433_31/Retrieved2026-11-09Snapshot timestamp—Abstract only.. Official record
In Tucheng
The stinging in the eyes when peeling shallots, or when cutting them to fry into fried shallot crisps (油蔥酥), comes from this substance. The Annan variety of shallot is known for being "more pungent"; see Shallot (Allium ascalonicum).
See also
- Lachrymatory factor synthaseOnion enzyme that produces the lachrymatory factor
- AlliinaseThe first enzyme of the allium flavor system
- IsoalliinThe main flavor precursor of onions
- Pyruvic Acid and Pungency MeasurementMeasuring onion and shallot pungency by pyruvate
- AmaryllidaceaeShallot (Allium ascalonicum)Cultivated Allium, a winter crop of the Tainan coast
- AnthocyaninWater-soluble red-purple plant pigment
Reports that mention it
Hall of the Present6.11Present conditions and institutions / Fishing and farming
Fishing and Farming on the Coast: From Sicao to Beimen
Along the coast from Tucheng to Beimen, the land by the sea has been enclosed into fish ponds and oyster racks, and the saline land is planted with shallots, garlic, carrots and melons. Township statistics of the Agriculture and Food Agency show that Annan District has ranked first in the city for shallots in most years, while cantaloupe and garlic have shrunk to a few dozen hectares over thirty years; fish ponds have shifted from shallow-pond milkfish to hard clams, polyculture and deep-water culture. There are seven fishing harbors from north to south, and in 2009 trawlers blockaded Jiangjun Fishing Harbor.